Newbie 1368 - Will there ever be a title? (GAME OVER)

[RachMarie]

I thought you were serious

Then I remembered this is a newbie game... duh After I posted

So tired .... Cant wait til I get a hearing aid and my new computer.

[Edosurist]

VC 1.13

LnGrrrR (5): Candillan, Grimgroove, Syryana, RachMarie, imkingdavid

Syryana

(1): mothrax

Not voting

: Core_H86, LnGrrrR, homertve

LnGrrrR,

townsperson

, has been lynched Day 1!


Night 1 ends in

(expired on 2013-06-11 22:45:00)

.

I will also update the first post during the night phase.

[Edosurist]

Candillan,

Town Doctor

, has been found dead Night 1.

With 7 alive, it takes 4 to lynch.

Day 2 ends in

(expired on 2013-07-03 12:45:00)

[homertve]

Well, that's too bad. I had a feeling that Candy-Land is town.

I think I'll go with my instincts this time.

VOTE: Syryana

[Candillan]

Bah! Good luck, town!

[Grimgroove]

@Syryana: you never answered this:

No big deal, but for the record, the last quote in your post (#289) you have attributed to yourself, when I actually said it.

I'm not interested in credit. Stuff happened, Grim townread resulted.

While walking I was suddenly reminded of this bit. (yes, I sometimes think about you guys when I'm walking, scary stuff come to think of it)

Why did the fact that the scumslip you thought you saw me make was no scumslip at all, automatically (?) result in a townread on me? Why couldn't I be scum who simply didn't slip?

[RachMarie]

Time for me to do some VCA...

(VCA is vote count analysis)

[LnGrrrR]

Bah. Told you I was town Candi! I'll buy the first round

[Core_H86]

ok now that we're here how was that a good end to day 1? what makes it so bad to have a no lynch?

[imkingdavid]

ok now that we're here how was that a good end to day 1? what makes it so bad to have a no lynch?

No lynch = Free night kill for scum with no information gained. We'd basically be in the same position as we were at the end of day 1, except with one less person.

Instead, we have information about LnG's role and can read through the past day with that information in mind, keeping in mind player interactions.

[imkingdavid]

As a side note, I will be starting a new full time job tomorrow so I will really only be available during evenings/nights/weekends and lunch break (on my phone). If this becomes a problem, I will replace out, but I don't foresee it becoming a big issue.

[Grimgroove]

ok now that we're here how was that a good end to day 1? what makes it so bad to have a no lynch?

I don't like this post at all. Productivity zero.

VOTE: Core_H86

[Grimgroove]

Even if I would have been there for the end of the first daystage I'm pretty sure I would have left my vote where it was.

Still some question marks around RachMarie and imkingdavid.

But despite that I'm not liking the posts between 614 and 618. I of course don't know your schedules, but whereas post 614 left some room for a few hours and for Homer and LnG to move their vote to Syryana, vote 616, only less than ten minutes later, already moves to an LnGrrrR lynch with surprisingly little resistance.

If imkingdavid is scum it will be difficult to pin this lynch on him as circumstances were definitely in his favor in case he is (by circumstances: lack of agreement and LnGrrrR's scummy behavior), but I find the 7-minute-shift a bad sign nonetheless.

[RachMarie]

david is right there are very few circumstances where a NL is a good idea (for example in MYLO which stands for Mislynch and Lose you do want to NL most times,) but generally it is best to lynch even if you are not sure before deadline. Most definitely not on day 1 though.

Grim some sites do push for a NL on Day 1 and are far more reliant on PRs than we are here. They often move a lot faster too. So I have seen that should we NL question in many games and its a newb tell and rather null on alignment.

[Grimgroove]

I don't necessarily have a problem with someone wanting a No Lynch on D1, but I don't like the way Core_H86 is rubbing our nose in the mislynch after the fact. It feels scummy to me, washing his hands in innocence and hoping we'll sort it out amongst ourselves (those on the wagon).

Questions for Core_H86: What would be your preferred course of action now? A lynch? On who? Why? What are your reads? And if you would like a lynch: why a lynch now and not in the previous stage? What do you feel you have learned from what happened so far that makes you feel more confident in lynching someone now, as opposed to D1?
And if you wouldn't like a lynch: How do you expect to move forward?

[RachMarie]

ahh ok now I understand what you meant.

Just as IC I do have to make sure I am doing my job as well as my role. You would be surprised by how many games it comes up.

[mothrax]

Well, that's too bad. I had a feeling that Candy-Land is town.

I think I'll go with my instincts this time.

VOTE: Syryana

I don't like this post... It's bad form to woe is me the night kill...

I still dont like Syrana.

[homertve]

bad form to what?

[Syryana]

Catching up tomorrow.

[mothrax]

Bad form to bemoan the night kill.

[imkingdavid]

Sorry haven't had a chance to respond. Will do tomorrow.

[Grimgroove]

This game has slowed down again. What happen?

[Grimgroove]

Time for me to do some VCA...

(VCA is vote count analysis)

Eagerly awaiting that.

[Grimgroove]

[Syryana]

Hey Grim. Wassup?