Mini 1566: Lunar Silver Star Story Complete (Game Over)

[PhDScar]

Sorry didn't like that.

[HighShroomish]

But... Then... Why didn't you put your vote back on me?

[Hello Kitty Creampuff]

UGH

[sangres]

kdub said he has a post incoming.

Why would you want to hammer before he makes the post.

[Kdub]

He gave the reasoning that he wanted to see if anyone counter claimed. I think the intent is the same: PR claim is no risk for scum!Jake, forcing him to claim a specific role is added risk for scum!Jake. Do you seriously not see that?

I don't think the intent is the same at all. You're talking about locking scum into a claim, which is fine. How does that have anything to do with looking for counterclaims?

You don't find it even the least bit sketchy that HS asked Jake for a role claim at the point that he did? I could get into why his reasons for asking for the claim were crap as well, but let's just start on this point for now.

context: shroom was pushing jake and jake already softclaimed.
looking at the ISO, it looks a lot more like shroom thinks he's calling jake's bluff rather than just straight up role fishing out of nowhere.

fun exercise:
assume shroom is scum and jake's town. why would shroom ask for a counterclaim? he knew he wouldn't get one.

kdub's case makes a lot less sense considering the context.

Ugh, did you not even read my post where I responded to this (which is what sangres and I have been arguing over)? Stuff like this is why I'm annoyed at this game, and you've generally been one of the better posters so far.

kdub continues to pull this thread even though sangres and i have repeatedly talked about this and it's really not that hard to understand. it's an untenable position, kdub knows it but he's pushing it anyway because he needs those mislynches

OK, let's think this through. You talked before about how I didn't join the Scar wagon when it got going, and I didn't join the Jake wagon either. Yet now, I "need those mislynches" even though I was the first one to vote HS. If you think I am scum, why was I not on those more viable wagons (at the time)? Do you think Scar/Jake are both scum too?

I'm VT whoever asked me to claim.
And yes Scar, that's what I was looking for. Kdub would be good, too.

Not a word about me up to now, but willing to vote me? Reasons?

I'm not claiming because 1) claiming my role is unlikely to change anyone's mind, and 2) my role is such that claiming will make it pretty much useless.

Final reads/comments if this is going to be my last post:
- I thought Jake was town before, and the last few pages have strengthened that read.
- HKC still feels town to me.
- sangres is a big question mark. The last exchange between me and them (re: HS's motivation) doesn't feel like one that should have happened the way it did if we were both town.
- I didn't like catboi, but Antihero is probably town.
- HS is still scum.
- Aegor's last few posts have felt a bit better to me. Not enough for me to give him a town read, but better.
- Dan/Scar need to answer for their votes on me. I get that there's deadline pressure, but there were three viable wagons (me/HS/SMP).

I will be here for about ~30 minutes, then I'll be out until the deadline.

Pedit: Scar, since you're here, why did you vote (and then unvote) me?

[Jake from State Farm]

kdub said he has a post incoming.

Why would you want to hammer before he makes the post.

Cause he's fucking scum but NOOOOOOOO you don't want to listen to me

[PhDScar]

Because I have no idea what is going on! I'm planning on finishing the day then replacing out, to give the mod and replacement more time.

[Kdub]

Because I have no idea what is going on! I'm planning on finishing the day then replacing out, to give the mod and replacement more time.

So you were just happy to hop on any wagon regardless of who it is?

[HighShroomish]

kdub said he has a post incoming.

Why would you want to hammer before he makes the post.

Cause he's fucking scum but NOOOOOOOO you don't want to listen to me

Did you guys not read my post? I asked if he was going to post. This was a good 15 minutes after he said he would have a post incoming...

[PhDScar]

no I have town reads that I don't want to lynch.
But I seen enough of the reasons to vote you to be down with it.
Just don't expect me to add anything or think.

[HighShroomish]

Well since Kdub is at L-2 now-

UNVOTE
VOTE: KDUB

[Kdub]

Before someone hammers, I'd like HS to explain why he thinks I'm scum.

[sangres]

kdub said he has a post incoming.

Why would you want to hammer before he makes the post.

Cause he's fucking scum but NOOOOOOOO you don't want to listen to me

Did you guys not read my post? I asked if he was going to post. This was a good 15 minutes after he said he would have a post incoming...

I think you're used fast-paced games.

15 minutes is not a ridiculously long time to write up a post. Especially when you're at L-1

I spent days at L-1 in the last game we played, writing multiple posts that took way more than 15 minutes each.

This is a different situation, but when a player is at L-1 and has indicated they're going to post, 15 minutes would actually be a pretty damn quick response.

Newbie Queue might be a little different. I'd probably stress not to hammer before I was able to make my post in that environment.

[HighShroomish]

Well, because I'm being lazy and don't want to quote it-
618
You actually try to force a thought process into my mouth. One that I didn't have. I did not want to out "more" PR's. Then you continually push that as a reason I am scum, and a major one. Off of a fake thought process you came up with.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
And now I'm off to bed. Be safe, be smart, make wise decisions.

[Kdub]

OK. I will note that you never responded to my follow-up question in that post, and never indicated a scum read of me for that up until the point where my wagon became a viable alternative to your own.

[Aegor]

This is a fucking shitshow.

[Kdub]

Well, I'm headed out. It's possible I may be able to check in briefly in ~30 minutes to answer last questions, but otherwise, I might be gone until the deadline.

[PhDScar]

Should I hammer?

[ActionDan]

it's possible that they are both town.

Scar would have been the better choice

[ActionDan]

it's possible that they are both town.

Scar would have been the better choice

[Aegor]

PhD, revote Shroom

[Jake from State Farm]

PhD, revote Shroom

This

[fferyllt]

it's possible that they are both town.

Scar would have been the better choice

agree with your first sentence. Still think PhDScar has posted from a town mindset, at least while he was caught up.

[sangres]

it's possible that they are both town.

Scar would have been the better choice

agree with your first sentence. Still think PhDScar has posted from a town mindset, at least while he was caught up.

sigh

[PhDScar]

see I prefer the KDUB wagon because i trust the people on that wagon more.