Mini 1536 - Silph Co. Reverse Mafia (Game Over)

[Whiskers]

Finally I got some damn time on the net.
Dry-fit:
I was feeling suicidal, when you lose all hope in the game and don’t care about it anymore.

Yeah so, null.
cool.

Whiskers’ #273 is basically “I don’t know if he’s scum but let’s lynch him anyway”. Please explain this.

Yeah, that's pretty much it. I should point out it wasn't until several pages later that I actually voted you, preferring other, better policy-lynch players (Zekrom, for example), but when Tiershift went "dude, the game has become boring, can we just lynch?" I said to myself, "yeap, sounds good."

[Whiskers]

Tier why do you find Emp a more plausible lynch than cx when Emp had no votes on him when you voted?

Zekrom could you tell us what mafia experience you have?

He watched The Godfather on a plane once.

How do you know he'll pick wrong in lylo? If he's truly clueless it seems like it would be a coinflip. Also not interested in a policy lynch.

How about, "town is better off having a LyLo of two scum and one townie, than one townie, one mafia, and one Zekrom," instead of a simple, "he'll pick wrong"? How about, if you have to be exact and specific and nuanced and verbose, we just say, "we can put no faith in his skill, since thus far, his main inspiration seems to be rubbish, and his chances of deducing which player is scum in a high-tensity situation is going to be 0:1, or possibly lower." Maybe something like "three deserters are more likely to pull off a townwin
in LYLO.

I do not

want

a coinflip, Dry-fit.

[Zekrom25]

But Zek, as amateur as he is, genuinely looks like amateur scum rather than amateur town. He doesn't react like town, his ideas aren't town. There's deception in his posts. They're poorly disguised, but it doesn't read like genuine attempts to help town win. I don't see him as a policy lynch. But I don't see him as scum.

@Paschendale is this your reaction to post # 372 ?

[Paschendale]

My reaction to that is that you're playing up your noobishness intentionally. You never referred to scum as "the mafia scum" before, nor is there any reason for you to think that you'll be night killed. You suck, but you're not retarded.

[Whiskers]

i probably may be night killed so the mafia scum may be waiting for a town to vote against another town

I actually laughed out loud.

[Kenobi]

i probably may be night killed so the mafia scum may be waiting for a town to vote against another town

I... wut.

There are so many things wrong with this.

Grammar and word choices aside (that's more RBD's area), you're probably one of the last on the list of people who'd be night-killed. The people with the most convincing arguments or the greatest content, the threats to the mafia are the ones they're likely to kill off.

The whole point of the mafia is to get town to vote off other town; there's no 'may' about it.

any town that vote another town would be MyLo, so i guess next thing to do may be to let myself be scum bait ( those that vote against town would have to be scum ) this is an open invitation to vote against what could be a town

Town voting against town is not MyLo, not at this point in the game. Mylo only happens when the mafia have majority (or equality, iirc).
Letting yourself become scum bait? What does that even

mean

?

This whole post stinks to high heaven. Of what, I'm not certain whether it's more scum or newb, but it's certainly a bit of both.

[TierShift]

But Tiershift, Tiershift doesn't have that excuse either way.

He's been consistently against progress the whole day

, has relied on crap arguments, and

generally gives reads that look strategic rather than genuine.

I take offense by the bolded. This is pretty damn fucking untrue, I have consistently been trying to move the day forward (eg attacking you and whiskers to get a read on you two formed, pressuring cxinlee and seeing him being scummy as a result of and more) and you using this on me with all the lurkers around makes no fucking sense. The part in italics also remains unexplained. Your arguments have become worse and worse and it seems like you're making it all up.
Stop offending me and explain your arguments.

[Maxous]

vote: Zekrom25

I'm not super-confident he's scum but it's plausible enough to lynch.
He's been under the spotlight for a while now and I don't see a town reaction out of him.

[Whiskers]

vote: Zekrom25

I'm not super-confident he's scum but it's plausible enough to lynch.
He's been under the spotlight for a while now and I don't see a town reaction out of him.

Whoa man, careful.
He might be potentially town.
Also maybe probably the nightkill.

Why don't you wait until town starts voting town, bro?
Jeez, it's like you don't know how to play.

[Espeonage]

Vote Count

cxinlee:

Aj The Epic, Whiskers, Bulbazak

Zekrom25:

Kenobi, cxinlee, Rainbowdash, Maxous

TierShift:

Empking, Dry-fit, Paschendale

Empking:

TierShift

Not Voting:

Psyche, Zekrom25

With 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynch.

Deadline: 29th Jan, 1:30pm (AusEDT)

Can we tone down the hostility please. Thanks.

[TierShift]

vote: Zekrom25

I'm not super-confident he's scum but it's plausible enough to lynch.
He's been under the spotlight for a while now and I don't see a town reaction out of him.

Whoa man, careful.
He might be potentially town.
Also maybe probably the nightkill.

Why don't you wait until town starts voting town, bro?
Jeez, it's like you don't know how to play.

[Kenobi]

vote: Zekrom25

I'm not super-confident he's scum but it's plausible enough to lynch.
He's been under the spotlight for a while now and I don't see a town reaction out of him.

Whoa man, careful.
He might be potentially town.
Also maybe probably the nightkill.

Why don't you wait until town starts voting town, bro?
Jeez, it's like you don't know how to play.

That's the first time in a long time something on the internet has actually made me laugh out loud. *applauds*

[Dry-fit]

Pasch is probably right about what he's saying in 378.

Unvote
Vote: Zekrom25.

Let's do this.

[Paschendale]

Fine, Zek goes first.

[/b]Unvote
Vote: Zekrom[/b]

L-1

[Zekrom25]

@Mod please tell them the mistake that they are making.

[Rainbowdash]

If that's an IC claim we actually may want to go massclaim route because as I said, im cleared too on multiple levels, especially if we massclaim early (like by end of D2). This could be a "me theory" jackpot.

[Paschendale]

Fine, Zek goes first.

[/b]Unvote
Vote: Zekrom[/b]

L-1

Unvote
Vote: Zekrom

[Zekrom25]

well you all are about to mis-lynch a town

[Zekrom25]

Vote: cxinlee

[Paschendale]

If that's an IC claim we actually may want to go massclaim route because as I said, im cleared too on multiple levels, especially if we massclaim early (like by end of D2). This could be a "me theory" jackpot.

If it's an IC claim, the mod should be confirming it. I don't think it is.

[Zekrom25]

currently this mistake needs RQS/PoE before it becomes a MyLo situation ( like with my first mafia game where the town loses after mis-lynching me )

[Psyche]

waht

[Kenobi]

currently this mistake needs RQS/PoE before it becomes a MyLo situation

Just wondering, do you actually know what these acronyms

mean

?

[Zekrom25]

the town lost when they mis-lynched on day 1

Mod: am i allowed to post a link to my first mafia game?

Only if the game is over.

[Zekrom25]

RQS - random questions
PoE - proved evidence ???