In post 78, Ravenpaw wrote:Grimgroove is a bit iffy to me. (...) but the fact he said he checked the old game but was proven that he didn't really does seem a wee bit suspect to me.
You make it sound as if I didn't check the old game. Why?
Because apparently you only looked at my last few posts (which would've been post-game comments, not actual game play).
Also, this is why I feel so iffy about it:
In post 26, Grimgroove wrote:I can't see this anywhere, neither here or in the "title pending"-game.
That above sentence is troubling me because of the word "anywhere". You implied doing a thorough search when you said that, but your later story of only looking at my last few posts doesn't correlate with that.
It's a fair argument, but when it comes to that "case" I feel I've already told you everything I could tell you about it in post 65. I didn't mean to make said implication, but understand why it would come off that way. But let's say I did mean to imply it. What reasonable tactic do you see behind it that is scummy? And by reasonable I mean: a tactic that has even the slightest chance of succeeding?
Okay fair enough, I guess it just felt opportunistic.
@Mod, requesting prod/replacement on shaboostein, whichever you deem appropriate
In the timeless words of a great and revered man: "Blow it out your ass."
A hydra of Rift Adrift, Oil Tycoons and Trust Fund. "In the Oil Rift we Trust."
@Ravenpaw, just read both in ISO. Grim feels pretty town to me like last game. Crand is null leaning scum, with the lean because of three reasons:
1) Voted Raven and then tried to pass it off as RVS
2) Says he misunderstood RVS, even though it would seem hard to misunderstand that the RVS stage had ended
3) Votes Grim in a bit of OMGUS, semi-weak case but it could be for reactions (Grims case against Crand wasn't too strong after all)
In post 128, LnGrrrR wrote:@Ravenpaw, just read both in ISO. Grim feels pretty town to me like last game. Crand is null leaning scum, with the lean because of three reasons:
1) Voted Raven and then tried to pass it off as RVS
2) Says he misunderstood RVS, even though it would seem hard to misunderstand that the RVS stage had ended
3) Votes Grim in a bit of OMGUS, semi-weak case but it could be for reactions (Grims case against Crand wasn't too strong after all)
I just have a problem with these reasons.
1) It was an RVS. It was my first post.
2) I don't remember saying that. RVS stage had not ended IMO especially if you read what was posted before me.
3) Only one I feel as scum as of right now. I need to do a careful re-read of the thread though I've been pretty swamped with work and lack of Shaboo/Rach lowers my motivation to play considerably.
In post 131, Crandaja wrote:
I just have a problem with these reasons.
1) It was an RVS. It was my first post.
2) I don't remember saying that. RVS stage had not ended IMO especially if you read what was posted before me.
3) Only one I feel as scum as of right now. I need to do a careful re-read of the thread though I've been pretty swamped with work and lack of Shaboo/Rach lowers my motivation to play considerably.
And yes I am being defensive.
1) Sorry, read that wrong. For some reason I read your unvote as a vote.
2) Due to my dumbness re point 1, ignore point 2.
3) Still OMGUS.
Ok given the above, Crand swings back to neutral. Crand thanks for fixing my misrep.
I am here... I wanted a response from Shaboo but looks like hes flaked instead of lurking so will ISO and see what else there is. See if we can get this game moving forward.
Rach, can you share with us some of your reads in this game so far? What do you think on Syryana? What do you think on Grim? Cand? Crand? It seems to me you're not enough involved in this game. Now, I know I didn't say much either, but at least I specified some of my feelings about other players.
Cran,
I think Candillan leans town. His posts seems like he's trying to scumhunt and I have a good feeling about him. Grim and Syryana - as I said earlier I have a feeling they are scum, but after some more posts from them I'm not so sure about that anymore. I don't have a read on you yet, and I do want to know what do you think about these players.
Ravenpaw, why did you unvote Cran?
All the rest - if you don't start posting (and by "posting" I mean "posts with some content"), I'm afraid I'll have to switch my vote to one of you. Right now a wagon on shaboo seems useless cause he has a good chance to be replaced (I think), so I'll have to target another silent player.
Grim I still get a bad feeling from. His deduction seems to be erratic and a lot different from last game. I don't really get what he's trying to do. The only thing I see from Syryana is his case against me (hence his vote) and while I don't agree with it I get what he's trying to do so I don't have a great read on him. Slight town but not enough information to say for sure.
[quote="In post 138, Ravenpaw"]But Grim was scum last time.[/quite]
Yes, but he sounded very townie last game. Everyone pretty much thought he was town. (And it likely would've come back to bite him, as people would've wondered why he wasn't getting NK'd.
Yes, but he sounded very townie last game. Everyone pretty much thought he was town. (And it likely would've come back to bite him, as people would've wondered why he wasn't getting NK'd.
This post's logic doesn't make sense. He was scum last game, and because he's acting the same way this time, he's town? That makes zero sense.
In post 140, Crandaja wrote:The only thing I see from Syryana is his case against me (hence his vote) and while I don't agree with it I get what he's trying to do so I don't have a great read on him.
What are you trying to say here? What am I trying to do?
I was going to mention how weird #141 was, but Cand beat me to it.
In the timeless words of a great and revered man: "Blow it out your ass."
A hydra of Rift Adrift, Oil Tycoons and Trust Fund. "In the Oil Rift we Trust."
@Mod, requesting prod/replacement on shaboostein, whichever you deem appropriate
I do not know his role because I wasn't updated with the alignments for the new game. As a result, I can't look for a replacement yet. I'll prod him instead.
"I give up on trying to read you. You're unimaginably scummy, with a dose of ultra-Town thrown in for spice."
In the timeless words of a great and revered man: "Blow it out your ass."
A hydra of Rift Adrift, Oil Tycoons and Trust Fund. "In the Oil Rift we Trust."
In post 140, Crandaja wrote:The only thing I see from Syryana is his case against me (hence his vote) and while I don't agree with it I get what he's trying to do so I don't have a great read on him.
What are you trying to say here? What am I trying to do?
I was going to mention how weird #141 was, but Cand beat me to it.
Sorry the wording was pretty bad. What I meant was I get why you would think I was scum based on my defensive stance. Although I'm town I understand why you would vote me. I haven't really done a great job of winning you over thus far.
Yes, but he sounded very townie last game. Everyone pretty much thought he was town. (And it likely would've come back to bite him, as people would've wondered why he wasn't getting NK'd.
This post's logic doesn't make sense. He was scum last game, and because he's acting the same way this time, he's town? That makes zero sense.
He was acting town last game. Did anyone think he was scum last game? No, because he acted town. He is acting town here so I give him townie points. Should I only give him town points if he acts scummy?
