Mini 1467 - Arkham Horror Smalltown II - Game Over

[PhDScar]

Exactly our point, you responded by switching it off because you knew you were busted.

Psst I'm still voting you. I didn't switch it off and I'm not "busted" for anything. I like my vote on you a lot. You are coming off less and less as unhelpful town and more and more like scum just spouting BS.

Symph is town, move your vote to a better place like ours is Dry-Fit.

Also nice slip, thank you DTM for pointing this out I missed it the first time around.

[DTMaster]

@pHD
1. Not quite a slip. Reread BB. The timing is right (after Dry-fit votes Symph) and reads as a multi post stream of concisousness post. See the triple post and comments - BB's clarification is actually solid with context looked at.

[Radioactive Wolf]

Alright, I have to do a reset here since Blue Bonnet is clearly town. Let me take a moment to forget all my reads so far...

[PhDScar]

@pHD
1. Not quite a slip. Reread BB. The timing is right (after Dry-fit votes Symph) and reads as a multi post stream of concisousness post. See the triple post and comments - BB's clarification is actually solid with context looked at.

Yeah I see it.
@BB I apologize.

[PhDScar]

Radioactive wolf, Sajin and BB, what is with people in this game declaring someone is scum or town but not actually backing it up?

[Radioactive Wolf]

Alright, this is harder than I thought it was going to be...

Let's just go down the playerlist:

1. Lady Lambdadelta -- Michael McGlen, the Gangster
One of the players I can't read for shit is up first... great...
Well, she did put a lot of effort into the case on me and she seems genuinely annoyed at me. None of that is alignment indicative, though. Also don't like the fact that she made a point against Symphony and then quickly abandoned it after hito and I didn't bite.
Null

2. PhDScar -- Roland Banks, the Fed
Seems alright, and I don't like his wagon. The reasoning behind it seems really tenuous, so...
tentative town

3. Symphony * -- Charlie Kane, the Politician
Not much to go on here. Commentary seems to be very limited to hito's slot; possibly newbtown, but I'm not rushing to judgment yet.
Null

4. Sajin -- Darrell Simmons, the Photographer
Actually, he seems alright. I don't like his verbose style, but I really can't justify keeping my vote on him.
Null-townish

5. shaboostein -- Bob Jenkins, the Salesman
Null
Yeah, there's really not much to be said here. It seems like he spends a lot of his posts defending his playstyle. ...and people think

I'm

unproductive?

6. inte -- "Ashcan" Pete, the Drifter
Eh; not as town as I thought before I looked at his iso.
Meh
Null

7. hitogoroshi -- Dexter Drake, the Magician
A lot more active lurkish than I remember before I read the iso...
What's your deal?...
Null-scum

8. Toogeloo -- Jacqueline Fine, the Psychic

[Radioactive Wolf]

8. Toogeloo -- Jacqueline Fine, the Psychic
Commentary seems limited to DrScar and Kanye. I didn't like the way he went after inte for being a "troll" (makes me think he's going after an easy target) and I don't like his participation in the DrScar wagon.
Null-scum

9. kanyeknowsbest -- Diana Stanley, the Redeemed Cultist
I tend to think that stream-of-consciousness posting like this is more characteristic of town.
Null-townish

10. DTMaster * -- Vincent Lee, the Doctor
Solid null
He hasn't said anything unreasonable, but this text wall posting style is very easy for scum to hide behind.
You are going to be a nightmare to read, my friend...

11. Dry-fit -- Joe Diamond, the Private Eye
Posting is sparse, but I don't like the symphony vote.
Null-scum

13. Blue Bonnet (a hydra of fuzzybutternut and notscience) -- "Skids" O'Toole, the Bootlegger
If he's scum, he wins the Oscar for best actor...ever.
Town

[Radioactive Wolf]

UNVOTE:

I have to think about where my vote's going to go ....

[Magua]

Vote Count 1.6

With 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynch.

PhDScar (2): inte, Toogeloo
Sajin (2): hitogoroshi, DTMaster
Symphony (1): Dry-fit
inte (1): kanyeknowsbest
hitogoroshi (1): Sajin
DTMaster (1): Blue Bonnet
Blue Bonnet (1): PhDScar
kanyeknowsbest (1): Lady Lambdadelta

Not Voting (3): Symphony, shaboostein, Radioactive Wolf

Deadline is July 12th, 2013, at 2:00am EST (site time).
Countdown to deadline:

(expired on 2013-07-12 01:00:00)

[DTMaster]

@Wolf
1. Lol I have good points but walls are hard. However I won't apologize for commenting on what I want to comment on since I clearly lay out my thought process. :deal with it:

2. I find it odd you say I'm being reasonable but if you actually have been reading I'm making a Sajin case right now about his questioning about anti town roles as alignment. You have a town read on him. But I'm reasonable. Elaborate.
I should be wrong here but some how you have contrary opinions about my line of thoughts.

