NY 170: Georgetown II (Game Over)

[inHimshallibe]

Whoops, didn't need the vc there.

[Thor665]

@Thor
I had a townread on garmr day 1, and the bulba flip makes garmr's fights with bulba feel more town. Check out 1409. This kinda makes me think Thesp [Discode [garmr]] is town.

Hurm...I could get behind this.
Wanna help me lynch PJ then?

Unvote: Thesp
Vote: Petroleumjelly

[emeraldemon]

VOTE: Petroleum Jelly

[Sotty7]

Stressful ass day at work and now I have to go to the dentist so this will be a flyby until probably late tues/weds.

PJ and Thesp are my top two. PJ's vote for Rainbow at deadline just felt big timing wise. Thesp mostly just because how HARD bulb was trying to link emo with his slot.

[Aegor]

VOTE: PetroleumJelly

Emogirl's memory should live on.

[Rainbowdash]

I will try and get resituated a bit over the next couple days. Still on the tail end of a cold and having almost a 12 hour work day where im suddenly pulled on a project with an ASAP due date did not do much to help me feel better.

[petroleumjelly]

I will not be voting until I have reread the game given the new information. Currently I can really only devote time to reading during my evening commute for the next couple nights (personal reasons), but I should be able to devote more time after Wednesday is over.

After the flip my top three suspects prior to any rereading were RainbowDash, Thesp, and Sotty7. I also think No Lynch should be at least considered today. Question: why did nobody bring this up at all yesterday? It should have been pretty much been one of the first topics of the Day. Scum naturally had no reasons to raise it because it was to their disadvantage, and given the supposed level of experience here I am still surprised it was never raised.

~

I have reread up to about page 10 and the interactions are now a

lot

more interesting. Bulbazak spent a fair bit of time trying to make an emogirl123-Garmr connection on the theory that Garmr was "scumming it up" (not well-explained), and then emogirl123 defended Garmr (with emogirl123 being willing to vote the first person to make an "actual case" on Garmr, as Bulbazak focused on). While Bulbazak originally voted for Garmr, emogirl123's continued posting on the issue got Bulbazak to instead focus on emogirl123 to the point of saying that Garmr could be left for later (see Post #186).

I do find interesting that during this discussion, Garmr voted emogirl123 while calling Bulbazak Town (see Post #193). Albert B. Rampage voted emogirl123 shortly after (see Post #212). I will need to think on whether a Bulbazak-Garmr-Albert. B Rampage scumteam would all be willing to vote for emogirl123 at that stage in the game like that. While I actually almost fell into the trap of thinking Bulbazak seemed overly concerned with linking emogirl123 to Garmr (as opposed to Garmr being linked to emogirl123), that is not a fair reading of the game given that emogirl123 had a post explicitly defending Garmr as a Townread, while Garmr did not have such a reaction towards emogirl123.

Maestro (now RainbowDash) actually seemed to be actively undermining Bulbazak's theory, but he similarly seemed to be trying to get emogirl123 to not go after Bulbazak, to the point of saying that Bulbazak "wasn't serious" about his Garmr-emogirl123 accusation (see Post #156). I can see this as scum trying to defuse what he thinks could be a highly unfavorable interaction for his team, and trying to give Bulbazak a safety valve (ala, getting Bulbazak to agree that he was just feeling around the game and wasn't

actually

trying to connect Garmr-emogirl123).

~

Sotty7 raising the "timing" of my vote earns an eye-squint. I finished reading the game on the day of the deadline. I was largely confined to reading the game on a cell phone while commuting back from work because I have been busy. My realistic choices by the time I finished reading were to vote my top suspect who also appeared to be able to be lynched while pushing for others voting less likely lynches change their votes (which I did), vote simply to achieve a lynch (Bulbazak), or to not vote at all / advocate No Lynch. Obviously I would look a lot better had I voted for Bulbazak, but I pretty much had no control over the "timing" of my vote unless I wanted to vote to lynch somebody before I had finished reading the entire game.

[Thor665]

Question: why did nobody bring this up at all yesterday?

I know I didn't because I am not particularly sold on no lynching as a strategy. I consider it weak wristed and kinda namby, and only to really make sense in 4 person lylo where you lack town reads or in situations involving PR interactions.

[petroleumjelly]

I suppose I should clarify:

I finished reading the game on the day of the deadline.

This is not technically true, but more how I remembered it, I suppose. I finished reading the game the night before the Mod-imposed deadline. However, since I was flying out the morning of the deadline,

my

deadline was the night I actually finished reading. I then made sure to vote before I went to bed (which ended up being the morning of the deadline). I then checked the thread again after waking up and, seeing nothing had changed, I left my vote where it was.

[kabooooom]

I m comfortable with pj, thesp or rainbowgul lynch.

[kabooooom]

vote:pj

[Aegor]

I want kab to die soooooooooooooooooooo bad.

[kabooooom]

I want kab to die soooooooooooooooooooo bad.

awwww...i feel sad for u!! cos thats not gonna happen!

but the opposite might happen!!

[emeraldemon]

kaboom, in our last game together you actually tried to build cases on people. If you are town, do you really want a reputation for only trying to hunt when you are scum?

[kabooooom]

kaboom, in our last game together you actually tried to build cases on people. If you are town, do you really want a reputation for only trying to hunt when you are scum?

nop. its just this game. i will never be able to catch up(also many times i dont get what the post means) . i tried but failed. now that we already have got 2 scums and there are couple of obv. town players, i will try to hunt scum by looking at their votes rather than their posts.

[Thor665]

Fear his mighty skillz!

[Thor665]

Though what votes made you like PJ as a lynch?

[Thor665]

(he said awkwardly transitioning from sarcasm to actual question.)

[kabooooom]

Though what votes made you like PJ as a lynch?

umm..i still havent done that. i suspect pj just cos of emogirl.

[Thor665]

Are you planning to look at votes today?

[kabooooom]

nop. it will take couple of days. i have thing i need to take care of irl.

[kabooooom]

things*

[Thor665]

Who do you consider the obv. town players?

[kabooooom]

sotty she was the first to vote ABR when he was lynched.
you cos bulb turned out to be scum. and emogul.

[Thor665]

Why not Highshroomish?