The Wire Season 1 Mafia: Baltimore Police and Omar Victory!

[Messiah Complex]

unvote
vote: bookitty

[Messiah Complex]

Fine, I can call off Desp for the time being. I had a stronger scum read on another player anyways, and I would like to see how this plays out.

Unvote

Vote Boo

Pedit, did I just ninja myself?

[Messiah Complex]

go-go gadget high-level hydra play!

:highfive:

[Messiah Complex]

we weren't even talking about the game. we're just that fucking synced up.

[Messiah Complex]

::High five::

Hydra dissonance? Fuck that shit.

- Fishy

[Jackal711]

Alright I'll bite.

VOTE: Boo

I'm on mobile so I can't do quotes to present the case properly, but it's similar to the one that's already been done by mastin. He's my biggest town read atm.

@Mod: Consider me V/LA until Saturday. We're having a wave of record temperatures in my area and my computer keeps shutting down due to overheat even with a desk fan pointed directly on it. I'll phone post as I have time.

[Slandaar]

If there is a neighbourhood of three people and one of them who is town says 'lynch me and the other two become masons' why are the two not already masons from that townies POV?

If anyone can solve this mystery then I would love to hear from you. I have been up all night trying to work it out but quite frankly I am bamboozled.

[Slandaar]

Lets also say for arguments sake we have a neighbourhood and one of the neighbours is scum with flavour heavily hinting they are scum while the other two are masons, what would that scum do to try and avoid being lynched? Would they try and be productive and scumhunt? would they just push through a lynch on an easy target who claimed scum? would they throw a terrible gambit to try and look like they have town motivation in their posting when really there is none?

I do love a good mystery.

[Xisiqomelir]

@mastin2

:

@mastin2

: I'm perturbed that this post doesn't end in a vote on me.

Alas, the mod has seen it fit to bequeath to me but a mere singular vote, a great honor best put to use in continued support of the great campaign to lay rope around Bookitty's neck.

FOR SALAMANCE!

So you ain't gonna say nothing on it?

[Xisiqomelir]

@Dr Pants

:

anyone who questions the nk gains instant scum points

Do you...legitimately believe this? If yes, why shouldn't NKs be discussed?

[Xisiqomelir]

If there is a neighbourhood of three people and one of them who is town says 'lynch me and the other two become masons' why are the two not already masons from that townies POV?

If anyone can solve this mystery then I would love to hear from you. I have been up all night trying to work it out but quite frankly I am bamboozled.

This is where I'm at:

1) DGB is a town neighbour:
- She is self-voting, playing against wincon and risking modkill. -

Unlikely

- This is a ruse and she will call scum from interactions around her wagon later today -

Possible

2) DGB is a scum neighbour:
- She is self-voting, playing against wincon and risking modkill. -

Unlikely

3) DGB is more than just a town or scum neighbour (BBMolla theory):
- She is some sort of jester/vengeful/something and her death will benefit her faction, whatever it is -

My position

[Slandaar]

The point was if DGB were town she would know she doesn't need to be lynched for her neighbours to already be considered masons. This being one of her big arguments as to why she wants to be lynched. It sounds really pro-town though when you are saying you confirm two people as masons by being lynched it

sounds

like you have thought it through and have the towns interests at heart.

[Xisiqomelir]

The point was if DGB were town she would know she doesn't need to be lynched for her neighbours to already be considered masons.

If she were town I don't see how anyone could consider the remaining neighbours masons.

I mean, it's possible, I've been part of a town which fell victim to modpranks before, where Empking put 3 "Werewolf Seers" in Discworld mafia who could night investigate for lycanthropy but no werewolves and the seers went crazy going after each other thinking they all fakeclaimed.

However, setting up an all-town masonhood as a neighbourhood seems even more anti-town than that.

[Slandaar]

If she were town I don't see how anyone could consider the remaining neighbours masons.

Because she would have been telling the truth?

[Xisiqomelir]

If she were town I don't see how anyone could consider the remaining neighbours masons.

Because she would have been telling the truth?

She'd have been telling the truth about her own alignment, but "neighbourhood" implies scum. So 3 person neighbourhood minus one town does not make me think "2 masons".

[Slandaar]

BlueBloodedToffee

Now that I am moving up in the world let us go back to this.

Blue voted me for having a town avatar from what I can tell. How is that town?
He then posts a huge image when I questioned the vote because posting images is town.

Why is he so high in your reads?

[Slandaar]

She'd have been telling the truth about her own alignment, but "neighbourhood" implies scum. So 3 person neighbourhood minus one town does not make me think "2 masons".

DGBtown isn't going to tell us to consider them masons unless we should do.

It is quite clear cut either the PM's made it clear enough both Body and Poot are in the game or there is enough grey area that they can be fake claims in which case DGBtown would not be pushing that lynching her makes the other two neighbours masons.

[DrippingGoofball]

If there is a neighbourhood of three people and one of them who is town says 'lynch me and the other two become masons' why are the two not already masons from that townies POV?

Because my flavor is the snitch flavor. The other two guys in the neighborhood (Bodie/Poot) were always vassals to Barksdale. If you lynch me, you remove all possible doubt of a scum in that neighborhood, creating instant-masons.

[DrippingGoofball]

1) DGB is a town neighbour:
- She is self-voting, playing against wincon and risking modkill. - Unlikely
- This is a ruse and she will call scum from interactions around her wagon later today - Possible

I am playing for my wincon to create masons in the other two neighbors and I'm not getting modkilled.

It's not a ruse. Just vote me.

[DrippingGoofball]

The point was if DGB were town she would know she doesn't need to be lynched for her neighbours to already be considered masons.

As the snitch-flavored neighbor, my scum hunting is tainted. No one should pay attention to anything I say while alive. And historically no one pays attention after you're dead and flipped town (see Pikmin Mafia LOL).

Further, Gottemer and RSD should do nothing but try to lynch me all game as they are correctly doing. Everyone else should comply.

I decided the best way to play this role is to get lynched.

[DrippingGoofball]

So 3 person neighbourhood minus one town does not make me think "2 masons".

Arrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrgh

IT SHOULD

DUH

I AM THE SNITCH FLAVOR

THE OTHER TWO ARE NOT

I AM A PAIN IN THE DRAIN AND A DISTRACTION

[DrippingGoofball]

they can be fake claims

How likely do you think it is that Bodie/Poot be fakeclaims in a neighborhood with Wallace? I've never see this where a scum's fakeclaim dictates their actual role flavor.

[Sharpest-knife-on-tree]

so is DGB snitch or not?
it seemed straight forward to me...
:shrug:

[DrippingGoofball]

so is DGB snitch or not?
it seemed straight forward to me...
:shrug:

Exactly. Why let me live a minute longer?

[Slandaar]

Hi DGB.