Micro 214 -- Chosen Mafia (Game Over)

[RedCoyote]

Apologies to OGML and the rest of the players. I hadn't noticed that Alexcellent did not post today. Looking for replacements for him and Narrow. The deadline will be extended if necessary. Prodding runnerman.

---

Vote Count 2 - 2

• runnerman

  (1) (Narrow)

  
  Narrow

  (1) (OhGodMyLife)

  
  F-16_Fighting_Falcon

  (1) (hohum)

  
  OhGodMyLife

  (1) (runnerman)
  
  
  Not Voting
  (3) (F-16_Fighting_Falcon -

  runnerman

  - havingfitz - Alexcellent)

With seven alive, it takes four to lynch.

Current Deadline:

(expired on 2013-09-09 15:30:00)

[runnerman]

No need to prod me.

[RedCoyote]

If you do not post for three days, you will be prodded whether you feel you need it or not. Nachomamma8 replaces Alexcellent. Thanks, Nacho!

[F-16_Fighting_Falcon]

I'd be interested in hearing what Nacho has to say. This game is stagnating.

[OhGodMyLife]

I'd be interested in hearing what Nacho has to say. This game is stagnating.

It would be a lot less stagnant if you would do something aside from make a case on the dead townie....

[havingfitz]

OK...I've had a hard time getting motivated for this game but I've been lynched in one of my games and the other two are not taking my time ATM.  So I'm giving this one a reinvigorated once over.  From the beginning (and armed with the knowledge that Amrun and JK were town).

So.....

Page 1:  Mostly RVS stuff I think but if someone was going to come off suspect on page one...I would say it is Alexcellent.  Mostly for Post 23.

Page 2: OK...Post 27 was a good explanation but then Post 29 seems to be a poor attempt of an excuse.  Like the points wrt runnerman not voting the fishiest person.  Why switch from a random vote on Narrow to a vote on F16 for no reason?  When there was someone you suspected? 

FOS

runnerman.

Page 3: Not a good page for runnerman IMO and Alex still pinging my suspicions.

Page 4: And now runnerman has Amrun as obvious scum.  I predict a runnerman vote when I get done....

Page 5: OK...I don't think runnermand and Alex are scum together so that is a plus in Alex' favor (atm). 

Page 6: Given that I know he eventually votes JK I do not care for Narrow's assessment that JK seems "fairly obviously town."

Page 7: nada

Page 8: Mostly nada.  OGML makes an appearance and my current view on him (as of page 8) is null leaning town.  

Page 9: uhhhhhh....nothing jumps out on this page or strengthens my opinions one way or the other.

Page 10: Narrow cameo.  F16 makes an appearance as well and mentions his early town read on JK. 

Page 11: Narrow is here and making a few posts that feel town...but i do not like how he (Narrow) ended the page.  bleh.

Page 12: .....

Page 13: meh

Page 14: Not liking F16's reliance on Alex's post 326 to determine JK is scum...and hammer.

Page 15: Jake against the world.

Page 16: F16's faux Amrun vote.  And OGML jumps on it.


OK...that's me caught up.  I think scum are within this group: runnerman, F16 and OGML. 

VOTE: runnerman

[OhGodMyLife]

Fitz take me through how your thought process got from null leaning town on page 8 to scum shortlist, and did you have anything at all to say about hohum?

[havingfitz]

I'm leaning town on hohum. My two most consistent suspects as I read through were runnerman and F16. You were kind of lumped in with Narrow and Alex/Nacho as players I went back and forth on. If I had stopped reading at an earlier point in the game I very well may have had one of them in my suspect pool. I think they each had some later posts that I liked and felt like were coming from town.

[havingfitz]

What's your take on runnerman?

[OhGodMyLife]

What's your take on runnerman?

Could be scum. Distinctly :nothelpful:. If I'm Chosen his chances of being scum go way up.

