Open 561: Farmer's Market (Game Over)

[mathbandit]

So if there are 10 people in a room, you say that say, sunday is the best day of the week, 4 of them agree with you and the rest say nothing, does that mean they all agree with you?

Thats this situation.

How does that change if one of those 4 tells them before everyone goes home that Sunday is the best day?

At this point,

unless something is decided to the contrary, everyone will be assumed to acknowledge that they are to give fruit to the person below them on the playerlist that is alive at end of Day.

If anyone has an objection to this plan and intends to not follow it, they must clearly state that before the end of the Day so that it can be discussed.

[Siveure DtTrikyp]

The point is that unless they all SAY they agree with you, you can't know for sure. You're assuming that everyone who hasn't posted on the fruit agrees with the plan, or would agree as soon as they looked. I mean, it probably won't change, but if they come back to the thread and see the last post saying "pass fruit below you or be considered scum" that'll probably affect them.

"Must clearly state before the end of the Day." Is it possible to do this if the day ends very abruptly?

[neil1113]

Still haven't gotten around to reading this unfortunately. I really want to read up on Math. And D_J, I plan on looking into that as well when I read up.

Fitz: Lol you're awesome. Best scum hunter on this site. Haven't we gone through this before? Just curious by the way, do you plan on actually making a case for your vote or did you just want to use that fluff as your excuse for if I get mislynched, so you have a way out of it tomorrow after my flip?

BTW's, if the plan is to send fruit to the person below you, I'm totally down with that.

[havingfitz]

Neil...the game is not that long. You should have been able to read it by now and form opinions vice coming in almost a day after joining and posting an "I'm lonely" post.

I prefer Siv...but if I'm off the mark enough to be the lone vote on him...I'm going to switch to option B. You.

How do you feel about Aronis and Fish's reasons for voting you?

[neil1113]

Neil...the game is not that long. You should have been able to read it by now and form opinions vice coming in almost a day after joining and posting an "I'm lonely" post.

I prefer Siv...but if I'm off the mark enough to be the lone vote on him...I'm going to switch to option B. You.

How do you feel about Aronis and Fish's reasons for voting you?

Sigh... I guess I'll read the game. Tonight it should be complete and I guess I can look at Fishface and Adonai's reasonings.

I don't think I even know who either of them are to be honest. :/

P.S. I'll do a recap of my read through every couple of pages, so you know where I am in my read through and my opinions of it.

[Siveure DtTrikyp]

Neil on a scale of 1-10 how good are you as town and as scum? (separate answers please)

[Formerfish]

Neil should know who I am. We just played a newbie game together where I spearheaded his lynch after he shittily tunneled me.

[neil1113]

Neil on a scale of 1-10 how good are you as town and as scum? (separate answers please)

As town? Eh... 5. As scum? I'd say 8 or 9. I don't normally lose scum games.

Neil should know who I am. We just played a newbie game together where I spearheaded his lynch after he shittily tunneled me.

Ah yes, where you spearheaded a mislynch. It was great. I also had no time what-so-ever to put into that game unfortunately. I'd rather not remember that. But to be fair, it's not difficult to "spearhead" a mislynch with a hundred newbies... it's like bragging because you successfully convinced a group of 3 year olds that Santa exists. Weren't you town that game? I don't think bragging about spearheading a mislynch with a terrible crappy case that only went through because I wasn't around to stop it, is something to boast about personally. But whatever floats your boat, cutie.

[Robocopter87]

--:Vote Count:--

• T S O [ 0 ]
  
• havingfitz [ 0 ]
  
• Siveure DtTrikyp [ 0 ]
  
• Aronis [ 0 ]
  
• IceGuy [ 1 ] mathbandit
  
• The Bulge [ 0 ]
  
• don_johnson [ 0 ]
  
• neil1113 [ 3 ] Formerfish, Aronis, havingfitz
  
  
• mathbandit [ 2 ] Don_Johnson, Sivuere DtTrikyp
  
• Formerfish [ 0 ]
  
• Bins [ 0 ]

Not Voting

: IceGuy, T S O, The Bulge, neil1113, Bins

Amount To Lynch

: With 11 alive it is 6 to lynch

Deadline

: None.

[Robocopter87]

IceGuy replaces innocentvillager, effective immediately.

WELCOME HIM.

Hey Mod! mathbandit is due a prod.

