Open 558: Hope Plus 1 (GAME OVER!)

[Armageddon]

Nevermind. Found my role PM.

Unvote. I need to think this through since I am town affiliated.

VOTE: stabsinthe

Why do you feel the need to say that? Almost feels to me like you need to hide the fact your scum by saying you're town.

[ShadedMelee]

stabsinthe is this account an alt?

Also could you please use bold or vote tag while voting?

[Stabsinthe]

Nevermind. Found my role PM.

Unvote. I need to think this through since I am town affiliated.

VOTE: stabsinthe

Why do you feel the need to say that? Almost feels to me like you need to hide the fact you're scum by saying you're town.

It was a futile attempt to deflect Mafia attention from me by acting like a mentally handicapped player.

[Marcrell]

Hello everyone. Thought I might get first post since I was 9th to confirm, but thou decided to start while I was sleeping. Anyways, VOTE: Stabsinthe. One would naturally assume one was town due to a town majority, so if you didn't know your role, a likely reason to rethink your stance on the game is being mafia.

[Kodama]

Dude, are you ok?

VOTE: Armageddon

Oh I'm absolutely fine, how are you?

Welp, after much consideration and reading through I'm beginning to get town vibes which leads me to suspect that awest is town.

Unvote

Yeah, Ragnarok was just a random vote.

Unvote.

What the hell is this? How are you going to vote scum if you aren't voting? Sorcery?

If you're lacking in moxie you can always proxy your vote to us

[bubbajack8]

Welcome all to this lovely town. Unfortunetly for you there's a killer on the loose. As that spreads throughout the town votes are thrown each and every which way. I've never before seen such a volatile and hostile town. Will they be successful in lynching the scum? Or will they lynch the Macho doctor? Only time will tell. (Insert welcome to cool tv show name here)

Vote Count 0.2
Thomas: RaganokCometh, Kodama Stabsinthe: Armageddon, Marcrell Egg: wickedestjr tn5421: TheYankeeReaper Armageddon: tn5421 TheYankeeReaper: Egg awestfie: Thomas randomidget: ShadedMelee Not Voting: randomidget, awestfie, Stabsinthe
With 13 alive it is 7 to lynch
(expired on 2014-06-25 09:57:00)

[RagnarokCometh]

Nevermind. Found my role PM.

Unvote. I need to think this through since I am town affiliated.

What, did you originally think you were mafia affiliated?

UNVOTE:

VOTE: Stabsinthe

Current (weakish) reads:
Scum:stabsinthe>Thomas
Null:Armageddon, tn, random, egg, shaded, wicked, reaper
Town: Kodama>Marcrell>Awestfie

Kodama's been vocal and I like his logic so far. Same with awestfie.

Marcrell's only posted once but not only did it look genuine, he managed to push on stabs before I did for the same reasons I am.

[RagnarokCometh]

stabsinthe is this account an alt?

Also could you please use bold or vote tag while voting?

He didn't know about vote tags, so either a) he's an alt or b) he wants us to think he's an alt. What'd you hope to achieve by asking? I'm curious.

[Stabsinthe]

I think awestfie is a cop because cops are usually cautious about their votes and awestfie is not voting.

Randomidget, on the other hand, is just AFK.

My reads so far from Town > Mafia: awestfie > everyone else

[Stabsinthe]

Nevermind. Found my role PM.

Unvote. I need to think this through since I am town affiliated.

What, did you originally think you were mafia affiliated?

Yes, because of my RL personality and my tendencies to get accused of being Mafia affiliated in other forums due to innate lurking and/or too much talking. I'm pretty bad at not lurking if there are no substantial proof and people tend to vote me for lurking in the first day. I decided to stop lurking when I started playing in this forum.

Not sure if this breaks the site rules since it does not refer to any specific Mafia game.

[ShadedMelee]

I think awestfie is a cop because cops are usually cautious about their votes and awestfie is not voting.

Randomidget, on the other hand, is just AFK.

My reads so far from Town > Mafia: awestfie > everyone else

Townies generally do not try to find the doc. They try to find the scum. I can really see why you are being lynched when you talk too much.
I still think you are town because no scum would ever be such careless.

[RagnarokCometh]

Stabs, outing cop reads is very anti-town, since we don't really want cop to be outed and/or help mafia find cop.

Your reasoning isn't particularly sound since you changed your opinion /after/ you received your role pm.

Still, you answered, and Thomas hasn't even managed that much so far. (Probably due to time zones though.)
I don't think I'll achieve much by camping this except for stirring up an angry bees nest.

