Also, what exactly is making our case more scummy than Speaker for the Dead's? I'm not following how we went from lean-town to scum on people's reads lists.
borkjerfkin wrote:In post 1407, Macaronis and Cheese wrote:Certainly there are no past games to see how the moderator chooses characters for roles, nonetheless I think it's valid as a supplemental argument (not a foundational one - I agree there).
What is your foundational argument then?
I'm not biting on flavor spec in general and in specific I'm not biting on it here: I skimmed the Earth-295 article for Nightcrawler and he's a member of the X-men and a pretty popular character in general. It's reasonable he's in the game, and I don't see how you can, in good conscience, make any argument that his minor influence in this universe is alignment indicative.
Macaronis and Cheese wrote:We have strong suspicions that Speaker for the Dead is the mafia member implanted within our neighborhood. Firstly, they made a post very similiar to bork's in our neighborhood, nearly one day after he did in yours. Thus it brings up the strong possibility that the person in bork's neighborhood saw the post, told the other mafia and suggested that one of them replicate the idea. Of course he didn't quote it, but most likely just mentioned it. Leaving them to create their own and gain more credibility for it. They also choose not to post it at the start of the day.
Before the game had started, I made a post about flavor: Stating that I thought we were Team X-Calibre and mentioned Nightcrawler. When asked to flavor claim, they claimed Nightcrawler. Which goes to suggest the possibility that they used the info in my post to form a fakeclaim.
Now, only after we have shown reasonable suspicions towards them, they are going after us, wanting to policy lynch us. Which I find to be very OMGUS, considering they didn't even notice us in the first 24 hours and only begin suspecting us, after we suspected them.
I recently claimed within the 'hood, but when they claimed, their claim was two words. Which makes it very difficult for us to discern that they want us to claim. Neither me or my partner recognized it as pointing to us to claim, thus the delay.
The 'X-Men' within this Marvel universe, contain Quicksilver, Storm, Dazzler, Iceman, Banshee, and Exodus.
We're Weapon X. It causes suspicions that they are one of three players outside our 'group' as well.
We're also not very impressed by their posts, despite the wall, which brought this all up in the first place.
~Macaronis
After considering it more, I will admit that given this is likely to be a VT-heavy and Mafia power-heavy game, the likelihood that mafia have been given powerful fake claims seems fairly high.
-Cheese