[RedCoyote]

Shane replaces Narrow. Thanks, Shane! I'll also be adding three days to the deadline for our two replacements. Also prodding hohum.

[F-16_Fighting_Falcon]

Nearly forgot about this game. HavingFitz, reason for Hohum townread?

[RedCoyote]

Going to do a mass prod for all the players in this game. The activity levels have been abysmal today across the board. I have started looking for a hohum replacement as well.

[F-16_Fighting_Falcon]

I was really looking forward to Nacho's analysis. And OGML, yes, I haven't done anything other than make a case on a dead townie. I was fairly certain about her affiliation last Day but her townflip just took the wind out of my confidence. I think once we get some analysis from our replacements, we should be able to go from there.

[havingfitz]

Mod...I wasn't due a prod and have been one of the most active posters recently. And does Nacho know he has replaced into this game? But I agree the game is stagnating.

Nearly forgot about this game. HavingFitz, reason for Hohum townread?

Based on the absence of making me think he is scum.

[havingfitz]

When is the deadline mod?

[havingfitz]

Who do you suspect F16 and why aren't you voting them? Since Amrun isn't an option....

[F-16_Fighting_Falcon]

I think we have three more days. I am unsure at the moment. Hohum didn't substantiate his FOS on me merely going off of Amrun's reasoning and he claimed he was right when he put faith in her reads. But how could he know whether he was right without a scumflip of someone she suspected? I doubt I can get a hohum lynch going though. I don't have a read on you yet. OGML is coming across as town hunting for scum. I can see how his reasoning is evolving over time. I also want the replacements to start posting so we can get a read on him.

[F-16_Fighting_Falcon]

I am a little worried Nacho and Shane haven't posted despite the mass prod.

[Shane]

Worried about? And you're not worried about the other 3 players who haven't responded?

I'm on page 11, give me an hour.

[F-16_Fighting_Falcon]

You two haven't posted at all. The other two have.

[Shane]

It seemed like an odd, non-contenty thing to say.

I think we have three more days. I am unsure at the moment. Hohum didn't substantiate his FOS on me merely going off of Amrun's reasoning and he claimed he was right when he put faith in her reads. But how could he know whether he was right without a scumflip of someone she suspected? I doubt I can get a hohum lynch going though. I don't have a read on you yet. OGML is coming across as town hunting for scum. I can see how his reasoning is evolving over time. I also want the replacements to start posting so we can get a read on him.

What do you think of runnerman? You don't have a read on fitz but what about Jake? and Alex and Narrow?

Also why do you think you cant get a lynch on hohum going? About one person has expressed a town read on him. You're seeming awfully hedgy.

While I'm questioning you, I'm curious, you seemed very certain Day 1 that Amrun was scum, why did you jump in and hammer JK then, a wagon that Amrun was on?

I couldn't figure out, can anyone tell me how far from deadline the hammer was?

[F-16_Fighting_Falcon]

I think Alex's slot (Nacho) is town. I felt Alex's case delved very deeply into the scummy motivations for JKMatthews actions. I independently found JK scummy based on Alex's case - I didn't take Amrun's vote into consideration. Amrun is definitely a competent enough player for whom bussing isn't out of the question. I found your above post townish - leaned town on narrow as well. Not sure about runnerman. What is your read on hohum?

[Shane]

You still seem like you're trying to sound out the viability of a hohum lynch without committing to it, but I'll answer your question anyway.

Most of hohum posts so far have been back and forths against Jake and has not engaged much else in the game. I would almost think ambivalent town, except the vitirol leveled against Jake seems too invested for ambivalence, so I'm thinking scum.

OTOH, I didn't like Alex's case on D1. Or more to say, I didn't like the way he jumped, and that most of his arguments were based on things that happened early on, but yet he was only then bringing it up.

Can someone tell me, does the killed player get a PM or some notification that they've died? Am trying to figure out F-16's dead man attack.

[F-16_Fighting_Falcon]

I am down for lynching hohum.

VOTE: hohum