Ok, applying some wisdom to the situation because I can foresee what is going to happen: I will never get a full analysis post out fast enough this early in the game with so many players.
The following players I have yet to analyze:
Anx, DG, ZD, Snow, Chem, Yates, Mastin, Matt
I will just briefly summarize and get back to digesting.
Anx -- Has a wishy washy voting profile but yet is willing to accuse others for the same thing. Reads like insincere town posturing
scum
DG -- Bad game start re BJC. Over-defensive. Bad game logic. Rusty & R/L issues. Sincere. I want to give him the benefit of the doubt but he seriously needs to improve.
null
ZD -- Very strong entrance. Strong and consistent scum hunting effort. INCREDIBLE FAKE VIG! Helped the town tremendously. I strongly disagree with Talah read but that's all I disagree with; the guy is playing a near perfect town game.
strong town
Snow -- Excellent DG catches with blending & over-defensive tone. Excellent reads. Another great DG catch falsely elevating BJC read. Needs to widen scope but so far :goodposting:.
town
Chem -- Can't understand Rach read; oversimplistic. Good game logic. Totally sincere +town reaction to vig.
very strong town
Yates -- Undigested but incredible game-wide scope. Don't agree with all reads but at least 75%+. Errrm, what? No vote? Meh. I guess there is only so much 1 guy can do at one time. Can't fault Nero here though.
null to town
Mastin -- Terrible initial game reads with Thad, Aptil & Luca. Bad vote switch backpedal. Strong defense post #114 but even this does not eclipse the very bad entrance. Talah seems wise to pull back and let Mastin continue and I will do the same.
leaning scum
Matt -- Reads post #133. Agree with reads except Rach. Noting Matt-Pere interactions. Not voting. Good start that I agree with. Needs more.
null to town
Nero -- Welcome back man. Obviously you will deliver more than a naked vote.
null
Scum:
Rach, Luca, Aptil, Doc, Anx, Mastin
Need to see that Smudge replace. I expect to see some of the low posters to improve their rating. I expect that there is at least one town/null read that is playing a great scum game so far; *glares at Thad*