Shadow's terminally happy Newbie 1451 game over,mod exploded

[Huntress]

Not much, honestly. I'd have to reread on rothwell's interactions.

Did you mean Nat rather than Rothwell here? I'm puzzled as to how a town Rothwell's interactions would affect your read on Nat.


Strange things happen while hanging about waiting. Like I'm beginning to wonder if there really was something in my original impression of a link between Tier and DC.

[Shadowmod]

Vote Count

Rothwell

(3/5): Yiley, Huntress, TierShift

emeraldemon

(0/5):

pirate mollie

,

Natirasha

,

Huntress

Yiley

(1/5):

Huntress

, Natirasha

Natirasha

(1/5):

pirate mollie

, Malakittens

pirate mollie

(0/5):

Malakittens

not voting

(3/8): Rothwell, emeraldemon, pirate mollie


8 alive, 5 to lynch, 4 to no lynch

Day 2:

(expired on 2013-12-16 15:00:00) remaining

[Rothwell]

Rothwell, please come out and explain your last few posts!

I mistakenly assumed someone would know if they were jailed, and forgot that someone jailed is also protected from being attacked.

[TierShift]

Not much, honestly. I'd have to reread on rothwell's interactions.

Did you mean Nat rather than Rothwell here? I'm puzzled as to how a town Rothwell's interactions would affect your read on Nat.


Strange things happen while hanging about waiting. Like I'm beginning to wonder if there really was something in my original impression of a link between Tier and DC.

I misread lol thought you said scum.

I don't think a town rothwell would change my reads that much either.

[TierShift]

Also why is everyone totally ignoring my questions

[TierShift]

And huntress I feel offended by you thinking I would be so bad as scum...

[Malakittens]

Not much, honestly. I'd have to reread on rothwell's interactions.

Did you mean Nat rather than Rothwell here? I'm puzzled as to how a town Rothwell's interactions would affect your read on Nat.


Strange things happen while hanging about waiting. Like I'm beginning to wonder if there really was something in my original impression of a link between Tier and DC.

I misread lol thought you said scum.

I don't think a town rothwell would change my reads that much either.

I mean it should depending on the wagon. To keep one reads solid and not interchangeable is a crime.

Oh preedit:

I don't like that post either..

In fact, i really dont like it.

VOTE: tiershirt

ps do you have any completed scum games?

[TierShift]

I mean it should depending on the wagon. To keep one reads solid and not interchangeable is a crime.

Oh preedit:

I don't like that post either..

In fact, i really dont like it.

VOTE: tiershirt

ps do you have any completed scum games?

I meant that just my read on nati wouldn't change all that much with a roth town flip, not every read has to change with every flip.

And well sorry for the distancing but I was just letting my heart speak.

No completed scum games. One town game.

Tiershirt beats the current timeshift as best wrong spelling of my nick. Gratz.

[Malakittens]

I mean it should depending on the wagon. To keep one reads solid and not interchangeable is a crime.

Oh preedit:

I don't like that post either..

In fact, i really dont like it.

VOTE: tiershirt

ps do you have any completed scum games?

I meant that just my read on nati wouldn't change all that much with a roth town flip, not every read has to change with every flip.

And well sorry for the distancing but I was just letting my heart speak.

No completed scum games. One town game.

Tiershirt beats the current timeshift as best wrong spelling of my nick. Gratz.

How would you know how you would play scum if you don't have a competed scum game.

[Malakittens]

Lol at the name. Be greatful spell check auto hit it to 'shit' at first and then I recorrected it again.

[pirate mollie]

And the whole fact this game is sixteen pages.

towniest thing you have said all game

UNVOTE:

I am just going to be blunt since there was a no kill and mala said she wanted me to be transparent

@ mala

did you jail me?

totes not answering this. You know why.

I think since it is already mentioned it seems silly to not pursue it. I asked if you wanted total transparency and you said yes. I think it needs to go both ways.

it is d2 with 8 players, town is a bit ahead. it wouldn't be the worst strategy in the world and given this playerlist mebbe not a bad idea. there are going to be at least 2 town between me/you/nasty/huntress. <------ I like the odds.

your pushes are weird and seem forced so you are freaking me out.

@ teir

:/ I did answer you.

@ huntress

I don't think we have interacted at all why is that

[emeraldemon]

Rothwell, please come out and explain your last few posts!

I mistakenly assumed someone would know if they were jailed, and forgot that someone jailed is also protected from being attacked.

VOTE: Rothwell

Let me try this again. Why do you think there's a jailkeeper?

L-1, but it's OK because I doubt Rothwell would self-vote.

[Natirasha]

Willing to hammer, I guess, but I really wanna try lynching mala or Yiley over lynchbait.

[Huntress]

Sorry. I don't have your faith that he won't self-hammer so I'm not taking the risk.

