Shadow's terminally happy Newbie 1451 game over,mod exploded

[TierShift]

Skip to next vote count.

CAN SOMEONE FINALLY EXPLAIN THE NATI READS BEFORE ASKING COUNTERQUESTIONS?

[pirate mollie]

CAN SOMEONE FINALLY EXPLAIN THE NATI READS BEFORE ASKING COUNTERQUESTIONS?

I am not very good at explaining my reads but since this is rome I will try. it is just that my first 80 games before I even came to mafiascum were on other sites so I have a very different skill set and I see different things.

nasty rash feels like scum to me. when I interact with him I don't get a town vibe. so part of it is based on gut. but I think that I was targeted for nk last night and it would be nasty rash who would want me dead. or mala but I am townreading mala so nasty it is.

[TierShift]

Welp I got what I wanted.

VOTE: Yiley

Thinking Malakittens/Yiley at the moment.

Are those just the two most scummy players to you, or is this an associative tell?

[TierShift]

I am back to thinking you are scum. tbh I don't remember why I thought that I will to do a reread.

This is the last time you talked about mala and you said she could be scum?

Your explanation of your read was fine, if you'd do one fpr your earlier vote on ED I'd be super happy.

I've done some rereading on nati and well, he's not been particularly helpful. 221 and 285 don't match up, that was one shitty reaction test, what reaction are you hoping to get by voting your #1 townread? Most jumping to the eye is the insisting on that mala is scum, with only this comparison to his own meta?

I'm considering a rothwell/nati scumteam. Their interactions from 341 to 348 seem forced and perhaps prepared. 341 was the first time rothwell seemed to be sure about something, which is weird and inconsistent.

Mollie, comments on 341-348 pls.

[Huntress]

Huntress, what happened with rothwell being your 3rd/4th scumread?

Nothing happened to it, but I'm exploring other things while waiting for Yiley.

[Yiley]

Sorry about this guys, got a big report thing dumped on me Friday resuming from page 4 now. Back in a bit

[Natirasha]

I've done some rereading on nati and well, he's not been particularly helpful. 221 and 285 don't match up, that was one shitty reaction test, what reaction are you hoping to get by voting your #1 townread?

The emeraldemon vote was more about mollie than demon.

[TierShift]

I mean mollie's reaction will always be like: wtf are u doing?

[Shadowmod]

Vote Count

Rothwell

(3/5): Yiley, Huntress, TierShift

emeraldemon

(0/5):

pirate mollie

,

Natirasha

,

Huntress

Yiley

(1/5):

Huntress

, Natirasha

Natirasha

(2/5): pirate mollie, Malakittens

pirate mollie

(0/5):

Malakittens

not voting

(2/8): Rothwell, emeraldemon


8 alive, 5 to lynch, 4 to no lynch

Day 2:

(expired on 2013-12-16 15:00:00) remaining

[Natirasha]

I mean mollie's reaction will always be like: wtf are u doing?

It's more of a feel, tonal thing.

[pirate mollie]

tier I will respond to your comments when you answer whether or not you have nasty rash as town

[TierShift]

Would null/slightly scummy do?

[Malakittens]

Ok my mind was messed up I thought you had written different things. I do think your posting lately has been more townish, since it feels more genuine and helpful towards the scumhunt, instead of helpful just by explaining like you did before.

._.

I don't see how me tossing votes with no explanation is pro-town when prior I was trying to explain things while putting votes out.

Just don't see how at all I'm being more townish.

Anyone else?

[emeraldemon]

Rothwell, please come out and explain your last few posts!

[Yiley]

@ mod V/la until Thursday/Friday

[Malakittens]

-_-

I think I might be okay with a Yiley lynch too.

[TierShift]

Well mala I don't agree. Before you weren't to the point and now you are. And I like 280, for instance.

[pirate mollie]

I am back to thinking you are scum. tbh I don't remember why I thought that I will to do a reread.

This is the last time you talked about mala and you said she could be scum?

Your explanation of your read was fine, if you'd do one fpr your earlier vote on ED I'd be super happy.

I've done some rereading on nati and well, he's not been particularly helpful. 221 and 285 don't match up, that was one shitty reaction test, what reaction are you hoping to get by voting your #1 townread? Most jumping to the eye is the insisting on that mala is scum, with only this comparison to his own meta?

I'm considering a rothwell/nati scumteam. Their interactions from 341 to 348 seem forced and perhaps prepared. 341 was the first time rothwell seemed to be sure about something, which is weird and inconsistent.

Mollie, comments on 341-348 pls

.

well i did kind of, I mean that exchange is part of the reason I am wondering if they are both scum

[pirate mollie]

-_-

I think I might be okay with a Yiley lynch too.

I so do not like this post

[Malakittens]

-_-

I think I might be okay with a Yiley lynch too.

I so do not like this post

That's okay.
I'm just fed up with yiley saying he'll catch up but never doing so.

Seems like scum stalling

[Natirasha]

And the whole fact this game is sixteen pages.

[Huntress]

I'm considering a rothwell/nati scumteam. Their interactions from 341 to 348 seem forced and perhaps prepared. 341 was the first time rothwell seemed to be sure about something, which is weird and inconsistent.

I'm not sure about "prepared", because I can't see the point of Nat suggesting that Rothwell do that. What would be the scum motive for it? I could see it as Nat correcting an errant scum-buddy but it could equally well be a townie correcting a newbie.

Would null/slightly scummy do?

If we lynched Rothwell and he flipped town, how would that affect your read on Nat?

[pirate mollie]

And the whole fact this game is sixteen pages.

towniest thing you have said all game

UNVOTE:

I am just going to be blunt since there was a no kill and mala said she wanted me to be transparent

@ mala

did you jail me?

[TierShift]

@ mala

did you jail me?

Why just why? If mala says no you haven't gotten any further, if mala says yes you know who will be nk'd.
Why rolefishing d2?

Would null/slightly scummy do?

If we lynched Rothwell and he flipped town, how would that affect your read on Nat?

Not much, honestly. I'd have to reread on rothwell's interactions.

[Malakittens]

And the whole fact this game is sixteen pages.

towniest thing you have said all game

UNVOTE:

I am just going to be blunt since there was a no kill and mala said she wanted me to be transparent

@ mala

did you jail me?

totes not answering this. You know why.