Mini 1467 - Arkham Horror Smalltown II - Game Over

[Blue Bonnet]

^Furthering my idea that PhD is scum.
Just Saiyan.

~Goku~

[Lady Lambdadelta]

I hate to agree with this fucking Hudra, but can we just give PhD the rope?

He's asking for it, and I need blood for the blood god.

[Magua]

Vote Count 1.7

With 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynch.

PhDScar (3): inte, Toogeloo, Lady Lambdadelta
Sajin (2): hitogoroshi, DTMaster
inte (1): kanyeknowsbest
hitogoroshi (1): Sajin
DTMaster (1): Blue Bonnet
shaboostein (1): PhDScar

Not Voting (4): Symphony, shaboostein, Radioactive Wolf, Dry-fit

Deadline is July 12th, 2013, at 2:00am EST (site time).
Countdown to deadline:

(expired on 2013-07-12 01:00:00)

[Radioactive Wolf]

Jeez, you managed to vaporize your townread in only 2 posts, Dr Scar...

[Radioactive Wolf]

11. Dry-fit -- Joe Diamond, the Private Eye
Posting is sparse, but I don't like the symphony vote.
Null-scum

What's wrong with a symphony vote?

Symphony thinking jeremy was scummy because a vote would potentially be left on a town player is awful reasoning. But what's worse is removing the vote and not giving any other reads. Symphony looks like scum who doesn't know how to make a case.

Symphony looks like

newbtown

who doesn't know how to make a case.

FTFY

Symph is town, move your vote somewhere useful.

I think it's newb scum more often than newb town that has trouble giving reads and making cases.

I just looked at Symphony's one completed game though and she did basically the same exact thing there as town <.<

Unvote.

I need to reevaluate.

Quoted for hypocrisy

[hitogoroshi]

I hate to agree with this fucking Hudra, but can we just give PhD the rope?

He's asking for it, and I need blood for the blood god.

195 was an awful post. But 199 was the town answer of the thing I set up. Scum would have been more likely to find a reason to defend their BB vote or joke with me or find some reason not to swap instead of just falling in to line. In general I find scum players far less likely to listen to flat ultimatums from unconfirmeds than town players. I'm thinkin 195 is just a factor of two-month-old account more than scum PM.

Radioactive Wolf: How in the world is that hypocrisy? He said "I think this is a factor of scum motivations" and then later "well, I just saw evidence that she did this when she had town motivations; I need to reevaluate." I think he was pretty explicit about what caused his change in view.

[Radioactive Wolf]

@Wolf
1. Lol I have good points but walls are hard. However I won't apologize for commenting on what I want to comment on since I clearly lay out my thought process. :deal with it:

2. I find it odd you say I'm being reasonable but if you actually have been reading I'm making a Sajin case right now about his questioning about anti town roles as alignment. You have a town read on him. But I'm reasonable. Elaborate.
I should be wrong here but some how you have contrary opinions about my line of thoughts.

If you weren't confirmed Id vote you so I'm curious to the town read.

Just because I disagree with something doesn't mean I don't think it's conceivably reasonable. I don't have empathy problems...

[kanyeknowsbest]

restricted to phone access til the 7th

btw dtm is town and hito is still too.

[Lady Lambdadelta]

You don't think a 2 month old account would fold under pressure and swap their vote, Hito?

The "new and bad" argument works both ways.

[hitogoroshi]

You don't think a 2 month old account would fold under pressure and swap their vote, Hito?

The "new and bad" argument works both ways.

In general my experience with newer scum players is that they're so scared of being suspected for any reason - because maybe they've been "caught" - that they'll fight to explain anything they've done as actually a townie move. Putting a vote in play in response to my ultimatum is an implicit admission that his previous position was bad times. I wouldn't expect newbie scum to just give up that ground - I was watching for scum-PhD to say "No you see, my vote being on BB is GOOD, because..."

Granted, I haven't played a newbie in years - I know it's a good thing to do in terms of the health of the site, but I can't stand newbie games. So maybe my knowledge of newbscum is dated.

[Blue Bonnet]

Welp.

VOTE: PhD (Dr. Scum from here on out).

Was gonna keep our vote on DT, but we'll come back to that later.

