Mini 1536 - Silph Co. Reverse Mafia (Game Over)

[TierShift]

I had no idea I'd still be alive

AJ what were you doing at pasch's dead body? Hugging him goodbye?

VOTE: aj the epic

[cxinlee]

Why would you be dead?

[TierShift]

I thought the hammer fell before deadline.

I don't think this game is wild enough to have 2 third party members, so whiskers is probs lying.

Current status:

Kenobi is obvtown to me, Dry-fit is unccd mason. And Whiskers I presume is third party.

Lynch pool is tier shift/cheery/bulba/ajtheepic

Do you think whiskers is SK or town?

[cxinlee]

sk

[cxinlee]

just realised, if whiskers is sk its auto lose for town, assuming. 3 mafia

[cxinlee]

We have to assume whiskers isn't sk >.>

[cxinlee]

actually regardless of whether whiskers is sk town loses if 3 mafia are alive (.

Whiskers is sk yes

[TierShift]

Why do we lose?

If SK doesn't shoot town and we lynch AJ it's all good.

Unless AJ is SK which ugh....

[Kenobi]

Why immediately go for Aj? I'd like to see reasons before a vote, especially at this stage in the game.

[TierShift]

I watched pasch and aj was the only one to go there.

[TierShift]

Massclaim?

Whiskers, you need to fullclaim anyway.

[cxinlee]

My role is apparent to all.

Eh need to think before I vote.

[Cheery Dog]

Why immediately go for Aj? I'd like to see reasons before a vote, especially at this stage in the game.

Have you not read the end of day 2? Or his post?

[TierShift]

Guys do you think AJ can be SK who shot pasch? Just doesn't make sense to me.

[cxinlee]

Assuming you're watcher, whiskers is sk and aj is mafia

[TierShift]

I'm still having a non-SK feel from whiskers.

[Aj The Epic]

Bullshit, I'm VT and have gone nowhere. You're lying, trying to get the main proponent of your lynch off your case. I asserted that you were lying about your role D3, saying you misplayed it if you actually HAD a watcher role and you then come back to claim I went and killed Pasche, someone who firmly listed me as town? Please.

VOTE: Tiershift

Seriously. This shit didn't get lynched because his scum buddies were pulling to keep the full band and make an easier game. Why else do you think the town fails ONE LYNCH this entire game, and it's against one of the people who has been scummier than the alleyways of Chicago all game? Tiershift has just knowingly lied to gambit an easy lynch and win.

[TierShift]

That's why I think you aren't SK but mafia. Because he thought you were town.

[Aj The Epic]

What? We already know the third party player. It's almost certain Whiskers made a kill last night, and my guess is that it was Pasche. Whiskers and Pasche argued back and forth for a while, so it would make much more sense for you to kill Max. If Whiskers was an SK, she'd have to be hunting those she thought to be scum.

So Whiskers, can you confirm who you killed? If I'm right, we can finish this business with Tiershift and be done with this scumbag.

[Bulbazak]

I also find it suspicious that Tier claims a guilty only in Mylo. If Aj is town and we lynch him, then scum automatically wins. Normally I'm pretty gullible when it comes to claims, but this one just doesn't make sense to me. Whiskers has to be SK given the kill, so she's going to make the best choice for her to win the game, which means that if she killed Pasch, she's going to vote Tier, whereas if she didn't, she'll vote Aj. I think we should wait for her to come in and then sheep for the best possibility of lynching scum.

[cxinlee]

In that case bulba, its auto lose for town

[Natirasha]

Vote Count 4.2

Pokemon Mystery Dungeon Time/Darkness/Sky are the most profound games in the franchise.

Bulbazak(0):

cxinlee(0):

Dry-fit(0):

Aj The Epic(1):

Tiershift

Kenobi(0):

Cheery Dog(0):

Tiershift(1):

AJ the Epic

Whiskers(0):

No Lynch(0):

Not Voting:

Bulbazak, cxinlee, Dry-fit, Kenobi, Cheery Dog, Whiskers

With eight alive, it takes five to lynch.

(expired on 2014-04-11 21:00:00)

[Cheery Dog]

In that case bulba, its auto lose for town

We could end up with a prisoner's dilemma.

The way you're continuing about being autolose for town while there is a slim possibly it's not (as the mafia would know Whiskers has claimed third party), makes me think you just want more apathy and my townread on you is dodgy.

But for town to still win without resulting in a prisoner's dilemma. (or worse a king maker)
scum lynch today
whiskers to kill scum tonight. (we assume mafia decide not to kill whiskers while there are 2 members alive, so one townie dies)
We are now at 3:1:1 - lynch mafia/sk, preferably mafia as if it was wrong, the PA still comes in.
SK kills town
We lynch SK = town win.

[Bulbazak]

In that case bulba, its auto lose for town

How so? It's in Whiskers best interest to lynch scum as well, since if she doesn't, and we lynch town, she'll lose. In that case, she'll be voting scum by necessity. We lynch scum, rely on Whiskers for a cross kill, and then we're hopefully in better shape come tomorrow.

[TierShift]

In that case bulba, its auto lose for town

We could end up with a prisoner's dilemma.

The way you're continuing about being autolose for town while there is a slim possibly it's not (as the mafia would know Whiskers has claimed third party), makes me think you just want more apathy and my townread on you is dodgy.

But for town to still win without resulting in a prisoner's dilemma. (or worse a king maker)
scum lynch today
whiskers to kill scum tonight. (we assume mafia decide not to kill whiskers while there are 2 members alive, so one townie dies)
We are now at 3:1:1 - lynch mafia/sk, preferably mafia as if it was wrong, the PA still comes in.
SK kills town
We lynch SK = town win.

This is incorrect in the most likely case of 3 mafia.
It's creepy that you are assuming two.