thats a pretty good analysis.
Certainly the bit about me "having half the world against me" is true.
However, if you play with me in lots of games, you will see its like this pretty much all the time. Regardless of my actual role, people think im scum. Either that, or scum use me as an easy target. In this game, id have to say its the latter.
[quote="theopor_COD"]Some thoughts on everyone so far shoot me for em afterwards -
Cheesefan -
Pretty irrelevant posts to start with, then is ninth on to the Livingod wagon
[quote="Cheesefan"]Oh what the hell, its time i made a vote that made a difference.
Unvote, Vote:Livingod
[/quote]
Could easily be voting his scum leader here, shouldn't be ruled out. Then subsequently attacks Battle Mage for his so called defence of Livingod, as I've pointed out before I don't think scum would go out of their way to defend him, day one. Continues to attack BM, then jumps on to the wagon me with little hesistation - still attacking BM mind, also don't really like the way he's changed opinion on Twito and KC so much and happily joins another bandwagon in Scope.
[quote="Cheesefan"][quote="~N9V~"]OverTheUnder, if he isn't scum, then I can almost garuntee that you are lynched tommorow, but it is to late now *prays that livingod is scum*.[/quote]
Id be looking more at Kelly or Twito.[/quote]
[quote="Cheesefan"][quote="KaleiÐoscøpe"][quote="Twito"]I resently heard KC is an excellent scumhunter. As she hasn't found any scum in this game she is likely to be scum herself. (or him?)[/quote]Why don't you just admit that you are actually scum, together with yellow and bm?[/quote]
I dont see a case on KC or Twito.
I didnt like that post
KaleiÐoscøpe
[/quote]
Doesn't present any reasons however and jumps on another wagon.
Moving on as you can tell I find Cheese pretty scummy
Yellowbounder -
Relatively quiet, under the radar points out suspicions of Cheesefan, with him pushing the Battle Mage is scum argument, his only other real input is outlining Scope's posts and voting him.
Twito -
Posted a shedload could be doing it to confuse, instigated lynch on LG and now prominent in the wagon on Kaleidoscope, he's posted so much I need to do a fair whack of analysis on him, which I'll do later. Gut says town mind.
Frustian/Water Foul/IH -
Water Foul did very little mind he voted for LG, IH I guess is still re-reading, either way it would be nice to get some input from him.
Rand Althor -
Hasn't posted in a week, and again one pushing for the Battle Mage lynch. Can't really decipher much else from him didn't vote first day.
Shamrock/Panzerjagger -
Shamrock was silent, Panzer's been opposite. All I can say is his voting is erratic so far we've had Votes for Chibo, Riverwind, Twito, Lowell, OtH and Lowell again, he sure likes to change his mind, here for example -
[quote="Panzerjager"]Riverwind, Scotmany is
decidedly town
.[quote]
[quote="Panzerjager"]On scotmany, he is being a little more aggresive and it seems a little scummy and like he is blending so disregard my last statement on Lowell, although I don't like her logic on Theopor and I don't like 2 votes in 4 post.[/quote]
[quote="Panzerjager"]I'm not pushing scotmany to hard but I can see a case for him, I just can not see the case for Scope.[/quote]
He needs to make his mind up, I can't tell whether it's scum jumping around or a townie uncertain of anything. Still at least he's prominent
DoS -
Good reasoning for voting Livingod day one unlike some
[quote="DragonsofSummer"]
Unvote Vote: livingod
because he is jumping on a bandwagon that was started because of my supposed bandwagoning.
[/quote]
He also has a reason for joining my bandwagon, he's now voting Kaleidoscope. Not much else to discuss with him seems solid but could be playing a careful game.
Amb -
Late bandwagon vote on Livingod, earlier rivalry with Twito, not much in it I don't think, I also like his reasoning on the argument against Battle Mage and I agree with him that I'd find it strange if scum defended Livingod so resolutely, seems happy with his vote on Twito and is convinced of of him.
