Mini 1582: Formerfish's First Foray (Game Over)

[Octopus]

And that's how you get yourself away from a near L-1 situation, folks.

What the actual fuck were you intending to prove with this post?
That you can be more scummy than bjc?
I'm borderline not caring what your alignment is.

You understand, Octopus, that it benefits neither you nor me for you to pursue this line of questioning. In any event, I hate roleclaiming and I don't see how it would benefit me on this occasion, and I already feel like I've had to say too much.

Actually it does benefit me to pursue this line of enquiry. You see, it turns out that in a typically balanced game bulletproof is usually a modifier to a scum role, to ensure that the scum team is not wiped out early by a SK or a vig. It's, not like you re going to be NK'd tonight is it? Now that scum know you are bulletproof are they going to waste a kill on testing it? If you are then scum waste a nightkill, if not we loose a liar and save a mislynch. Or we could just go for the lynch as you are contradicting yourself on the "full disclosure" point.

Also, correct me if I'm wrong, you started the rolefishing in this game.

[Octopus]

RESERVED FOR VOTECOUNT

Thanks. Incoming.

[Formerfish]

Vote Count 2.7

Fat_Tony- bjc
Boonskiies- Drew-Sta, Fat_Tony (L-3)
massive- Tattletale, Boonskiies (L-3)

Not Voting: massive, theelkspeaks, Grib, octopus

With 9 alive, it takes 5 votes to lynch
(expired on 2014-07-11 23:35:00)

[bjc]

bjc = not scummy

[Grib]

And that's how you get yourself away from a near L-1 situation, folks.

Please stop making us want to kill you if you actually are town.

I'm trying to get you guys to stop! How many times must I say, "I'm town!!!!" Completely vanilla.

You've been saying that for ages now. We can read. But saying "I'm town" and doing fuckall else is making me less inclined to let you live.

I want to lynch massive or Boonskiies toDay, unless Octopus' promised post heavily condemns someone else.

[Fat_Tony]

I can get behind a Boonskiies lynch more easily than a massive lynch. I'm back to choo choo.

[Tattletale]

I want both of them to die. massive first.

[Drew-Sta]

Again, his 'I'm so surprised by Shinobi' comments are very, very odd and seem to be aiming at gaining town cred.

The reaction to getting off L-1 is concerning too.

I'm interested in what Octopus has to say, where are you mate?

[Boonskiies]

I'm just an annoying town.

[Fat_Tony]

Annoying for sure. Town... Who knows.

[theelkspeaks]

Boonskiies, rather than insist that you're town, tell us who IS scum.

[bjc]

It sure as hell ain't bee jay see!

[Drew-Sta]

We're at an impasse, I feel. I've seen no evidence to change my vote. Boon has not justified his behaviour, so he's either a town member playing poorly or mafia trolling and getting away with it.

We need more interaction people. We need to work this our or it will cost us.

[Tattletale]

I think we should lynch them both today.

Tomorrow is likely to be Lynch or Lose unless we hit mafia now.

[Grib]

We're at an impasse, I feel. I've seen no evidence to change my vote.

Boon has not justified his behaviour

, so he's either a town member playing poorly or mafia trolling and getting away with it.

We need more interaction people. We need to work this our or it will cost us.

Seriously, though. This is what seals your fate, Boonskiies. If you flip town and you try to justify it with "but I

SAID

I was town!!", I will reach into the Internet and beat you until you are comatose.

I think we should lynch them both today.

Tomorrow is likely to be Lynch or Lose unless we hit mafia now.

With nine alive, we have ten votes total and five to lynch. Double hammering is an option, unless anyone is against it. I'm only a little wary of a world where both massive and Boonskiies are town -- the following NK would set us back three townies. And if there's more than two scum, that's game.

[Tattletale]

Does anyone believe both massive and Boonskies are town?

[bjc]

Swiggity swooty comin' for that booty

Does anyone believe I'm scum?

[Boonskiies]

Boonskiies, rather than insist that you're town, tell us who IS scum.

How should I know who's scum? All I know is I'm like the taste of the most common extract. Vanilla.

[Grib]

So Boonskiies is a lost cause and there is no way we aren't killing him toDay.

Any massive defenses?

[Fat_Tony]

Grib - do we know for sure that double hammering will work? Are your votes placed simultaneously or would the person who was voted first be lynched before the second? Probably important for us to verify that.

[Octopus]

Ok, again sorry about the delays.

I think Boonskiies is a SK.

If Massive is scum (by "if" I mean "as") and if his claim of bulletproof is true, then that would strongly imply the presence of either a Vig or SK.
Unless bjc is a vig then we can rule this one out, otherwise he would have become part of the dearly departed on night one. (Ok, it's highly speculative, if Boonskiies is a vig then all bets are off). bjc has already claimed VT, though he is not necessarily believable.
We have been assuming that Shinobi used his hiding ability, but if he didn't then he may well have been killed by the one person who was all over him day one.

I like the idea of the double hammer, massive is almost certainly scum, something is definitely wrong with Boonskiies. I don't how we can get bjc on board though. Would asking nicely work?

[bjc]

Sure would. Who do I need to vote?

[Grib]

Grib - do we know for sure that double hammering will work? Are your votes placed simultaneously or would the person who was voted first be lynched before the second? Probably important for us to verify that.

If I'm the one who hammers, both players would simultaneously reach the number of votes required to lynch. It should work.

But say the mod registers my first vote before my second one and only whoever the first vote was for is lynched. Then we simply lynch the other person toMorrow (provided they aren't shot, but I

highly

doubt that will happen). At worst, we only lose two townies instead of potentially three (if massive and Boonskiies are both town, that would...really suck).

I believe scum will probably shoot elk toNight, if they're going to keep with the safe kills.

[Boonskiies]

Unless elk is scum. ^

[Fat_Tony]

Boon is 100% certified scum. How to set up someone for a misylnch for dummies right there.

Kill it with fire.