NY 170: Georgetown II (Game Over)

[Nobody Special]

by the way this is the part where we summon votes from the Netherworld of the Townbloc and wagon emogirl fo realz

lessgo

Ageor, can I convince you to vote Bulbazak? Your vote on kaboom isn't going to accomplish anything.

WRONG, FRIEND-O

TOWNBLOC HO

Brian, pay closer attention. Thanks.

[Garmr]

I'm sorry Brian but the only read I got was Garmr early town read which you agreed with evidence is it possible to get a quick reads list.

1.would a scum buddy bust so hard on another this early on in the way bulb did? I don't think so.

Why not? They will get a ton of towncred for it, and in a mountainous game, will make it easier for them to slide by.

But bussing a buddy on day 1 is stupid as fuck because people will look for it. It's way better to leave it to day 3 or 4 and gradually build up the bus. It requires both players to look town through but when your nail scumbuddy this way you look so much fucking townier

What I saw was sarcasm and a bait where brian voted him for a reaction and Aegor omgused. Even through Aegor vote was suss. The way you reacted and voted Aegor was even more suss.

Well, this is an interesting conclusion.

Was I right through.

[Bulbazak]

I, for example, thought mountainous games were games where town outnumbered scum by a larger amount than the typical 1:3 ratio.

Oh, is it common for mountainous games to have more townies than usual?[/spoiler]

I assumed they did due to the word "mountainous". It seemed that way in the other mountainous game I played, but maybe I was under the wrong impression.

[Huntress]

Vote Count 1.9

Chevre (8) - OhGodMyLife, Garmr, emogirl123, Maestro, Tebow, Sotty7, Aegor, Nobody Special,
emogirl123 (5) - Bulbazak, Brian Skies, Albert B. Rampage, Maenara, kabooooom
Garmr (2) - emeraldemon, The Goodfather
Nobody Special (1) - yessiree
The Goodfather (1) - Slandaar

Not voting (2) - Acidic_TACO, Chevre


With nineteen players alive, it takes ten votes to lynch.

Deadline for Day One is Tuesday, 4th February 20.00 GMT, (in (expired on 2014-02-04 20:00:00)).

[Slandaar]

Kabs what do you think about Aegor claiming scum near the start of the game?

[Garmr]

today it's garmr can't be scum because it's his birthday day.

[Albert B. Rampage]

VOTE: Chevre

[Albert B. Rampage]

I haven't really followed the last 2 pages and am feeling distant from this game, I don't know why I can't get invested. Chevre's posts are scummy and I'm fine with his lynch. Hopefully we strike gold here and I'll get more motivated.

[yessiree]

HOLY FUCK NO ONE HAMMERS UNTIL I MAKE MY POST

[Tebow]

Albert's playing as per the Lord Gurgi scum strategy, apart from without the 'be super town to start with' part.

[Tebow]

Actually I'll

unvote

, because i need to think about this. Albert's vote for Chevre is scummy for exactly the same reason's Chevre's vote for emo was (except, I suppose, that Chevre is actually scummy and Emo wasn't).

[OhGodMyLife]

I think Albert is town. I have experienced the same malaise in some of my recent games. His emogirl vote was kinda scummy but his Chevre vote is good and is no reason to abandon the wagon.

[yessiree]

Spoiler: Aegor

Aegor {
#77 null
#89 null

Aegor.townLean(); // #93 no response to Acidic_TACO's #90
Aegor.townLean(); // #117 follow up on pressuring Garmr, better response than NS in regard to set-up spec

Aegor.townLean(); // #129 valid reason to keep vote on Garmr

Aegor.townLean(); // #277, good vote
}

Spoiler: emogirl123

emogirl123 {
pre-game shitstorm = null
emogirl123.townLean(); // #108 prying info from Garmr with vote noted, this is a better opening than Bulbazak's, my slot's, Slandaar's, Acidic_TACO's, and Nobody_Special's opening so far

set-up spec null

emogirl123.scumLean(); // #131, still voting Garmr while calling Aegor's attack on Garmr discrediting

// #133, honestly, I don't know what to make of this emogirl123 vs. Bulbazak, if emogirl hasn't made #131, it would have been easier for me to judge, but emogirl was STILL voting Garmr when she just suddenly switched to voting Bulbazak. But it's not scummy since, daymn, ASSOCIATION TELL, on page 6, ASSOCIATION TELL ON PAGE FUCKING SIX

Not gonna discard the possibility of scum vs scum yet, but both of them are not too towny-looking at this point

emogirl123.scumLean(); // #136, hmmm... you were on that toxic Garmr wagon until Bulbazak posted #132

emogirl123.scumLean(); // #144, please explain, you were the initial driving force on the Garmr wagon, and you didn't do anything as to stop further momentum from building until Bulbazak questioned you
}