And why haven't you requested a replacement for innocentvillager yet? WTF?

If you must know, I already had a replacement lined up for him, so I didn't need the request out. Turns out that the person couldn't replace, so I put out the request after TSO replaced out too. It's all good man, let your handsome mod take care of it.

[Robocopter87]

When I find a TSO replacement, I am going to put a deadline up.

[IceGuy]

VOTE: mathbandit

This day needs to end right fucking now and I'm not lynching neil since the wagon on him is bullshit.

Also, the night strategy should absolutely be giving fruit to the person below you on the list (or on top if you're the last one). We need the information now, not later in the game, so our best strategy is indeed to get it over with on N1 and N2 and play the rest of the game mountainous but with extra information.

I will personally lead the wagon on everyone who claims to not have followed the strategy.

Also, I've got my eye on Siveure. When I started reading the thread, I had him as solidly town, until he posted this. Asking for confirmation about something that is in the scum role PM right at the front of the thread is scum behavior.

[Siveure DtTrikyp]

*sigh*

Failing to check stuff off the role pms at any stage in the game is scum behaviour. Yay.

That said, agree wholeheartedly with the rest of the ice's post.

[Formerfish]

Neil on a scale of 1-10 how good are you as town and as scum? (separate answers please)

As town? Eh... 5. As scum? I'd say 8 or 9. I don't normally lose scum games.

Neil should know who I am. We just played a newbie game together where I spearheaded his lynch after he shittily tunneled me.

Ah yes, where you spearheaded a mislynch. It was great. I also had no time what-so-ever to put into that game unfortunately. I'd rather not remember that. But to be fair, it's not difficult to "spearhead" a mislynch with a hundred newbies... it's like bragging because you successfully convinced a group of 3 year olds that Santa exists. Weren't you town that game? I don't think bragging about spearheading a mislynch with a terrible crappy case that only went through because I wasn't around to stop it, is something to boast about personally. But whatever floats your boat, cutie.

That is quite the odd reaction to what I said. I was mearly pointing out the fained lack of recognition was slightly disingenuous since we recently played a game together where we had significant interaction, and we have played one together in the past as well. Maybe my feelings were hurt a bit because I failed to make a lasting impression on you...

[havingfitz]

As town? Eh... 5. As scum? I'd say 8 or 9. I don't normally lose scum games.

So you won't be of much use to us as town and as scum...you feel confident and capable.

All the more reason to lynch you

[Siveure DtTrikyp]

Hmm, I really didn't think #330 through.

[Formerfish]

Hmm, I really didn't think #330 through.

What does this mean? I don't even...

[Siveure DtTrikyp]

I had a plan based off one response, but the subjectivity of his opinion and how you could argue anything off his response, regardless of what it is, makes it essentially worthless.

#X = Post X

[havingfitz]

Zzz zzz

So what's up? Everyone just relaxing waiting on TSOs replacement?

Aronis and Bins are closing in on prods...exciting.

[havingfitz]

So Ice...

Why is the Neil wagon bs?

And why are you voting math? Especially given that the only person (aside from math) that you cast suspicion towards is Siv...who is also voting math.

[Formerfish]

Hey Robo, take your mass prod and shove it.

[IceGuy]

Why is the Neil wagon bs?

Because his behavior screams town.

And why are you voting math? Especially given that the only person (aside from math) that you cast suspicion towards is Siv...who is also voting math.

Because we need a lynch and he's the person most likely to get lynched that isn't clearly town. Also bussing.

[Robocopter87]

Hey Robo, take your mass prod and shove it.

Right into your inbox.

(But really though if you have a problem, you should PM me directly. I honestly couldn't tell if joking or serious.)

[Bins]

Sorry, really tought time with work right now.

Ice's entry post seems fine.
No one has yet to make an actual good case on Matt.
I don't like the Neil wagon.

[Formerfish]

/url], havingfitz"]
Why is the Neil wagon bs? [/quote]

Because his behavior screams town.

And why are you voting math? Especially given that the only person (aside from math) that you cast suspicion towards is Siv...who is also voting math.

Because we need a lynch and he's the person most likely to get lynched that isn't clearly town. Also bussing.[/quote]


His behavior since he replaced in, or his slots since the start of the game? Also, do you have anything you could point to showing his townieness? I think that would help in your defense of him.