Open 533: Pick Your Poison - The End

[notscience]

Hot Cheetos are you a hydra

[mnemonicdevice]

Alright. 8th post. Now you can call me town.

I currently think Nic is scum/ish

but definitely not enought to lynch.

[YellowKingValley]

When should our 1-shot use his/her night action?

Immediately before they die so that their ability is not wasted? Which means N1.
Or wait until there are clearer scum suspects? Which means N3.

[YellowKingValley]

What?! The scum already know the roles the town has so why the heck would they need to fish to find out which one the village has?

I am scum. I love notscience's reaction test. Helps me to find out exactly who the town PRs are so that I can them tonight. I want 1baldeagle1 gone because he knows too much. Keep beastcharizard around because he is useful.

[YellowKingValley]

to Mod: How does Mafia pick their poisons anyway? Each one gets to choose a town PR or they meet pre-D1 to discuss about their choices, plus other things.

[YellowKingValley]

Shows that I'm town.

[YES YES YES]

V/LA til Sunday

Im sick and I dont know when Daniel will go online..

DP

[Hot Cheetos]

Can you tell me why you are voting Banakai?

Read his iso and you tell me

[Hot Cheetos]

I was lieing about being IC,
Pretty sure notscience was too

Still not liking Nic. He's over reacting abit and he still hasn't said why he's calling that post "WIFOM"

Nic is town. This is weak reasoning.

The whole cc was stupid. Backing out of it was stupider and then making a joke about town being the only ones to joke in RVS takes the cake.

[YellowKingValley]

Got an . Team NicCage, Hot Cheetos and notscience.

[Hot Cheetos]

Can you tell me why you are voting Banakai?

I hated his counterclaim and subsequent role-fishing.

Hot Cheetos are you a hydra

Yes. Now identify this head.

When should our 1-shot use his/her night action?

Immediately before they die so that their ability is not wasted? Which means N1.
Or wait until there are clearer scum suspects? Which means N3.

All limited power roles should use their power immediately.

Got an . Team NicCage, Hot Cheetos and notscience.

The scumread on notscience surprises me.

[YellowKingValley]

All limited power roles should use their power immediately.

I'm , you mean they should claim D2?

[Hot Cheetos]

No, I mean that they shouldn't hold their shots for any reason.

[Hot Cheetos]

One-shot cop claiming day 2 is kind of a gotcha, though.

[Kalimar]

Vote Count 1.4

(5)

NicCage

: Egg, Hermy, Banakai, 1baldeagle1, YellowKingValley
(3)

Hermy

: notscience, NicCage, beastcharizard
(2)

1baldeagle1

: Venrob, BK201
(1)

Banakai

: Hot Cheetos

Not Voting:

mnemonicdevice, YES YES YES

With 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynch.

Deadline: (expired on 2013-10-22 07:45:00)

Mod Notes:

to Mod: How does Mafia pick their poisons anyway? Each one gets to choose a town PR or

they meet pre-D1 to discuss about their choices, plus other things

.

The latter is correct -- the choice is collective.

[YellowKingValley]

One-shot cop claiming day 2 is kind of a gotcha, though.

Come to think about it, 1-shot Cop claiming D2 is really !

[YellowKingValley]

Maybe we should vote who to lynch, kill and investigate!

[beastcharizard]

@hot cheetos:
Scum don't need to role fish! They know the dang roles in the game. You are using horrible logic to push your "scum" reads just like Hermy! Do you read the thread because what you just did is the exact reason I voted Hermy.

Scum teams so far: Hermy/Hot cheetos/????

One more and the game is in the bag.

[YellowKingValley]

They know the dang roles but they do not know who has the dang roles... thus rolefishing to find who has the dang roles... you are totally .

[Hot Cheetos]

Maybe we should vote who to lynch, kill and investigate!

I wouldn't mind directing the vig.
Directing the cop/tracker is problematic since mafia can dodge the tracker.

[Hermy]

Beast, are you actually stupid or are you just scum pretending to be stupid?

I OBVIOUSLY meant person-who-has-the-role fishing

[Egg]

I will just say it now but that's twice that notscience has been thinking the same thing as me. First time was with the question about what people would pick, though I didn't post that because I figured it would have too much WIFOM to actually use for scumhunting down the road. Notscience = town.

^bad logic. Matching opinions doesn't equal town. However, this post makes you more likely town so there's that.

Here's another question-

When forced to claim, do you claim something you know is in the game to out the PR (tracker or JK) or do you claim those not in the game?

^how does this post help town more than scum?

[notscience]

How does that post help either alignment at all?

It gets discussion going

I really want to say Nacho's in that hydra becoz cheetos but idk

[Venrob]

That post is setup discussion, which i find okay. You know that day I had that was the worst i had in a long time? 'that long time was about 1 year. Today was the worse day i've had in four years. If I don't do much posting or analysis today, that is why; in fact,

V/LA UNTIL NOON TOMORROW, EST.

That's about when i wake up on saturday But yeah, REALLY rough day. I blame it on my broken MP3 player.

[Egg]

What if someone is scum for the first time and worried about fakeclaiming properly? An answer to that question could help them a ton.