Spoiler: The Goodfather

The Goodfather {
// dam I didn't know this guy existed until #329, prob town anyway meh
}

Spoiler: Sotty7

Sotty7 {
Sotty7.townLean(); // #52
Sotty7.townLean(); // #61 clarifies when he is able to contribute, and calls out on Maenara, town motivation

// #87 is a much better approach than Bulbazak's #80

Sotty7.townLean(); // #141, echoing my opinion on Bulbazak's use of association spec this early
}

Spoiler: Garmr

Garmr {
if ( #18 & #20 & #25 & #27.isReactionTest() == true ) {
Garmr.townLean();
// blatant misrep in pre-game
} else {
ignoreList.Append(Garmr);
// scrub
}

if ( #39.isReactionTest() != true ) {
ignoreList.Append(Garmr);
// more misrep, holy fuck this guy
}

Garmr.townLean(); // #55 questions in response to Sotty7 are good
if ( !(#62.isIntentionalStupidity()) ) ignoreList.Append(Garmr); // #62

Garmr.townLean(); #94 for voting Acidic_TACO, same though process as me, as for last line,

nah

Garmr.scumLean(); // #124, #127 weird aggression on Aegor for Aegor's vote on him, misrep a vote for pressure and jumping straight to the conclusion of a scum vote
}

Spoiler: OhGoodMyLife

OhGodMyLife {
// #245, OhGodMyLife's stance noted

// #392, please state any other reasons why Chevre is scummy when you voted for her other than the fact that his vote on emogirl is scummy by a mile
}

Spoiler: Maenara

Maenara {
// #57 what the fuck? but null
// #65 WEAK reply to Sotty7, but considering the game hasn't started, null

Maenara.scumLean(); // #230 using POST COUNT STATS as an excuse to vote emogirl rather than using the reasons as to WHY SHE IS SCUMMY is a GODDAM LAZYASS ATTITUDE AND A BIG FUCKING SCUMTELL

Maenara.scumLean(); // #232, wrong, {content, and interaction with players} = info for town, thus she's doing town a favor by providing information, which in turn, is DOING SOMETHING FOR TOWN WHCH, BTW, IS SOMETHING

YOU

HAVEN'T DONE
}

Spoiler: Bulbazak

Bulbazak {
Bulbazak.scumLean(); // #80 attacking an easy target in a way that does not generate clean and meaningful discussion, #78 is not an alignment-indicative tell

Bulbazak.scumLean(); // #132, another lazy ass jump on a forming wagon with an ASSOCIATION TELL thrown in, ASSOCIATION TELL, on page 6, ASSOCIATION TELL ON PAGE FUCKING SIX

Bulbazak.readReset(); // #139, I see your reasoning for stating an association now, but I doubt the possibility of a scum theatre in pre-game, and connecting emogirl to Garmr this early is a stretch, should resort to other means to scumhunt

// #142, disagree, as seen in 64

Bulbazak.townLean(); // #164 strong conviction and declaration on the pursuit of scumread

// #275, fucking annoying quote wall, not gonna read that shit
}

Spoiler: me slot

yessiree/WBOCampfire1104 {
#69 is pretty bad I'm not gonna lie
#85 ...nah
}

Spoiler: Maestro

Maestro {
Maestro.townLean(); // #119 voting Maenara

Maestro.townLean(); // #151, #154, #156, #157, agree with his reasoning on the emogirl attack

// blah blah blah town reading you blha blah blah
}

Spoiler: Chevre

Chevre {
// #311, lol...

// #323, only part I don't understand is the call on emogirl being suspicious for doing wierd things with people, rest of the logic understood, still NULL for me

// gut says town
}

Spoiler: Albert B. Rampage

Albert B. Rampage {
Albert_B_Rampage.scumLean(); // #212 go home

Albert_B_Rampage.scumLean(); // #293, "overconfident", nah, that's you for being happy with an emogirl lynch

also, voting someone because he/she is being oversonfident,

Albert_B_Rampage.scumLean(); // #293, because {reasons}

// #299, nah, Maenara is bad, totally, and you're bad for saying Maenara isn't bad, because {reasons}

Albert_B_Rampage.scumLean(); // #320, go home, do you know there is this thing called ISO and did you know you can do a Ctrl+F (on windows), or Command+F (on mac) to search for keywords (hint: maenara) while in someone's ISO. HOLY SHIT TECHNOLOGY IS SO USEFUL (hint: #261)
}

Spoiler: Brian Skies

Brian Skies {
Brian_Skies.scumLean(); // #voting the top wagon when you haven't read the fucking thread? what the fuck are you doing?