[quote="Amb"]I wouldnt bother arguing over Twito's sureness of DoS being scum. Im reasonably sure Twito is scum but can't get any traction on it. So hopefully he won't get traction on the things he is pushing as well.[/quote]
Then leaves his pursuit of Twito to go after Kaleidoscope
Phita/Lowell -
Phita posted once voted for DoS then vanished, Lowell then appears quickly votes on Scot and then he attacks me with the argument I'm walking on eggshells! maybe he could be so kind to point it out. I'd also like to see his reaction to Twito/Panzer's discussion. p.s Twito's post 149 pretty much sums up Phita.
Battle Mage -
Dear old Battle Mage, seems to have half the world against him. I don't think his defence of Livingod means he's scum, more that he's town looking for more valid reasons for voting, he does make the point against voting LG 3/4 times but I would just find it odd I guess if he's defending LG, however lynching him could reveal a few things. He's then been involved with the attack from Cheesefan/Scope/Riverwind ever since, votes for my wagon then attacks Cheese again and has continued to do so against Cheese, Scope and River.
Chibo/mole -
Chibo's posts suck, contrdict themselves one he doesn't want to join the wagon against LG, possibly an attempt to save him, then pipes up with wanting the game to move on against me, very scummy, so he doesn't want the game to move days previous with a mafia man on the hill, but does so against me. Now he's gone need to keep an eye on Mole, don't really like much about his vote either, Yellowbounder's vote makes sense to me.
OvertheUnder -
Hammers Livingod anything in it? Doesn't bring anything else to the first day so it could be he's scum hiding or just inactive he doesn't really fear hammering LG either. I think he really should have explained the hammer at the time, instead he's had a week or so since doing it and come up with the reasons
[quote="OverTheUnder"]If I was mafia (Which I'm not) I wouldn't of been the last one to jump onto the bandwagon, I was suspicious of him for 1. Gut instincts, and 2. Because he hopped on a bandwagon himself and then when the bandwagon was on him he started pointing fingers at the people on his bandwagon claiming them scum because they bandwagoned. This was pretty clear to me, so I went ahead and voted for me. If I need to clarify more, let me know.[/quote]
Still not sure on him, he votes on my bandwagon same reason as many, mind I was playing like a tool. Then has gone on to attack Amb and voting him for the bandwagon on Scope.
Kaleidoscope -
Scope is adamant LG is scum first day, doesn't even consider the chance he may not be, he does ask for a claim when LG is at -1, the only one to do so I may add, which doesn't come. He's then happy to be agressive against Battle Mage and although I'm not sure on Mage, I'm getting second thoughts about Scope being scum only pretty much because he was the biggest aggresor in LG's lynch, mind I do think some ppl on the wagon had some inside knowledge. He's then having it out with Twito and I'm not sure about whether he's scummy or not, still in for Mage's lynch aswell. I'm not sure he's responded pretty well to the wagon in my eyes
Scotmany -
Seems defensive to me. He avoids voting LG but alludes to voting him if more points are raised against him, I found that pretty odd, nearly got myself lynched for doing so. Votes Chibo wisely, then changes to Amb for his vote on Twito. Hasn't really offered much other than when he's been attacked.
Wartys Neron/KC -
Scares me. I'll form an opinion on her later when I've got more time.
Riverwind -
Crazy is the only word I can use for him, no lynch at start. Posts all sorts of random crap, I can't make out whether he's just foolish or a newbie scum. Canna make heads or tails out of him, he just confuses me, not a jester by any chance?
~n9v~ -
Day one gets on the LG wagon, then asks for a claim from me before hammering me. His current plan of attack is on OvertheUnder for hammering the Godfather still continues his attack on OtH. Not keen on his last post much either
[quote="~N9V~"]
So in my case, I think OverTheUnder hammered who he knew was the GodFather, so as to make it look like whoever was protecting him was scum.
But if thats not enough, I strongly beleive that he is scum, that if we lynch him and I am wrong, then you can lynch me the next day. Or if I'm right, I pray the doctor in this game will save me!
[/quote]
I see no reason why mafia would take out the guy who hammered, would imagine it would be a more experienced member usually ala SpectrumVoid. He's pretty sure on OtH mind.
Anyway that's just a quick assessment, need to look at Twito and KC, as such and after I've reviewed things, I think Scope is less scummy than others so
unvote
and because of the reasons outlined
vote cheesefan
.[/quote]
