Open 529 -- Picking Simplicity -- Game Over

[Svenskt Stål]

wtf are you talking about

loran has a guilty, that cant be changed, we lynch whoever he says he has a guilty on

[uctriton00]

You asked me for my reads (and asked me in general to start contributing) and I'm going to contribute once we finish Loran's hunt.

[don_johnson]

loran said he had a guilty yesterday too.

[Svenskt Stål]

lorans hunt has nothing to do with you uct, stop hiding behind it

[uctriton00]

The spotlight is on you DJ Titus and Rach.

Don't drag me into your spotlight, you suspect.

[Svenskt Stål]

since i have read my pm and understand english i am exxcluding myself from that group.

ty

[uctriton00]

lorans hunt has nothing to do with you uct

Exactly so I'm playing follow the cop right now and want to see what comes out of his lines of questioning.

It's not as simple as "hey here's my guilty, let's kill em", it's obvious what his goal is/should be at this point.

[Svenskt Stål]

its a boring way to play

[Nobody Special]

Votecount 3.01

JacobSavage - 1 - RachMarie
jmo16mla - 1 - Maenara

Not Voting: aptil, Brian Skies, don_johnson, Loranthaceae, JacobSavage, jmo16mla, Rainbowdash, Skullduggery, Svenskt Stål, Titus, uctriton00, Antihero

With 14 alive, it takes 8 to lynch.

Deadline: (expired on 2013-11-17 17:55:19)

[Svenskt Stål]

VOTE: aptil

[Loranthaceae]

@Sven do an iso of Rach and tell me what you think.

[Maenara]

Figured you would wait until you'd killed him to say that?

If he flipped scum then I would have said "nice try" and understood he was just trying to stay alive. It depended on what his role was going to be.

Did you just admit to being the SK?

[Svenskt Stål]

@Sven do an iso of Rach and tell me what you think.

are you a he or she?

i am to lazy to iso. why dont you iso me and search for "rach"

[uctriton00]

Did you just admit to being the SK?

what?

[Loranthaceae]

@Sven do an iso of Rach and tell me what you think.

are you a he or she?

i am to lazy to iso. why dont you iso me and search for "rach"

Because I'm asking you for an updated version with everything new that came to light. Also you have a shitload of posts.

[Svenskt Stål]

you will not get one.

[Loranthaceae]

You enthusiastically call one of her posts bullshit. You vote her once because she needs to be motivated via torch but turn elsewhere (Evil). She has posted today, how do you feel about her and why not iso her and tell me your thoughts for the sake of looking a little more townie?

[Svenskt Stål]

becouse i am lazy

and you apparantly dont know my role, and since i can deduce that i can only guess that you are fishing for info.

ask yourself, does my reactions, after you claimed one of us four is scum, in any way seem scummy?
what i have stated about rach is in the thread, if i felt that you were on to me i would tell you what ever i thought you wanted to hear.

but mostly its becouse i am lazy

i find rach scummy, i would bet that she is the most likely of us four to be scum. does that statement carry worth?

[Svenskt Stål]

i do hope your guilty is on dj thou

[Loranthaceae]

I know, you said so.

[Svenskt Stål]

sorry for not cooperating

i hope you got one

[Loranthaceae]

Yep, no worries.

[Skullduggery]

What's this? Antihero isn't paying attention to the game? What a shocking turn of events.

DJ is a good bet for whatever faction killed Wake. Really a player who Wake called scum is the only one who would have any reason to kill the player who after a fake guilty reiterated a VT claim.

Serial Killer DJ would also make sense for the Mastin kill when you consider what Mastin said at the end of day one.

Interesting. I'll put this on the back burner for now. Catching the Serial Killer isn't our top priority at the moment.

Rach, Titus, Sven, DJ - I checked one of you last night and it came up guilty, not fucking around this time. I'd like a complete list of your reads before I announce today's lynch. Thank you.

-your friendly neighbourhood cop
LH

You'd better not be lying again. Trust is not something that can so easily be won back.

doc protects lora. lora investigates the scummy scummy scummy evil regals.

Loran, I really hope you didn't investigate Evil Regals last night. If you did, then

here's

the reason why Scum killed her.

Potential Doctor crumbs + Potentially screwing up the Cop's investigation = A kill that actually makes sense

Yeah that makes perfect sense.

Y'know, except Evil crumbed

cop

, not

doctor

.

Okay? Why are you telling me this? I'm trying to look at the situation from the Scum team's point of view.

All discussion should stop now. It's Better that we lynch lorths guilty after the people in her group give reads. This keeps scum in the dark with lorths investigations and the identity of the doctor.

Are you serious? What incentive could Town possibly have to stop talking just because the Cop says that he has a guilty on someone? We have plenty of time before the deadline. We might as well chat a little before we hear Loran's results.

I highly doubt that the Doctor is going to accidentally reveal themselves, and unless they do something stupid tonight, Loran is almost guaranteed to survive until tomorrow and get another investigation result. Town is in a good position right now. There is no reason why we shouldn't take advantage of the time we have left.

to add to that, NK analysis is WIFOM. Youre trying to pin the NK on Aptil? uh. sven, I think you're scum.

So vote for him.

You've got to remember, there isn't one scum left. So even if Aptil IS scum, she/he has two other people to converse with about the NK, making it less likely that they would be complete newbs.

How does this make it less likely for the Scum team to be comprised of new players?

DJ's explanation makes sense, though I'll still argue that Evil's crumbs were way more cop oriented, and that it'd've made much more sense if SK had killed Evil, while mafia killed Wake, under the assumption that they were targeting one another.

Why would it make more sense for the SK to kill the player who left Cop crumbs? The SK has nothing to fear from the Cop.

After Loran finishes then I have another theory I'll share but I don't want to stop the momentum Loran currently has.

Why wait? Tell us. Loran's "momentum" isn't going anywhere.

[Maenara]

doc protects lora. lora investigates the scummy scummy scummy evil regals.

Loran, I really hope you didn't investigate Evil Regals last night. If you did, then

here's

the reason why Scum killed her.

Potential Doctor crumbs + Potentially screwing up the Cop's investigation = A kill that actually makes sense

Yeah that makes perfect sense.

Y'know, except Evil crumbed

cop

, not

doctor

.

Okay? Why are you telling me this? I'm trying to look at the situation from the Scum team's point of view.

Yeah but I don't really think anyone but you have managed to read it as doc crumbs.

DJ's explanation makes sense, though I'll still argue that Evil's crumbs were way more cop oriented, and that it'd've made much more sense if SK had killed Evil, while mafia killed Wake, under the assumption that they were targeting one another.

Why would it make more sense for the SK to kill the player who left Cop crumbs? The SK has nothing to fear from the Cop.

The point is, the doc crumbs were obviously

fake

, because we already know with almost certainty who the cop is - Namely, Lora. And it makes no sense for the SK to try to fakeclaim cop, whereas it makes perfect sense for faction-scum. So the SK would kill Evil thinking they were Mafia.

[Titus]

VOTE: Sven Stal

I saw the request for reads. I will be typing them up in a moment after I finish catching up. I'll do conclusions with brief sentences. If anyone wants elaboration, just ask. Ranking the possible guilties I would go

Stal
Dj
Rach
Titus