// Brian Skies, what the fuck are you doing? what's the fucking point of catching up and responding in chunks? like what the fuck? did you at least skim read the entire thread before going into nitty-gritty details? Mafia game content is a stream of consciousness and you can't just chop it up into pieces and look at each individual chunk discretely.
}

Spoiler: Tebow

Tebow {
Tebow.townLean(); // #98 calls out on Slandaar

// #208 don't know what to make of Tebow's stance on the emo v. bulb exchange

sortQueue.Append(Tebow);

// #254 Tebow's stance noted, but he is on my sort later list
}

Spoiler: Slandaar

Slandaar {
Slandaar.scumLean(); // as of #97, only seen set-up spec from him, no actual engagement with players, no pressure, no vote

Slandaar.scumLean(); // #209, go home

Slandaar, townLean(); // #467 agree with your first sentence
}

Spoiler: Acidic-TACO

Acidic_TACO {
is ( #90.isReactionTest() ) { // jumping on an opening with a weak stance
null
} else {
scumLean();
}

// as for #353, he is still a scumlean
}

Spoiler: emeraldemon

emeraldemon {
as of #120 he is still not engaged, but not enough for a scumLean
}

Spoiler: kabooooom

kabooooom {
#7 - town eagerness
#10 - scrub
kabooooom.townLean();
ignoreList.Append(kabooooom); // until he posts something worth reading

// #337, kewlbeanz
}

Spoiler: Noboday Special

Nobody Special {
Nobody_Special.scumLean(); // so basically you just made a post and agreed the post you just made is useless

#112 null

#175, LOOK AT THAT SHAMELESS HOP, BIG NULL, but you're probably town anyways so meh

#309, NAH you just suck

#351, NS, emogirl is very experienced with mafia, I can endorse her skills, but I can't say I can read her accurately yet
}

[yessiree]

pleeeeeeeeeeeeeeeease no more

my head is gonna explode

[Aegor]

As much as I appreciate the detailed comments, that formatting is...not ideal. Also, who are your top scumreads?

[yessiree]

ABR, Maenara, emogirl, in order of decreasing confidence

[Tebow]

I think Albert is town. I have experienced the same malaise in some of my recent games. His emogirl vote was kinda scummy but his Chevre vote is good and is no reason to abandon the wagon.

Oh, the malaise thing is, of course, sometimes true. It wouldn't be a useful and common scumtactic if it weren't.

The problem with the Chevre vote is that it implies that jumping on emogirl without really adding anything new due to a self-proclaimed difficulty with getting going is scummy enough to vote for, whilst also, y'know, doing the same thing.

[yessiree]

ABR can give people the malaise all he wants, as long as he's being USEFUL by explaining his thought process, which he isn't

[OhGodMyLife]

The problem with the Chevre vote is that it implies that jumping on emogirl without really adding anything new due to a self-proclaimed difficulty with getting going is scummy enough to vote for, whilst also, y'know, doing the same thing.

Not really. Chevre isn't scummy for jumping on emo without adding anything new. Chevre is scummy for jumping on emo while at the same time equivocating about not having a good read on emo but still insisting its a good vote (or some other BS idk I'm at work and not going back to read right now), then bailing on the vote pretty much the moment the heat got turned up on it.

[Bulbazak]

I haven't really followed the last 2 pages and am feeling distant from this game, I don't know why I can't get invested. Chevre's posts are scummy and I'm fine with his lynch. Hopefully we strike gold here and I'll get more motivated.

This is not a good reason to put someone at L-1. In your own words, how are Chevre's posts scummy?

[OhGodMyLife]

I haven't really followed the last 2 pages and am feeling distant from this game, I don't know why I can't get invested. Chevre's posts are scummy and I'm fine with his lynch. Hopefully we strike gold here and I'll get more motivated.

This is not a good reason to put someone at L-1. In your own words, how are Chevre's posts scummy?

I'm finding it hard to put into words how much I dislike this post.

[OhGodMyLife]

I really wish we had more than one lynch in a day because there are at least three people I'd like to see hang right now

[yessiree]

I haven't really followed the last 2 pages and am feeling distant from this game, I don't know why I can't get invested. Chevre's posts are scummy and I'm fine with his lynch. Hopefully we strike gold here and I'll get more motivated.

This is not a good reason to put someone at L-1. In your own words, how are Chevre's posts scummy?

I'm finding it hard to put into words how much I dislike this post.

wtf? it's a perfectly good post and a perfectly valid inquiry

[OhGodMyLife]

What exactly constitutes a "good" reason to put someone at L-1 then? And with so little content from Chevre in the first place I wouldn't be surprised if anyone found it difficult to come up with something novel and new about him. That ground has already been covered. Asking for how he's scummy "in your own words" is a trap. Basically there is no good answer to Bulba's query, it seems plain to me that he'll now have a scumread on ABR based on whatever answer he could come up, or his lack of an answer.

[Huntress]

bump