NY 170: Georgetown II (Game Over)

[Sotty7]

I'm sorta caught up but I am going to set a V/LA until the 15th because I have an intense next few days of work. I will try to squeeze in some reading if I get the time, but I will be back.

[Albert B. Rampage]

Whenever someone replaces in and has the exact same reads as their predecessor, I'm automatically suspicious. The Zdenek vote is such a throwaway, it seems like a red herring to encourage town to vote for me.

Recap:

-Tony is voting from me when he replaces in
-He votes Zdenek as an RVS
-Comes back to me

Apparently, I contradicted myself because I was confident and I said emogirl's overconfidence was scummy, so that makes me scummy. Yeah, right.

Unvote, vote Tony PF

[Tony PF]

Whenever someone replaces in and has the exact same reads as their predecessor, I'm automatically suspicious. The Zdenek vote is such a throwaway, it seems like a red herring to encourage town to vote for me.

Recap:

-Tony is voting from me when he replaces in
-He votes Zdenek as an RVS
-Comes back to me

Apparently, I contradicted myself because I was confident and I said emogirl's overconfidence was scummy, so that makes me scummy. Yeah, right.

Unvote, vote Tony PF

Then explain your reads. So far the most explanation I've seen has been, "my reads are usually right on the money".

[Nobody Special]

Questions for everyone!

@Nobody Special

Why are you voting ABR? Also, you voted Chevre yesterday, what made you decide he's town?

I am voting ABR because he's scum.

I don't recall saying that I thought Chevre was town, I'm just not voting him at the moment because, sadly, I have but one vote.

[Albert B. Rampage]

Garmr what do you think of emo's replacement?

[emeraldemon]

Questions for everyone!

@Nobody Special

Why are you voting ABR? Also, you voted Chevre yesterday, what made you decide he's town?

I am voting ABR because he's scum.

I don't recall saying that I thought Chevre was town, I'm just not voting him at the moment because, sadly, I have but one vote.

I do not understand how a discussion of my meta vs. ABR's meta is in any way useful.

That's not really what the discussion is about.

What is your read on Chevre?

Ineffectual town.

Ineffectual town is still town yes?

[Garmr]

Garmr what do you think of emo's replacement?

I want my little emo back (shows a picture of a emo pony) but in all seriousness I don't see the effort. If it wasn't for emo's latter plays and all the content she provided to look over I would jump on this guys wagon.

[inHimshallibe]

I have no read on TonyPF. I probably didn't even read Bulba's case, or I forgot.

[inHimshallibe]

Garmr what do you think of emo's replacement?

I want my little emo back (shows a picture of a emo pony) but in all seriousness I don't see the effort. If it wasn't for emo's latter plays and all the content she provided to look over I would jump on this guys wagon.

Kinda contradictory, possible poor diction.

[Garmr]

diction

Well i'm not known for perfect English -_- and I'm allowed to change my mind about past events as well.

[inHimshallibe]

diction

Well i'm not known for perfect English -_- and I'm allowed to change my mind about past events as well.

Just cataloging.

[Tony PF]

Garmr what do you think of emo's replacement?

I want my little emo back (shows a picture of a emo pony) but in all seriousness I don't see the effort. If it wasn't for emo's latter plays and all the content she provided to look over I would jump on this guys wagon.

I didn't think there was a wagon on me. I thought the wagon was on ABR.

[Garmr]

Garmr what do you think of emo's replacement?

I want my little emo back (shows a picture of a emo pony) but in all seriousness I don't see the effort. If it wasn't for emo's latter plays and all the content she provided to look over I would jump on this guys wagon.

I didn't think there was a wagon on me. I thought the wagon was on ABR.

me:You become correctness nazi when you're hungry
-gives you a snickers-
me: better
you:better

[Tony PF]

Garmr what do you think of emo's replacement?

I want my little emo back (shows a picture of a emo pony) but in all seriousness I don't see the effort. If it wasn't for emo's latter plays and all the content she provided to look over I would jump on this guys wagon.

I didn't think there was a wagon on me. I thought the wagon was on ABR.

me:You become correctness nazi when you're hungry
-gives you a snickers-
me: better
you:better

That's pretty funny, but we need to stay on topic.

[Aegor]

Any response to any of this?


Everyone: Top three scumreads. Go.

Zekrom
Nobody Special
kabooooom

[Bulbazak]

Everyone: Top three scumreads. Go.

TonyPF
Garmr
Aegor

[Garmr]

thor
chev
bulba

[Garmr]

Everyone: Top three scumreads. Go.

TonyPF

Garmr

Aegor

I think you should push for my lynch over the other 2 if your scum reading me. You start pushing hard now and we will have our little back and forth town see's your scum and i'm town you get lynched we have a scum flip then I get night killed.

[Zekrom25]

top 3 probably would be

Aegor
Garmr
Nobody Special

[Huntress]

OhGodMyLife has been prodded.

[Tony PF]

Everyone: Top three scumreads. Go.

ABR
Aegor
Zekrom

[Zdenek]

If that was directed to me, I don't what you are asking.

do you have any reads on ABR, Brian & Slandaar ?

Scum, Null, Dead.

Nice to see that you aren't even trying to sort people.

Well, okay, but you should know that your case on Emogirl is more of a case for her being town than one for her being scum.

Why's that?

Well, the way I see it is that Emo thought that Garmr was town, and that the reasons for your vote were bullshit. Even if you don't think that making bad cases is scummy, on page 6 of a large game, this is a pretty fair reason to vote for someone. It is true that she was defending Garmr, but I don't think that it all that likely to come from a scum buddy that early in the game. To me her thought process is rather transparent - she thought that Garmr was town, she saw that he'd be easy to attack, she attacked the person who attacked him. I agree that is weird that she talks about trying to town-tell, but I have a hard time seeing it as scummy. Especially in combination with her desire to maintain a wagon on herself. It really sounds like she was genuinely trying to accomplish something.

it seems like a red herring to encourage town to vote for me.

I don't buy this at all.

Garmr

Aegor

Could you two write a couple of sentences explaining these ones?



My three preferred lynched are still Zekrom, Inhim and ABR.

[Albert B. Rampage]

TonyPF and Zdenek are scum together, I don't know who the third is.

[Zdenek]

Copy and paste

Code: Select all

[b]Vote: ABR[/b]

[Huntress]

bump