Lady, might I say that you have an impeccable sense of right and wrong. I do admire that. :3

~Dr. Frankenstein~

[hitogoroshi]

Hey Bonnet. I know you don't like to sign posts but indulge me and let me know if 200 and 210 were the same person or not.

[Blue Bonnet]

Yes, they were, in fact. ^.^

[Blue Bonnet]

~Doctor Octopus~

[Lady Lambdadelta]

Hito, if you didn't catch on, one half is signing their posts one half isn't. So we can tell who is who but not who they are.

[PhDScar]

Hito, if you didn't catch on, one half is signing their posts one half isn't. So we can tell who is who but not who they are.

Nope they were both signed but were not the same person.

[Blue Bonnet]

I occasionally forget to sign my posts

But don't worry, I like to do it

and it was my idea :>

~Lorenzo von Matterhorn

[Symphony]

Then these two posts happen. 1 It seems like in all of these posts he has three different onions on me all of which seem to change based on the great view of me. 2 He dedicates more time to defending his play style than scum hunting. 3 The way he going about his play style just comes off as mudslinging and setting up for a way for him to easily hop on to a wagon that might appear.
I would hope he'd post more so I could get a better read on him but it appears he has despaired. Same goes for Symphony could you guys post more?

Ogres are like onions.

[shaboostein]

[PhDScar]

Then these two posts happen. 1 It seems like in all of these posts he has three different onions on me all of which seem to change based on the great view of me. 2 He dedicates more time to defending his play style than scum hunting. 3 The way he going about his play style just comes off as mudslinging and setting up for a way for him to easily hop on to a wagon that might appear.
I would hope he'd post more so I could get a better read on him but it appears he has despaired. Same goes for Symphony could you guys post more?

Ogres are like onions.

[Symphony]

My apologies about the lack of posts, I had almost forgotten that I was in this game. (bad player)

^Furthering my idea that PhD is scum.
Just Saiyan.
~Goku~

I laughed way to hard at this.

Its a little late now, but I will take another look in the morning and will try to post more often.

[inte]

@pHD
1. Not quite a slip. Reread BB. The timing is right (after Dry-fit votes Symph) and reads as a multi post stream of concisousness post. See the triple post and comments - BB's clarification is actually solid with context looked at.

Yeah I see it.
@BB I apologize.

Okay, you 'apologize'...but you're still voting BB. What's the dilly bar here PhD? Is BB scum?

Bonnet's probably town, even if they do the passive agressive "noted" thing that makes my lynchin' hand all trembly. Unconcerned with other people's opinion, but willing to accept an apology, marks self-interested town more than it does prickly scum. DTM's town for 184. I wanna say Kanye too but to be honest that's mostly a tone thing and I got no clue if he keeps the same tone as scum.

Sajin, what's the most compelling reason that I'm scum?

I kept my vote hoping he would eventually speak his mind and tell me what he has on DTM but that clearly isn't working. So now I just have it there because I've got nowhere better to put it. With the fact it takes 7 to lynch my one vote is not putting him at risk.

what a post

[Blue Bonnet]

Except Symph.

Symph is town.

~Buzz Lightyear~

[Blue Bonnet]

To clarify the above

Lucky is everywhere

DTM is everywhere

I'll secks for an extra vote so we can vote both and kill both

That is all

~Buzz

[DTMaster]

@Wolf
1. Wat. Why Sajin town? It's a town read on your end, why aren't you discouraging me from attacking a town read?

@Symphony
1. This post here. You ignored it. Why?

@LLD
1. Dude why are you making an age argument for a Symphony meta read. A 2 month old account has nothing to do with folding under pressure. My first game (under 2 months) I super tunneled an anti-town townie and convinced the IC to not lynch the scum (effectively making scum win in my first game as townie). Why are you posting fluff? You're better than this. LLD is up for wildcard mastermind scum (a la principle of the IC scum - questioning with fluff, but not catching scum with actions).

@Shaboo
1. Answer my post here for reference. Why did you agree with Tooge on a scum read on pHD when right after you called him null for wanting a replacement on the Jeremylu slot. Considering you had time to post an emoticon but

not respond to my attack on you

.

Unvote, Vote Shaboo

.

@Sajin
Do not ignore my questions - but you haven't posted yet. This serves as a reminder to refer back to this post.

Revising my original read on pHD. He's been asking why but no one has been answering. Null-frustrated townie read.