If you weren't confirmed Id vote you so I'm curious to the town read.

[Blue Bonnet]

@pHD
1. Not quite a slip. Reread BB. The timing is right (after Dry-fit votes Symph) and reads as a multi post stream of concisousness post. See the triple post and comments - BB's clarification is actually solid with context looked at.

Yeah I see it.
@BB I apologize.

No worries, Brethren.
All's fair in love, war, and mafia.

~Smokey the Bear~

[Blue Bonnet]

Radioactive wolf, Sajin and BB, what is with people in this game declaring someone is scum or town but not actually backing it up?

Check my main accounts meta.
I do it all the time.

~Master Chief~

[Toogeloo]

Commentary seems limited to DrScar and Kanye

Not a lot really going on that I feel I need to comment on that hasn't already been said by someone else. I'm keeping a few notes on certain comments, but I generally only mention something if I want to talk about it since I don't typically make conversation just to make conversation. And let's be honest here, the only reason I talked about kanye is because hito asked me my stance on him.

I currently have a couple people I like and a couple I don't like, all of which I have listed in the topic. We are on page 8, so I'm not entirely sure how many people you feel I should be focused on at this point.

I didn't like the way he went after inte for being a "troll" (makes me think he's going after an easy target)

It was an RVS. I unvoted inte and said I currently liked him as soon as I found a real target. I never "didn't like," inte really.

I'm gonna be V/LA until friday with the holiday.

[inte]

limited access for a few days

[Blue Bonnet]

Everyone goes V/LA!
>.>

~The Incredible Hunk~

[Dry-fit]

11. Dry-fit -- Joe Diamond, the Private Eye
Posting is sparse, but I don't like the symphony vote.
Null-scum

What's wrong with a symphony vote?

Symphony thinking jeremy was scummy because a vote would potentially be left on a town player is awful reasoning. But what's worse is removing the vote and not giving any other reads. Symphony looks like scum who doesn't know how to make a case.

[Blue Bonnet]

Symphony looks like

newbtown

who doesn't know how to make a case.

FTFY

Symph is town, move your vote somewhere useful.

[Dry-fit]

Symphony looks like

newbtown

who doesn't know how to make a case.

FTFY

Symph is town, move your vote somewhere useful.

I think it's newb scum more often than newb town that has trouble giving reads and making cases.

I just looked at Symphony's one completed game though and she did basically the same exact thing there as town <.<

Unvote.

I need to reevaluate.

[Blue Bonnet]

Symphony looks like

newbtown

who doesn't know how to make a case.

FTFY

Symph is town, move your vote somewhere useful.

I think it's newb scum more often than newb town that has trouble giving reads and making cases.

I just looked at Symphony's one completed game though and she did basically the same exact thing there as town <.<

Unvote.

I need to reevaluate.

Sheep the Bonnet and be forever merry.

~St. Nicholas~

[hitogoroshi]

@pHD
1. Not quite a slip. Reread BB. The timing is right (after Dry-fit votes Symph) and reads as a multi post stream of concisousness post. See the triple post and comments - BB's clarification is actually solid with context looked at.

Yeah I see it.
@BB I apologize.

Okay, you 'apologize'...but you're still voting BB. What's the dilly bar here PhD? Is BB scum?

Bonnet's probably town, even if they do the passive agressive "noted" thing that makes my lynchin' hand all trembly. Unconcerned with other people's opinion, but willing to accept an apology, marks self-interested town more than it does prickly scum. DTM's town for 184. I wanna say Kanye too but to be honest that's mostly a tone thing and I got no clue if he keeps the same tone as scum.

Sajin, what's the most compelling reason that I'm scum?

[PhDScar]

@pHD
1. Not quite a slip. Reread BB. The timing is right (after Dry-fit votes Symph) and reads as a multi post stream of concisousness post. See the triple post and comments - BB's clarification is actually solid with context looked at.

Yeah I see it.
@BB I apologize.

Okay, you 'apologize'...but you're still voting BB. What's the dilly bar here PhD? Is BB scum?

Bonnet's probably town, even if they do the passive agressive "noted" thing that makes my lynchin' hand all trembly. Unconcerned with other people's opinion, but willing to accept an apology, marks self-interested town more than it does prickly scum. DTM's town for 184. I wanna say Kanye too but to be honest that's mostly a tone thing and I got no clue if he keeps the same tone as scum.

