NY175: Sycamore Scuffle

[Aegor]

SKOT is like 95% PL.

[Cabd]

Eh. When you realize who his main is and frame it that way it makes total sense. It's his call if he wishes to reveal it though.

[Cabd]

(an actual catchup and reads list is being generated while I keep current on these pages fwiw)

[Cabd]

I lurked on the site for a couple months and read some games before actually signing up and playing. And trust me, I'm not that confident, lol. My last game my reads were all over the place. I'm hoping I can fix that this game instead of flip-flopping on people every other post. Also, I want to hear more from boon than just "hmm," and I don't feel like voting Soren anymore so

VOTE: Boonskiies

Give thoughts or something please?

As a side note while I catch up, what games did you watch/read before playing?

[shaddowez]

Current lynchpool:

{Wake, Boonskiies, SKOT, BroodKing, HunterSeeker}

Aegor, you don't mention Clusk in that list at all. As a matter of fact, in your ISO you don't mention him at all until your question about him still being in the game in Post #769. Could you give an explanation/read on him?

[Burning_TowN]

@MOD:

I'm V/LA until further notice, but it will be for at least 3 days.

~tn5421

[Cabd]

Thoughts on pages 1-10:

Spoiler: Notes

post 68, if wake flips scum Adrien is potential partner for it.

The followup in 72/73 also gives me bad vibes between those two. Very possible relational tells here.

Clusk's interaction with wake feels off too but it can't be ~this~ easy?


Yeah not_mafia is playing super pro-town so if he's scum he's still practically worth keeping around over plenty of others, heh.

Actually 82 makes me feel slightly better about clusk's slot, but it could be theater.

I hate everything about post 121 and post 132. Ewwwwwwwwwww.



...I actually incredibly get eebie jeebies from BP's opening post (138) too. Over the top and keeps trying to include himself in good townie logic yada yada. Help.


Farside's insistance wake is town is interesting.

I like shaddowez's first post (157)

Yeah aegor I know you hate that sort of thing but it works for him and meh.

If we're PLing anybody i'ts wake for stepping way out of line and then trying to excuse shit with a slayer's gambit claim.

GOd damn BP's posts in 198-199 are terrible.


HunterSeeker ignoring everything about the wake and Skot situations to push his RVS once more is shit.

Adrien I know your new stuff was great but dear god the sheer amount of shit that is post 221 makes me want to take everything back.

Spoiler: Reads

As with all my reads lists, the order of names within each tier is not in an order of strength.

Probably Scum/Worth Lynching D1:

5. Wake88

Lean Scum:

20. BP
19. Clusk92
18. HunterSeeker

To be sorted:

9. Mirhawk (Probably not scum with Scarab)
3. TheAdrienC
4. reinoe
8. Damon_Gant
14. Boonskiies
15. BroodKingEXE
16. Juls
17. Aeronaut
12. Scarab (Probably not scum with Mirhawk)

Lean Town:

11. Aegor
13. farside22
10. Not_Mafia
21. Alina
1. Sharpest-knife-on-tree
6. Burning_TowN
7. shaddowez

Is Me and Therefore Confirmed Town:

Cabd

[Burning_TowN]

@Cabd: When you finish with your iso, I would like to know why you feel the way you do in 781 about Wake and Boonskiies.

Welcome to the game.

~tn5421

[Alina]

I lurked on the site for a couple months and read some games before actually signing up and playing. And trust me, I'm not that confident, lol. My last game my reads were all over the place. I'm hoping I can fix that this game instead of flip-flopping on people every other post. Also, I want to hear more from boon than just "hmm," and I don't feel like voting Soren anymore so

VOTE: Boonskiies

Give thoughts or something please?

As a side note while I catch up, what games did you watch/read before playing?

Probably somewhere about 7-9, most of them newbie games from a long time ago. If you REALLY want, I can go through and try to find them all for you, but I can't imagine that would be very useful.

