My gut said that BigAl was scum on Day 1.
I was completely surprised about IH though. My list (most suspicious first) was Bertrand, BigAl, kaos. Congratulations to the mafia, you played it really well. I guess two IC's against 4 newbies and 1 IC is a hard game for the town.
But very well done.
@BigAl: I guess you will see me on this site in the future. I'm currently playing Newbie 314 and Mini 411 so I think I'm getting started.
@MeMe: thanks for modding, it was a smooth game.
My conclusions of this game (my first one on a mafia-dedicated site): think twice, no thrice before posting. My lynch -1 vote WAS a newbie mistake but one can never talk himself out of that I have learned.
Secondly, when you're threatened in a deadline, don't vote on who you think, but vote with the majority, lol. I changed my vote from kaos to Bertrand which was equal to signing my own death. If I had stuck to kaos, there was a chance that he would get lynched and I would live.
Too bad I couldn't play a lylo situation. It puts you under pressure and I think I would have liked it. But there will be plenty of games though (starting with Newbie 314).