Unvote: Rothwell

I want to sort Yiley before we end the Day and if Rothwell or anyone else hammers we won't get that chance.

[Huntress]

@ huntress

I don't think we have interacted at all why is that

I never really felt the need. I've been watching you but there's been nothing I felt I had to question, or at least, nothing that someone else didn't beat me to. I did notice something that I didn't want to mention but I think in the light of recent posts that I was probably wrong about it anyway.

[Huntress]

@ Rothwell:

Going back to my earlier question, who are your top two suspects. based on their posts in this thread, not on any setup speculation?

@ Emerald:

I'm getting flashbacks to Day 1 here, where you put GM at L-1 and Rothwell came in and hammered. What makes you so certain that he wouldn't self-vote?

[Malakittens]

And the whole fact this game is sixteen pages.

towniest thing you have said all game

UNVOTE:

I am just going to be blunt since there was a no kill and mala said she wanted me to be transparent

@ mala

did you jail me?

totes not answering this. You know why.

I think since it is already mentioned it seems silly to not pursue it. I asked if you wanted total transparency and you said yes. I think it needs to go both ways.

it is d2 with 8 players, town is a bit ahead. it wouldn't be the worst strategy in the world and given this playerlist mebbe not a bad idea. there are going to be at least 2 town between me/you/nasty/huntress. <------ I like the odds.

your pushes are weird and seem forced so you are freaking me out.

@ teir

:/ I did answer you.

@ huntress

I don't think we have interacted at all why is that

No.

Back to work I go

~Yayyyy

[emeraldemon]

@ Rothwell:

Going back to my earlier question, who are your top two suspects. based on their posts in this thread, not on any setup speculation?

@ Emerald:

I'm getting flashbacks to Day 1 here, where you put GM at L-1 and Rothwell came in and hammered. What makes you so certain that he wouldn't self-vote?

Maybe I'm wrong here, but I actually think he does want to win.

[Malakittens]

Willing to hammer, I guess, but I really wanna try lynching

mala or

Yiley over lynchbait.

How is Yiley not as much of lynchbait as Roth?

[Natirasha]

Roth's is more blatant. Yiley is less slow burn.

[Yiley]

Sorry. I don't have your faith that he won't self-hammer so I'm not taking the risk.

Unvote: Rothwell

I want to sort Yiley before we end the Day and if Rothwell or anyone else hammers we won't get that chance.

Ok ask and sort away I'm ready nowish.

[Malakittens]

Sorry. I don't have your faith that he won't self-hammer so I'm not taking the risk.

Unvote: Rothwell

I want to sort Yiley before we end the Day and if Rothwell or anyone else hammers we won't get that chance.

Ok ask and sort away I'm ready nowish.

Why don't you give your thoughts on the thread for starters.

[Huntress]

Maybe I'm wrong here, but I actually think he does want to win.

If he's scum, then self-hammering to end the Day early could well help his team win, it's a valid tactic and I'm concerned that you gave him the opportunity, especially with what looks like it might be a hint to him.

Vote: Yiley

Now Newbie 1446 has finished I can refer to Yiley's play in that game, where he was town, and was much more proactive than he has been here. I recommend a read of his ISO there. I know he's been busy but that doesn't account for the difference between his activity here and elsewhere on the site. I suspect that it's because he is scum here.

Willing to hammer, I guess, but I really wanna try lynching mala or Yiley over lynchbait.

Was that actually an intent to hammer?

[TierShift]

it is d2 with 8 players, town is a bit ahead. it wouldn't be the worst strategy in the world and given this playerlist mebbe not a bad idea. there are going to be at least 2 town between me/you/nasty/huntress. <------ I like the odds.

your pushes are weird and seem forced so you are freaking me out.

@ teir

:/ I did answer you.

Mollie can you explain the first part of this further, I am not understanding.

As for the questions, I have not received answer as to why the ED votes from both you AND huntress and then I have a question for nati about the scumreads that he isn't answering.


I super duper agree with huntress, that linked game opened my eyes. Look at this post here and see how it doesn't match up with his play.

UNVOTE:
VOTE: yiley

[emeraldemon]

1446 was already finished when I made my meta post on yiley, it's one of the two I linked to. Are y'all reading Huntress's posts but not mine?

And @tiershift, I disagree. The post you are pointing to is after the town lost that game, he says "oh i guess town should be more active". That's totally different from actually being active town in a game (which he wasn't).

I stand by what I said before, yiley's play doesn't seem inconsistent between that game and this one. Also, I'm kinda getting paranoid about Huntress for the first time this game. Everyone thinks she's town, but it's easy to seem town when you're never under any pressure.

@huntress: could you point to a post or two in that game that seems different to you from yiley's play here?