Newbie 1488: Igloo-Town Tragedy (Game Over)

[jklash12]

I was agreeing with who he was voting. obviously I can't agree with why he voted because there is no explanation.

[jklash12]

Dawn to Dusk- Do you think you unvoting DDD had something to do with his vote on Private?

[innocentvillager]

DDD voting private is very suspicious to me. Especially since I just I unvoted them. There were much better options than a randomized vote (due to there being better options) and I kinda gave Private an alibi until further notice, so I see no reason.

VOTE: Debonaire Danny DiPietro

I don't like this vote; it seems opportunistic and random.

UNVOTE: fused_shadows

[Zephyrus]

Could we do a day 1 no lynch by any chance?

We could, it's an awful idea though because it puts the numbers in scum's favor.

Hm... thanks, this actually helps us newbies know what strategies to look out for

[Billi bilaði]

So, two votes on each of the experienced players, and I think inactivity plays a part in that.
Then 2 votes on fused which is tied in the top inactivity space, and should be back from V/La.
Zephyrus, who keeps to the above players posting schedule, is voteless.
The rest has all broken the 10 post barrier.

So, coming to the end of week one - will we pick up the phase a bit, or will we be content to lynch from this group? (I, for one, would like to see more activity.)

[Billi bilaði]

Ah, didn't see page 5, but it doesn't change much.

[Randomnamechange]

Would have been nice if DDD explained his actions though

This is exactly why my vote is on him.

[Randomnamechange]

Okay, here are my most important reads.
Danny - weak scum
Innocent - weak scum
billi - strong town
jklash - medium-strong town
everyone else I have null reads on.

[Billi bilaði]

If it were the end of the day, and I had to vote for lynch, then the following list would be my vote-choice in descending order:

Debonair Danny DiPietro : Saying a lot of the "right" things, but not showing me that he is look for mafia.
PrivateI : Semi-experienced player who's trying not to say anything.
innocentvillager : Seems to have decided to lay low after the first rounds of attacks.
fused_shadows : Hardly said anything, and hasn't returned at specified time.
Zephyrus : Waiting for others to play. Not contributing.
randomidget : Playing the game. Will not get my vote at this time.
dawn_to_dusk : Playing the game. Will not get my vote at this time.
jklash12 : Playing the game. Will not get my vote at this time.

[jklash12]

Could we do a day 1 no lynch by any chance?

Going back to this. Zeph, when you asked this what did you have in mind? Did you actually want to no-lynch or did you want learn about the no-lynch strategies?

[Ser Arthur Dayne]

Prodding fused_shadows.

Edit: And PrivateI

[Ser Arthur Dayne]

Vote Count 1.04

• innocentvillager (2) -
  fused_shadows, PrivateI
  
• Debonair Danny DiPietro (2) -
  randomidget, dawn_to_dusk
  
• PrivateI (2) -
  Debonair Danny DiPietro, jklash12
  
• fused_shadows (1) -
  , Billi bilaði
  
• Billi bilaði (0) -
  
  
• randomidget (0) -
  
  
• jklash12 (0) -
  
  
• dawn_to_dusk (0) -
  
  
• Zephyrus (0) -
  
  
  
  
  
• Not Voting (2) – Zephyrus, innocentvillager

With 9 alive, it takes 5 to lynch.

Deadline is ~12AM EDT April 6
Countdown: (expired on 2014-04-06 00:00:00)

[/i][/area]

[Zephyrus]

Could we do a day 1 no lynch by any chance?

Going back to this. Zeph, when you asked this what did you have in mind? Did you actually want to no-lynch or did you want learn about the no-lynch strategies?

Someone already answered my question

[Zephyrus]

It's best to go with someone who is showing some scummy, I will cast my vote. Between DDD and IV...


VOTE: innocentvillager

[dawn_to_dusk]

Dawn to Dusk- Do you think you unvoting

Private (I never voted DDD)

had something to do with his vote on Private?

It had crossed my mind, yes, however, at the time I wasn't too sure either way.
Speaking of this, I would still like to know why you voted without saying anything. I don't care why as you could just copy paste the earlier answer, but I would like to know why.

[dawn_to_dusk]

Last sentence was dedicated at DDD

[PrivateI]

I think the vote count on Inovil is 3 or 4... gonna wait till we get a mod count since Im lazy

Zephyr, there has officially been a votecount posted, and you never gave us your thoughts. What do you think of InnocentVillager?

Irrelevant, IV's voters have been noted since they were trying to get that bandwagon started

It's best to go with someone who is showing some scummy, I will cast my vote. Between DDD and IV...


VOTE: innocentvillager

Zephyrus, I want an answer the instant you see this. This reads hypocritical in my view. Your reads are never irrelevant, and not giving them is SUPER scummy, as a general rule.

On that note, I'm still really flipping right now between who I like as scum. I see the DDD view, and I'm almost seeing Zephyr primarily for this reason. Does anyone else have thoughts on Zephyr, because I could be totally off.

[PrivateI]

DDD voting private is very suspicious to me. Especially since I just I unvoted them. There were much better options than a randomized vote (due to there being better options) and I kinda gave Private an alibi until further notice, so I see no reason.

VOTE: Debonaire Danny DiPietro

I don't like this vote; it seems opportunistic and random.

UNVOTE: fused_shadows

I'm not understanding the unvote without a subsequent vote. Is there a reason for this?

[Randomnamechange]

There wasn't a reason for IV's unvote and no revote Private.
I think the argument against Zephyr could be to do with the fact that he is still learning the ropes.

[Randomnamechange]

Guys, 2 days left so we really need to decide who to lynch.
I would like a DDD lynch, but would be ok with an innocentvillager lynch.

[jklash12]

Randomidget- we still have about a week left to decide on a lynch. Just under 7 days. You probably got mixed up with another one of your games.

[Billi bilaði]

fused logged in on friday but didn't see a reason to let us know he's alive, although his official V/LA was over. I would hammer him for this.
But, innocent has more posts in the game he's modding than in the game he's playing (both started on the same day), so, I'm gonna put him at L-1 now.

VOTE: innocentvillager

[Billi bilaði]

...On that note, I'm still really flipping right now between who I like as scum. I see the DDD view, and I'm almost seeing Zephyr primarily for this reason. Does anyone else have thoughts on Zephyr, because I could be totally off.

Zephyrus does not read as town to me.

[Debonair Danny DiPietro]

This seems as scummy as hell. You are basically saying you want us to follow you blindly into whatever you say. Give us one reason why we should do this a few days into Day 1, where you haven't even done anything particularly scummy?

Why wouldn't I want people to follow me? I generally think I'm going to be right and I generally want people to do what I say, hence I will play in such a way to increase the likeliness of that happening. It's Machiavellian but it's a game and one I always try to win.

No reasoning. Why?

Because I didn't want PrivateI to know why I voted so I could then evaluate what he did with the knowledge that the IC was watching him but not for what.

DDD voting private is very suspicious to me. Especially since I just I unvoted them. There were much better options than a randomized vote (due to there being better options) and I kinda gave Private an alibi until further notice, so I see no reason.

VOTE: Debonaire Danny DiPietro

Why on earth would I care that you just unvoted them?

[Ser Arthur Dayne]

Searching for a replacement for fused_shadows.