[Aegor]

Aegor, you don't mention Clusk in that list at all. As a matter of fact, in your ISO you don't mention him at all until your question about him still being in the game in Post #769. Could you give an explanation/read on him?

I do not find him particularly interesting at the moment. My read is null. I disagree with his "manipulation" charge, but I did not find that push particularly scummy. I would be happy to review individual posts, though.

[Cabd]

Aegor, do you feel the replacing out was indicative of alignment?

[Aegor]

Should I? Does Clusk have a history of replacing out as scum, or is the reasoning that the first few votes on him were enough to get him to replace out?

[reinoe]

Should I? Does Clusk have a history of replacing out as scum, or is the reasoning that the first few votes on him were enough to get him to replace out?

Clusk had both direct pressure and indirect pressure. People were openly saying they would be willing to vote for him/were scumreading him. The timing of the replace-out doesn't look good.

[Not_Mafia]

It was also a selective replace out

[Toomai]

Votecount D1-15

Sharpest-knife-on-tree	L-11	0	—
Cabd	L-11	0	—
TheAdrienC	L-10	1	Boonskiies
reinoe	L-11	0	—
Wake88	L-9	2	Clusk92, reinoe
Burning_TowN	L-11	0	—
shaddowez	L-11	0	—
Damon_Gant	L-11	0	—
Mirhawk	L-10	1	Scarab
Not_Mafia	L-10	1	HunterSeeker
Aegor	L-11	0	—
Scarab	L-8	3	Mirhawk, Sharpest-knife-on-tree, BP
farside22	L-11	0	—
Boonskiies	L-10	1	Burning_TowN
BroodKingEXE	L-11	0	—
Juls	L-11	0	—
Aeronaut	L-11	0	—
HunterSeeker	L-8	3	Aeronaut, Damon_Gant, Aegor
Clusk92	L-7	4	farside22, shaddowez, Alina, Not_Mafia
BP	L-10	1	Wake88
Alina	L-11	0	—

Not voting:

BroodKingEXE, Juls, TheAdrienC, Cabd

Activity

HunterSeeker is due for a prod in ~18 hours.
Damon_Gant is due for a prod in ~24 hours.
Burning_TowN is V/LA until 15/07/2014-ish.

Current deadline

27/07/2014 11:27 (EDT)
(expired on 2014-07-27 11:27:31)

[BP]

These replacements were funky. Didn't like 'em.

Calm yourselves, people. Grabbed my computer and a cup of coffe, will post what's been addressed to me and what's hot right now in the thread in a moment.

[Cabd]

UNVOTE:
VOTE: clusk slot

For now

[Not_Mafia]

@Broodking Why have you not voted?

[Sharpest-knife-on-tree]

I see references to cluck replacing out but I don't see it, where is it that cluck is a replace out?

[Cabd]

Clusk is still in the game, right?

Clusk92 has requested replacement via PM.

[Aeronaut]

unvote

, mainly because I've decided I agree with this.

I don't like the wagon. I don't want to waste our lynch on a lurker when we get way more valuable information from lynching a active.

Hunterseeker was my original vote because of the lurk, but honestly if hunter isn't going to speak up, there's no point keeping the pressure on him if there's scummier people to confront. For now, at least.


I'm waiting on giving a vote to Clusk, until his replacement can make a post. I'm already pretty sure of what's going to happen here, but Id like to be absolutely sure before I add to this wagon.

[Cabd]

I am scum with the clusk slot but want to give the slot a chance to dig out before I bus.

[Aeronaut]

I am scum with the clusk slot but want to give the slot a chance to dig out before I bus.

Nope, I'm perfectly alright with lynching him now, actually. I'm just not so quick to want to end the night like some other people.

[Not_Mafia]

The slot is on L-6, why the tentativeness? And where has anyone said or implied they want him quicklynched?

[TheAdrienC]

I personally want to get a read on his replacement before I vote. I think he stopped caring about this particular game and that was a cause of a lot of our suspicion. Could that slot be scum? He totally could be. But I want to get a good read on who is coming in to replace before we start talking about lynching.