Mini 1474: Desperado's Revenge (Game Over)

[jon_h61]

Bump, for Desperado.

[Impetus]

N64, you've dodged and avoided answering my question to you 2-3 times now;

I want an answer, if you thought Themoaners claim was legitimate why did you state that he makes sense as a scum BP?

As for your "case" 1) I initially had a scum read on Lucky and her later posting was the only thing that made he hesitate on that so I didn't expect her to flip town at all and a lynch on her is significantly better than a lynch on a town read of mine (ie. Flench) so with deadline looming and me having to leave for real life issues there was no point whatsover to make a "counter case". 2) Explain why you think my scum read on Mnenomic is "off the wall" becasue I think his lack of commenting on the vig claim while maintaining suspicion on Themoaner is a decent scum tell. 3) My town read on Feel It is largely to do with two things A) The selfvote being genuine and B) I don't think him and you work as scum partners and I have a scum read on you making him more likely to be town. 4) Where did I "try to take credit for Luckys flip", I didn't read her as town, who I did read as town was AJ and was/am pissed that he was vigged and that my read on him was ignored when taking the shot.

[mnemonicdevice]

Wow. How was me not commenting on the vig claim make me scum?

[evilpacman18]

Let's get this party started then

vote: N64Lord

Posts full of null intent, being at the head of a disastrous looking wagon, being kind of omgussy and inconsistent, his case on Feel It is mostly that he's not doing anything which is 1) obvious, 2) not scummy, and 3) indicative of his selection of an easy target because there's a lot of people who have "not hunted, put off commenting on wagons, given a list that assigns people as scum or town reads without mentioning posts that make them scum/town" and N64 isn't attacking them all.

[evilpacman18]

Also
"Flench = scum" in that post about Feel It is a Freudian scum slip of epic proportions and shouldn't have been ignored when it happened.

[evilpacman18]

If that's the case and N64 and Flench are town, it makes mnemonic confirmed town for 596-7. The irony would be beautiful.

[Flench]

@EPM

I think you've cracked it Watson. Flawless case.

Now that you have caught me however, could you humor me and say exactly what my slip was or why Feel It is such a bad lynch?

Ignoring bad town play and self moaning from someone for over 4 days is not how I play.

[evilpacman18]

Overly paranoid that I've caught you Flench? If you'd paid attention you'd notice that I wasn't even talking about your posting, I'm saying your buddy accidentally sold himself and you both out with the slip at the end of 578

[Flench]

Also
"Flench = scum" in that post about Feel It is a Freudian scum slip of epic proportions and shouldn't have been ignored when it happened.

You were talking about my posting, you just didn't say what exactly.

I asked what, you responded with "paranoid I caught you?"

...

[Flench]

oooooooooo you were talking about N64's post about Feel It. Not my post about Feel It.

I mean I'm pretty sure it was because our names look similar, if you haven't seen people mix up names before then yea this must be pretty big deal for you. So if you are basing your opinions around someone mixing up names that look similar I don't think you are going to convince anyone, but we will see.

[evilpacman18]

You know what would help me associate you and him less? You helping me lynch him!

[Impetus]

EPM, I don't think "Mixing up names" is a scum tell when names like Radiant / Radioactive or Flench / Feel It are similar. For instance Feel It mixed up people in Post 428. Also ugh the following line from N64's last post kind of reads town, want your opinion on it though:

I'm starting to think that I was the only person who expected lucky2u to flip scum

, and I just want to know why you people won't argue against something, but assume you can take credit for knowing a player's alignment after a mislynch?

[RadiantCowbells]

VOTE: Flench

Explanation forthcoming.

[Desperado]

theomoaner has been prodded

[Desperado]

NSin replaces Radioactive Wolf effective immediately

[evilpacman18]

EPM, I don't think "Mixing up names" is a scum tell when names like Radiant / Radioactive or Flench / Feel It are similar. For instance Feel It mixed up people in Post 428. Also ugh the following line from N64's last post kind of reads town, want your opinion on it though:

I'm starting to think that I was the only person who expected lucky2u to flip scum

, and I just want to know why you people won't argue against something, but assume you can take credit for knowing a player's alignment after a mislynch?

The post kinda reads town sure, but it's not enough for me. If he caught on to the similarity between the lucky2u and Feel It wagon, which anyone could do, it'd make sense for him to pull that as scum. I know that sounds kinda tunnelly and if you've completely swayed to a town read on N64, I'm happy to listen to what you'd rather do instead, but my vote stays for now.

[N64Lord]

Also opinions changing from the 2nd to the 4th post is not scum, who always try too hard for consistency.

@ EPM you're calling me out for being inconsitant, now when you said this earilier.... Also you accuse me of "ömgus" for making a case against impetus, who presumably has an intent vote on me? That's anti-logic.... Feel it has a medium-large post count, and has done more than not contribute, he also threw weak suspicion at people just to fish for waht would stick, and I can't see the process of how he changes his suspicion out of his posts. I'm going for easy lynches? Four people have town reads on impetus, and feelit is active enough to make efforts to scumhunt or open up viable discussions. I'm assuming that the other people who've done "what feel it is doing" are mmnemoic and flench? That's a fair accusation, but I had to defend town mnemoci from a mislynch in our last game together, and his posts very similiar, also they give you an idea of how his thought process shapes out, and I don't see his posts coming at times when a scum agenda would be viable, such as when someone gives an awful response to a question or when a wagon is first defended.

flench made awful posts during early day 1, but then became towny by making logical pursuits, The most suspicous thing is that the wagon on him ended with him as a null read to most of the participants, where a town backed wagon really ought to have kept pushing until he flipped scum or convinced them of town... I'll have to reread that...

I see Impetus backing down when you made the first hard vote on me as the most scummy thing that's happened on d2.
@Impetus I made an early case against theomoaner d1 because I didn't like the reasons he used for voting radiant, later, I looked at the intent of his posts, and really he tries to get people to discuss things or break down how they built their case, so I unvoted him as a town read. Finally, he claimed credit for a death, which is kinda too bold for scum to do, if it were a gambit regardless, I would need to know if he felt the need to re-justify his claim again under the pressure of discussion.

[evilpacman18]

sigh.

I don't know what to do.

unvote
vote: Feel It

One of you is scum.

[evilpacman18]

Nope, feel it is town too.

unvote
vote: Flench

[evilpacman18]

fuck it, he can't be allowed to live

vote: mnemonicdevice

[evilpacman18]

town, help me out here.

[Flench]

You seem to have it all figured out.

[mnemonicdevice]

fuck it, he can't be allowed to live

vote: mnemonicdevice

What is your reasoning on me being scum?

[evilpacman18]

You seem to have it all figured out.

obviously not, but hey I'm trying, when was the last time you did anything besides post fluff or defend yourself?

[evilpacman18]

fuck it, he can't be allowed to live

vote: mnemonicdevice

What is your reasoning on me being scum?

I DON'T HAVE ANY THAT'S WHAT SUCKS
I just know the longer you're alive, the more of a disaster it will be for everything.


But really, I'd prefer to lynch scum. Everyone, opinions on Flench?