OK, back to front didn't work, and then I lost brain power to do anything that required much original thought this weekend. Reading through the game in order, trying to keep in mind who's flipped what.
Posts of interest:
In post 83, aptil wrote: In post 67, HGH7193 wrote:You voted for me but I will change it before the deadline probably.
This statement is so strange . I am now thinking one of them(HGH and TCold) has to be scum.
Nice way to set the stage to lynch both of them, knowing now that neither is scum.
Antihero comes in and picks at both Borophil and RachMarie. I haven't played a game with town- or scum-Antihero (hi, cultmaster!) but my sense of him is that he's not the type to come in and start throwing his team under the bus.
In post 237, jmo16mla wrote:Willing to bet at least one out of tcold and aeronaut are scum. Anyone follow?
Just what aptil did in #83.
This reaction isn't great (AA9's slot)
Here:
In post 285, Titus wrote:@Wake, I just saw the questions I missed upon a reread of your ISO and mine. You raise some interesting points about Evil being hypocritical. I will move him to my watch list along with Skullduggery. I don't like your fixed number theory but I don't like a wagon so fast on Skull even though he's being a jerk. We should spend enough time to ensure everything has been discussed but no longer as lag can derail legitimate wagons. HGH is a strong scum read at this point for me and it seems like he's jumped on a lot of radars.
@Skelda, I have to disagree with the no motivation to cut the day short. If the town is aligned and agrees upon a plan, scum can manipulate to cause disagreement. Also regarding Anti-Hero, if you tried to twist your read of him, that's VERY hard to do. If you had just agreed with popular opinion (which you did) you would have at least commented with some hostility that I was suspecting you might sheep your reads. Objecting about being ignored by someone other than your scum read is a town indicator to me which both Wake and Anti-Hero displayed so I'm putting them as town tentatively.
@All, This wagon formed suspiciously fast. People shifting from HGH to Aptil to Skull back to HGH is just off. HGH's wagon takes one of the longest. For my own notes, I'd like it if everyone FoSed someone not on that list, even if it's not your biggest scum read. There's something off about the speed and formation of these wagons. Looking at each player might be beneficial to the group.
VOTE: don_johnson
More content needed from that slot.
Titus talks about all the places to scum hunt. Then she picks on a lurker. Um...
In post 342, Nobody Special wrote:Votecount 1.08
Skullduggery - 8 - aptil,
BoroPhil
,
elleheathen
, don_johnson,
Aeronaut, TCold, uctriton00, HGH7193
If I throw in DJ as a town read, it looks like scum stayed the heck away from this wagon. Probably for good reason. Which makes me think it's unlikely that aptil is scum after all, as I don't see BoroPhil following him on.
In post 446, BoroPhil wrote:don_johnson - 4 - Titus, JacobSavage, Brian Skies, uctriton00
voted me early on, possibly retracted his vote a little too easily but I put zero pressure on him so this does seem pretty town. scum would have kept their vote there.
so this leads me to think don is town, therefore 1 of the people on him could well be scum.
Titus - agreed with him at 191 (as above), but then his vote states that we need more content from DJ. bit bizarre this as DJ has been pretty prominent (and posted reads for everyone)
Jacob Savage - zero activity, strange vote. seems outraged that he is a 'townie vote'
Brian Skies - now unvoted
Uctriton - not actually sure why he voted for Don. but I agreed with his thoughts on skullduggery.
Not sure on skull overall. but Jacob has done nothing and that vote was bizarre. Got sidetracked somewhat there, but I think this person needs some pressure.
VOTE: Jacob Savage
This makes me think one of {Titus, JS, Brian Skies} is scum, with JS as the least likely. I'd put Brian Skies as the most likely for having the shortest reasoning.
In post 456, aptil wrote:Your read on me is basically, you wanting to know why i was away and looks like a reaction test.This is the last time i am even going to comment on it .
Why do you like to roleclaim for no reason at all?
I'm of two minds about this. On the one hand, aptil is unhappy about anti-town play if he's referencing a VT claim. On the other hand, he's taking it at face value, implying insider knowledge.
I like Maenara's entrance.
And it leads to this:
!!!
And this:
In post 496, JacobSavage wrote:Way to ask a loaded question.
What do I think, I think your full of shit personally.
I think maera's vote is justified and her reasonings are pretty soild.
Hell, I can't believe I didn't do this already.
VOTE: Wake88
makes me like JS. Not afraid to tell off abrasive and detrimental town.
With hindsight, not loving this.
Living players with my reads at this point (breaking this up so as not to piss everyone off):
aptil
ArcAngel9
don_johnson
JacobSavage
jmo16mla
Maenara
Antihero
Titus
That leaves three anti-town in aptil, AA9, JS, jmo, Titus.
I'd put aptil in there based on everything. jmo, likely given his sidelines feel. Not JS. Titus-AA9, not sure; Brian Skies was weird with BoroPhil, but I need to look at AA9's entrance more carefully. Titus pings a bit.
