Shadow's terminally happy Newbie 1451 game over,mod exploded

[TierShift]

Skip to next vote count.

Oh look, another one of those delightful vote counts!

But the way you phrase it makes me see it as a very bad plan. Nvm I retract it.

[Natirasha]

VOTE: Malakittens

[TierShift]

Why, is my wagon deflating?

[Natirasha]

No, I'm appealing to mindgamer and emeraldemon here. I've already stated that I'm fine with either of you getting lynched today. I do think you're slightly more likely to be scum at this point, but we can take the long route if they so choose.

[Rothwell]

I am okay with voting Mala.

Will reply to any questions I've been asked tomorrow.

[Shadowmod]

Vote Count

emeraldemon

(0/4):

TierShift

Malakittens

(2/4):

Natirasha

,

Mindgamer

,

TierShift

, emeraldemon, Natirasha

TierShift

(0/4):

emeraldemon

,

Malakittens

,

Natirasha

Natirasha

(3/4): Malakittens, TierShift, Mindgamer

not voting

(1/6): Rothwell

6 alive, 4 to lynch, 3 to no lynch

Day 1:

(expired on 2014-01-02 15:00:00)

[Malakittens]

Tier do you have any experience in mafia outside this site? (RL other sites etc)

[TierShift]

RL werewolf but that wasn't very in-depth. It basically meant me always getting lynched day 1 or day 2 because 'he knows the game he's dangerous'.
Why do you ask?

[TierShift]

Rothwell are you gonna vote now?

[Rothwell]

I really don't know between Nati/Mala, and am anxious of hammering after the second day debacle.

[TierShift]

You shouldn't be afraid to hammer, but you should state intent to hammer if you are going to. Then the person in question can claim (well yeah vt anyways) and give final thoughts or reasons not to vote him. Afterwards you can hammer.
Mala vote isn't a hammer btw.

[Natirasha]

I'm not scum here, Rothwell.

[TierShift]

UNVOTE: nati
VOTE: malakittens
That last post convinced me.

Nope I did some rereading and all I got from mala was lack of scumhunting and the freaking scummy 'i'm okay with a yiley lynch too'.

Idk why I scumtead nat as heavily as mala but still my second pick. His yiley vote was lots better than mala's.

[TierShift]

Rothwell you may now state intent to hammer

[Shadowmod]

Vote Count

emeraldemon

(0/4):

TierShift

Malakittens

(3/4):

Natirasha

,

Mindgamer

,

TierShift

, emeraldemon, Natirasha, TierShift

TierShift

(0/4):

emeraldemon

,

Malakittens

,

Natirasha

Natirasha

(2/4): Malakittens,

TierShift

, Mindgamer

not voting

(1/6): Rothwell

6 alive, 4 to lynch, 3 to no lynch

Day 1:

(expired on 2014-01-02 15:00:00)

[Malakittens]

UNVOTE: nati
VOTE: malakittens
That last post convinced me.

Nope I did some rereading and all I got from mala was lack of scumhunting and the freaking scummy 'i'm okay with a yiley lynch too'.

Idk why I scumtead nat as heavily as mala but still my second pick. His yiley vote was lots better than mala's.

Yes totally convinced me he's not scum either.

Anyways, you been saying I haven't scum hunted all game, but this is how I do scum hunt based on reactions to where I place votes or little things I have for meta.

His vote on yiley wasn't any better than mine.

Anyways reads:

Mindgamer - town don't lynch it.
Roth - town for the claim, but hesitant to call him conf town because mafia team could have accidentally forgot to send in a kill and claiming BP could have been a decent cover. (Doubt that's the case)
Tier - possible scum just little things for me.
Emerald - only possible scum if he killed huntress for nailing her.
Nati - probably scum

So my thoughts is that it's either tier or Nati.

Anyways gl town

[emeraldemon]

Rothwell you may now state intent to hammer

Tiershift I don't like it when you do this, you did it yesterday too. There are three days left, and unlike yesterday no one has gone VLA or disappeared. Don't rush the hammer.

[TierShift]

Mala, rothwell is actually conftown since there's no doc/BP CC.

ED, roth said that he was too scared to vote so I just wanted him to feel comfortable voting (and I'd rather have him vote for my suspect than anyone else, yes)

[emeraldemon]

@malakittens and mind gamer:
What do you think about my post about natirasha?

[Malakittens]

Give me a day. I want to review nati's ate with a newer completed scum game of his to my modded castle game where he was town and then to another past town game of his on paradox prime. I want to see if I'm right or wrong there and see if I want to place my vote elsewhere. (Even if I'm getting lynched I rather vote someone who I believe is scum even if the other wagon is bigger)

[Mindgamer]

Roth - town for the claim, but hesitant to call him conf town because mafia team could have accidentally forgot to send in a kill and claiming BP could have been a decent cover. (Doubt that's the case)

This makes no sense. In Matrix6 there has to be a PR besides the Tracker. Rothwell's bulletproof claim is not counter claimed, so it's basically 99.99% confirmed Rothwell is real unless someone is playing against their win condition. You of all people should know this, as you're such an active mod in Road to Rome.
This makes me lean towards Mala again.

@ Emerald
You mean your post about Natirassha's Yiley vote? Imo that vote could have been town and scum motivated. I don't really see it as indicative of anything. Bussing is a thing. You could also say that Malakittens is town because she wouldn't hammer her own buddy needlessely like that. Btw, I reread that part and TierShift states there that 'If Yiley is scum, Malakittens has got to be town'. Strange how he made for a 180 degree turn. What happened to that towntell, TierShift?

I wasn't aware deadline was only three days away. At this point I'd hammer Malakittens over Natirasha, but I'm not going to do so yet. I also like to hear more from Rothwell, who is the worst unimpressive clear I've ever seen in a mafia game.

[Mindgamer]

I would actually like to ask that everyone recheck their role PM to see if they didn't actually forget that they're the 1-shot bulletproof. I know I just did.

[TierShift]

Mindgamer are you saying you just forgot that you are the 1-shot BP?

About the 180 I made...I thought at the time that she vould have not hammered because she could have been 'offline' due to sickness. But you guys told me that's not a towntell...

[Mindgamer]

No.

- Cleared townies are extremely valuable to town and should (and usually will) step up their game to lead the town. Rothwell is doing the opposite and has basically disappeared for all of Day 3.
- Nightkill on Rothwell Night 1 still makes no sense at all.

The idea popped into my head that perhaps Rothwell is fakeclaiming and the real bulletproof (or even doc?) thinks they're vanilla townie. It's a stretch, but it would explain above information. So just take two seconds to reconfirm your role.

[Natirasha]

You're not thinking deep enough, mindgamer. I think Rothwell is better than I give him credit for.