Kelly Chen wrote:It's true that Twito was late on LG, but reading his posts I am inclined to believe that Twito was just being a good townie. Notice that he didn't just hop onto LG, there was clear reason that made him confident about it.
There should be more votes on theopor_COD.
Let me do a post by post recap...
Jan 29:
Hello everyone.
Interesting start.
Feb 1:
Kelly Chen wrote:Question for: theopor_COD
What did you find interesting about this game's start?
Just seems to have provoked plenty of reaction early. Looking at other games this one seems to be lively.
Note lack of content. Note several days' separation.
Feb 8:
Good night on the whole only one down, no serial.
First of all I'm amazed Livingod was a Godfather, complete shambles from his point of view, I'd also be inclined to think a few of his buddies gave him up and jumped on the lynch, just to make themselves look slightly more innocent. However I also think some of those not voting him look pretty sus aswell.
Having looked at the previous day's voting Rand Althor, Scotmany, Phita and Battle Mage worry me the most.
This post from Scot one reason why
Right now, the only vote that I am even considering is the one that my gut is telling me. Even though I know that you will all most likely attack me for this vote simply because I have a gut feeling, I feel it is the right thing to do.
Vote: Twito
I guess I just don't trust you.
However, if more information comes of on livingod being scum, then I am willing to switch.
Just seems like he knows Livingod is scum and votes Twito (due to his gut feeling) but also uses the old willing to switch line if it appears Living appears doomed. As such Vote Scotmany12
Note 1. noting town's good luck, 2. setup speculation (no SK), 3. wishy washy paragraph of suspicions before getting down to it (these are basic scumtells related to looking for stuff to post without actually helping the town or making commitments).
I admit I did #1 myself.
In my humble opinion this case against Scotmany sucks, although it doesn't necessarily mean theopor_COD is scummy. "I'm willing to switch" strikes me more as something that would be said by scum looking to move
to a townie
, not fellow scum. I'd expect scum looking to switch to scum to say "I do think LG is fairly scummy" not "I need to see the case," since this latter just invites more discussion on LG.
Also, there's nothing wrong with voting on gut; his Twito vote certainly wasn't out of nowhere (look at his earlier posts); and so it seems to me unnecessary to look at this Twito vote as a move to save LG or whatever might supposedly help scum.
Feb 8 (response to me saying he was suspicious for not posting day 1):
Apologies for not being much help for the first few days, one I can't get on every day, two the speed of the lynch was quicker than lightning, the guy didn't even have the chance to offer a claim.
making excuses
Feb 8:
Unvote, Vote Battle Mage
If he's not mafia then I think Cheesefan and Kaleidoscope most definately are.
WTF is this???? This is why I first voted theopor_COD, what is this stuff here --^^^ ??
He was also asked about this by Cheesefan, and he hasn't answered.
As before, I find the above scummy because Battle Mage was one of theopor_COD's suspects. And if Cheesefan and Kaleidoscope's pursuit seems scummy to theopor_COD, why in the hell would he want to go along with them?
My theory is that theopor_COD wanted to gently hop from Scotmany to (the more popular) Battle Mage and felt he needed to say something while doing so. What a sneaky guy eh!
Feb 8:
Rand Althor wrote:Well BM deffently deserves a fos:BM, theopor_COD can you give a reason why I worry you?
Just the vote for Riverwind on page five, sometime after the no lynch discussion had expired.
Mind I worry myself most of the time.
As for Scott I think your half hearted vote for Twito same page and then the I'll vote for Livingod if it becomes evident he's for the lynch quote.
Possible scumminess in seeming to undermine his own suggestion that RA was scummy (e.g. "You just worry me because of something that sounds lame now that I say it out loud, and hey I worry myself LOL").
Feb 10:
Scotmany wrote:Um, I honestly had no idea whether or not Livingod was scum or not. I would really like to here why you think I knew that livingod was scum.
Just a gut instinct I guess, your post reeks of wanting to vote Livingod but not because he's your Godfather.
Feb 10:
Scotmany wrote:So as i see it theoper. You are voting for me because of my gut instinct on twito. However, you are voting off of a gut instinct too. Hypocritical, are we?
I wasn't the one who made out I was voting someone on a gut instinct, but would happily jump to another if he looked like being lynched.
I find this response awfully scummy, as Scotmany didn't say anything remotely similar to being happy to jump to LG if it looked like he'd be lynched.
confirm vote theopor_COD
