In post 2607, petroleumjelly wrote:1.)
Hmph. RainbowDash, can you please convince me you are Town? If you would prefer not to go that route, could you lay out a case for your suspicions?
If I knew how to prove myself town I would have done that sixty pages ago. Best is probably that I actually didn't vote ABR (who basically cost scum game as scum last time I was with him) or Bulb (who I am on somewhat shaky terms). Not too many reasons not to bus liability player or conflict player when they are under fire to start. Really though I haven't been trying to figure out why im obviously town or anything so its not something I can quickly answer.
What I said on Thor still stands. Its a little weaker due to Bulb interactions but he is still a top three pick. Thesp I have explained a bit today, but the fact that he was vote parked on what was a major compromise with two scum alive, and then at the first chance jumped off scum to vote me, after trying to get others to start the wagon, does not sit well.
Also, who are your Townreads and why? I normally do not like to ask players about Townreads in particular, but I tend to recall you focus on Townreads more than you focus on Scumreads.
How in depth are you looking for. I have already outlined why I think kab is town, and don't want to burn the last bit of the day trying to lay out ED/HS which I think speak for themselves.
Aegor basically comes down to his willingness to just jump around when scum has been up for a lynch twice. The lack of actually caring what happens makes me think that he is town because if he was scum I think that at least some point there would be more of trying to make something happen, or at least positioning himself for the future which I don't see having happened.
Finally, how exactly did you miss the modkill on Matias? I have serious troubles believing that, and I think you may well be claiming you missed it because you are aware that had you admitted to seeing it, your lack of argument for No Lynching suggests you purposefully did not bring the subject up because you knew it would help the Town.
It was not in the same post as the kill. I clicked on the topic, scrolled up until I saw the NK and then read from there. You know im too lazy to reread so never would have found it that way. It really took somepony mentioning that there was a modkill before I realized it happened at it just wasn't lack of finding a replacement.