Sajin, what's the most compelling reason that I'm scum?

I kept my vote hoping he would eventually speak his mind and tell me what he has on DTM but that clearly isn't working. So now I just have it there because I've got nowhere better to put it. With the fact it takes 7 to lynch my one vote is not putting him at risk.

[hitogoroshi]

I kept my vote hoping he would eventually speak his mind and tell me what he has on DTM but that clearly isn't working. So now I just have it there because I've got nowhere better to put it. With the fact it takes 7 to lynch my one vote is not putting him at risk.

Vote somebody else in your next post, or sell me on BB being scum.

[Blue Bonnet]

@pHD
1. Not quite a slip. Reread BB. The timing is right (after Dry-fit votes Symph) and reads as a multi post stream of concisousness post. See the triple post and comments - BB's clarification is actually solid with context looked at.

Yeah I see it.
@BB I apologize.

Okay, you 'apologize'...but you're still voting BB. What's the dilly bar here PhD?

Is BB scum

?

Bonnet's probably town, even if they do the passive agressive "noted" thing that makes my lynchin' hand all trembly. Unconcerned with other people's opinion, but willing to accept an apology, marks self-interested town more than it does prickly scum. DTM's town for 184. I wanna say Kanye too but to be honest that's mostly a tone thing and I got no clue if he keeps the same tone as scum.

Sajin, what's the most compelling reason that I'm scum?

I can answer that!!!!
No.

~Tom Marvolo Riddle~

[Lady Lambdadelta]

@pHD
1. Not quite a slip. Reread BB. The timing is right (after Dry-fit votes Symph) and reads as a multi post stream of concisousness post. See the triple post and comments - BB's clarification is actually solid with context looked at.

Yeah I see it.
@BB I apologize.

Okay, you 'apologize'...but you're still voting BB. What's the dilly bar here PhD? Is BB scum?

Bonnet's probably town, even if they do the passive agressive "noted" thing that makes my lynchin' hand all trembly. Unconcerned with other people's opinion, but willing to accept an apology, marks self-interested town more than it does prickly scum. DTM's town for 184. I wanna say Kanye too but to be honest that's mostly a tone thing and I got no clue if he keeps the same tone as scum.

Sajin, what's the most compelling reason that I'm scum?

I kept my vote hoping he would eventually speak his mind and tell me what he has on DTM but that clearly isn't working. So now I just have it there because I've got nowhere better to put it. With the fact it takes 7 to lynch my one vote is not putting him at risk.

Vote: PhD

No.

[PhDScar]

UNVOTE

VOTE: Hito
Don't tell me what to do with my vote.
UNVOTE: Hito

VOTE: Shaboostein
He has made only three posts since the game started (not counting RVS) and I don't really like any of them.

Sorry for the absence. Freak internet problems.

On the topic of Hito's slot, and jeremylu's V/LA; it is a null tell for me.

UNVOTE: hitogoroshi

Im taking my vote off of hito for now, so that I can watch and see what else is going on.
My vote on jeremylu wasn't very solid before, they were just the most suspicious in my eyes.

Your last sentence looks like you're conceding under pressure and then trying to explain yourself with pretty obvious reasoning. Makes me feel weird.

Oh, don't worry about it.

My vote bores me and I don't like it anymore...
UNVOTE:
VOTE: Sajin

Cause reasoning is so 2012...

PhD's vote and response to my query is total BS. His post was completely null, and you are trying to back up both sides of your vote. Vote him because you think think it's a scum gambit, but also because you hope it gets him replaced? Really? So now that he's replaced what's your read on the "gambit?"

^ This

and

UNVOTE

Not a single original or detailed thought in this post. It seems like it's trying to look like scum hunting but without any actually effort or risk in it. He's just going with what most people were saying at the time of the post.

shaboo why didn't you place a vote on phd


Because I don't think he has scum intent, especially if all he wanted to do in relation to jeremylu is get him replaced.

I don't like how inte is pressuring for the phD wagon, looks scummy. And people seem to jump on the fact that I say something looks weird and don't immediately throw my vote at it. I like to be more convinced of someone's guiltiness before voting. Im not the kind to go reaction-testing with votes.

Then these two posts happen. 1 It seems like in all of these posts he has three different onions on me all of which seem to change based on the great view of me. 2 He dedicates more time to defending his play style than scum hunting. 3 The way he going about his play style just comes off as mudslinging and setting up for a way for him to easily hop on to a wagon that might appear.
I would hope he'd post more so I could get a better read on him but it appears he has despaired. Same goes for Symphony could you guys post more?