I don't have QUITE as much time this morning to address everything that happened considering how quick this game has moved in a short time so I'll address each point briefly, as I see it. I'll comb through everything later to put a more cohesive case together on who I believe are the most likely scum(s).
Bastion wrote:
assuming I dont?
As of
post 16 I'm almost positive that a town player wouldn't have a scum read on both of them. DO YOU?
I nodded along with everything zakk said in
post 43.
Garmr's response is mostly "lol that's funny!" which I don't like.
I have no idea what to think of Slar's first post, I'm going to chalk it up to satire regarding an earlier FOS.
Guthrie's
post 54 is making me twitch a bit. I called him out in that post and he's giving me a town read for it. He also didn't touch on any parts of that post that were directed towards him. Feels like it could be a way to buddy me or something. I can't quite put my finger on it but it's tinging my gut scumdar. The rest of the post was good though.
Macros is making me twitch, too. I'm not quite sure how to feel about his recent posts. I'll need to see a legit case out of him.
For the record I find Thor's call for a speed lynch to be perfectly reasonable. I also think people calling him out on it is perfectly understandable, but I won't because I find it a town move. Thor seems to be trying pretty hard to control and direct town here, but IIRC he's a pretty aggressive player either way.
Albert wrote:
The game opened yesterday.
Bad excuse is bad. If we all used this then no progress would be made. There are TONS of things worth commenting on.
Thor wrote:
I iz ninja.
*Cough*
Guthrie wrote:
Ok, after a quick re-read i'd be very happy with a Bastion wagon. I still can't get over the fact that he votes me for bussing. Makes no sense, and just seems like he is looking for an excuse to create a wagon on me.
This is really ticking my gut scumdar, too. Something about "oh yeah you guys are right we should totally lynch this guy for something he did on page 1, after a quick re-read of course" makes me hesitate on my current vote.
At a quick thought I'm still fine with where my vote is, though. More analysis less stream of thought to come later.