UNVOTE:
VOTE: Thomas

[RagnarokCometh]

Shaded, I see you're around.

Any chance you could answer my question in post#57?

[ShadedMelee]

Shaded, I see you're around.

Any chance you could answer my question in post#57?

I totally missed that sorry. Here it is:

stabsinthe is this account an alt?

Also could you please use bold or vote tag while voting?

He didn't know about vote tags, so either a) he's an alt or b) he wants us to think he's an alt. What'd you hope to achieve by asking? I'm curious.

I am asking that because his voting style in his post arouse suspicions in my mind and when i checked his meta i was surprised to find zero information. No previous posts. Even no newbie game.

[RagnarokCometh]

Thanks.

Any opinion on Thomas?

[Stabsinthe]

I think awestfie is a cop because cops are usually cautious about their votes and awestfie is not voting.

Randomidget, on the other hand, is just AFK.

My reads so far from Town > Mafia: awestfie > everyone else

Townies generally do not try to find the doc. They try to find the scum. I can really see why you are being lynched when you talk too much.
I still think you are town because no scum would ever be such careless.

I said COP. That means POLICE or, in this case, ALIGNMENT DETECTOR.

[RagnarokCometh]

Stabs, fairly sure that was a misnomer on shaded's part. He clearly meant cop.

[ShadedMelee]

Thanks.

Any opinion on Thomas?

Nope. Null. His two posts are insignificant imo. Why did you ask that? What is the problem with Thomas aside from not posting?

[Stabsinthe]

Thanks.

Any opinion on Thomas?

'Townish Vibes' might mean two things: he is feeling townish, or he picked up some information that could lead him to finding scum.
@RagnarokCometh: I see no reason why townies will not want to find out the cop's identity. While the Mafia would want to kill him, a doctor could protect him. On the other hand, finding the doctor is something townies will not want but the Mafia would like very well.

Cop found = free reads for Town = Town advantage.
Doc found = less protection on stuff = Mafia advantage.

@ShadedMelee: Some guy thought it was king of scummy that he got 'townish vibes'.

[ShadedMelee]

I said COP. That means POLICE or, in this case, ALIGNMENT DETECTOR.

Just curious: Are you an english teacher or some kind of education-affilated guy? That is the tone of those heathcliffs.
Yeah i meant Cop. Not Doc. Fck my keyboard if you want to

[RagnarokCometh]

His two posts are the problem. He made some reads which made no sense, so there's a decent chance he was faking reads to appear like he was scumhunting.

Stabs, if that was the case then cop would just claim. There's 2 macho doctors, if they both protect him then he isn't protected, meaning that he can't be reliably protected. If you think someone's cop in the future townread them off 'gut' please.

Gotta leave now.

[ShadedMelee]

@RagnarokCometh: I see no reason why townies will not want to find out the cop's identity. While the Mafia would want to kill him, a doctor could protect him. On the other hand, finding the doctor is something townies will not want but the Mafia would like very well.

Cop found = free reads for Town = Town advantage.
Doc found = less protection on stuff = Mafia advantage.

This is totally wrong as Rag explained. You can not rely on Docs in this setup. And even if one Doc dies, Cop becomes macho. So it does not work that way.

[Randomnamechange]

I think awestfie is a cop because cops are usually cautious about their votes and awestfie is not voting.

Randomidget, on the other hand, is just AFK.

My reads so far from Town > Mafia: awestfie > everyone else

Timezone difference.
We could have one doc claim and the cop claim, then the other doc protects the cop...

[Stabsinthe]

His two posts are the problem. He made some reads which made no sense, so there's a decent chance he was faking reads to appear like he was scumhunting.

Stabs, if that was the case then cop would just claim. There's 2 macho doctors, if they both protect him then he isn't protected, meaning that he can't be reliably protected. If you think someone's cop in the future townread them off 'gut' please.

Gotta leave now.

Town > Scum: RagnarokCometh (did not rush lynch) > awestfie (gut) > everyone else > Thomas ('townish vibes') > Wickedestjr (

Bandwagon gogogo

)

Now, why did I said you were the towniest? It is pretty simple. In my experience in previous mafia games (chat, etc), the mafia will just pressure someone to death to get a free quicklynch.

@ShadedMelee I forgot the part where the Cop becomes macho.

[ShadedMelee]

Timezone difference.
We could have one doc claim and the cop claim, then the other doc protects the cop...

So who would protect the claimed doc? Lol. We will loose one doc that night, and cop will become macho. Than we will loose all our powerroles.
I propose a policy-lynch on the next guy that brings such clever ideas.