Mini 1446, Generic Mafia (Game Over)

[JacobSavage]

Votecount 3.6

Bacde [3]

- Fegelein, T S O, Infinity 324

Palmar [2]

- Zhero, roflcopter

BeastCharizard [1]

- Palmar

roflcopter [1]

- Bacde

Infinity 324 [1]

- BeastCharizard

Not Voting [0]

-

With 8 alive, it takes

5

to lynch. The day will end in (expired on 2013-05-31 16:23:01)[/i][/area]

Mod, answer this

@Mod what happens if doc and bodyguard protect the same target which is targeted with a kill? Does the bodyguard die?

Should those roles exist, and this was to happen then the bodyguard would die.

Flavor-wise I see the doctor turning up after the kill has been performed and healing them. Whereas the Bodyguard's action happens whilst the kill is being performed. They would stop it before the doctor could save them.


EDIT: Whoop accidental page-top!

[T S O]

and it seems strange to me how palmar's role overlaps - 2 of the JOAT actions are also in the game.

[Fegelein]

What if he is X-Shot?

I assume that means BG has a higher priority protect than Doctor.

[T S O]

..does this refute Palmar's claim? cbf to check.

Feg if Infi was targeted, you should be dead. Does this mean Infi wasn't targeted?

[Fegelein]

Targetted by a kill, no. Palmar's claim is still solid in that regard.

[Infinity 324]

BF - Bulletproof.

Silly acronym. Why don't you say BP?

I dunno why you think I'm lying--everything fits except for roflcopter

Because I have a stronger townread on rofl than on palmar

i didn't *know* until palm claimed something at odds with my watch info. it could have been a doc on bacde. but i reasoned this all out in the neighbor at which you can read post game.

Wait, but I thought this meant you knew beforehand?

PEdit: Palmar is confirmed scum; bacde didn't target me since fegel would have died.

[Fegelein]

Roflcopter's posts are pretty town. Hoopla's posts read town. CES is leaning town. That said, I like my vote where it is.

Remember this?

[T S O]

Bacde has said he targeted Infi - either Infi is BP (seems OP) or Bacde's fucking with us.

[JacobSavage]

What if he is X-Shot?

I assume that means BG has a higher priority protect than Doctor.

Should either of the roles be X-Shot then they'd still lose one of their shots..

In the Doc's case he would show up but not have anyone to save.

In the Bodyguard's case he would be dead.

[T S O]

So, from what I can see, it's Palmar/Bacde scum. Let's get Bacde first.

[Fegelein]

I'm going off now. Do what you see fit Town.

[T S O]

also lol this fucking exploded with Palmar's claim.

same as feg, night guys.

[Infinity 324]

Since we know bacde is lying there's no reason to believe palmar over rofl. He isn't confirmed scum but there is little reason for bacde to lie about targeting me if rofl is scum anyway. And there's still the question of why rofl would claim as scum. So palmar is the remaining mafia.

@TSO I'm VT not BP.

[Infinity 324]

There's seriously no way that Palmar could have known that I killed ank except w/ a track so

Maybe there's 2 scum PR's. 1-shot tracker/jailkeeper/goon vs. SK vs. BG/odd-night tracker/even-night watcher/VT's seems really maf sided tho. SOMEONE HELP ME WHAT IS GOING ON

[roflcopter]

ugh i can't adequately explain all the dumb right now from my phone I'm at work til late

[Zhero]

Wow, this exploded pretty quick.

Yeah, Palmar is almost certainly mafia tracker, Even-night watcher matches the flipped odd-night tracker way better than a JOAT with a track.

One way or another, Bacde's a good lynch, since he's claimed scum and all.

VOTE: Bacde

[Infinity 324]

We should massclaim by tomorrow

I have

Palmar - JoaT
rofl - even-night watcher
Fegelein - BG
Me - VT
TSO - VT
Bacde - SK
Zhero - ??
beast - ??

I guess that's just zhero and beast then

The reason I want you to claim is if you're both VT's either this setup is really maf sided, palmar is town or he's a really lucky guesser.

[Bacde]

There's seriously no way that Palmar could have known that I killed ank except w/ a track so

Maybe there's 2 scum PR's. 1-shot tracker/jailkeeper/goon vs. SK vs. BG/odd-night tracker/even-night watcher/VT's seems really maf sided tho. SOMEONE HELP ME WHAT IS GOING ON

JoaT/Tracker/BG/VTs + SK + Maf JK/2goons

[Bacde]

there's a reason roflcopter is trying to make you feel stupid

[Infinity 324]

Is there a reason rofl-scum fakeclaimed watcher and reduced the scum pile to 3 people with only him left?

[Infinity 324]

Oh wait, this

(also palmar could successfully claim that bacde visited ank because he knew bacde was sk as soon as the kill on him didn't go through)

Bacde could have been doc protected, but a successful guess seems more likely now.

[Palmar]

oh well roflcopter is lying.

feel free to lynch me to confirm that.

[Palmar]

VOTE: roflcopter

[beastcharizard]

I am a vanilla townie.

After we lynch bacde what are we doing? I don't think the night results matter since the mafia could just not kill and frame the other one and what not.

[Infinity 324]

Lynch palmar? There is absolutely zero reason for Rofl to fakeclaim at this point; it's an autoloss for scum.