Mini 1591: PFs Flavorless Normal (Game Over)

[Cyberbob]

("my wagon" as in "my wagon on reinoe")

[popsofctown]

Why is everyone ignoring my case on Konowa? His reaction was "sounds about right".

IAI vote Konowa for me so I can get more attention

[SleepyKrew]

Hey cooldog, farside, and red coyote, how many scum in here...

[konowa, sleepykrew, cyberbob]

What is this supposed to accomplish?

I'll address other reinoe stuff when I get home later. Keep preachin, bob.

pops, do you not buy that Konowa hadn't read when he made his first post?

[popsofctown]

Even if I do buy it, skimming thread is correlated with a scum alignment, so that's no salvation

[reinoe]

Hey cooldog, farside, and red coyote, how many scum in here...

[konowa, sleepykrew, cyberbob]

What is this supposed to accomplish?

I'll address other reinoe stuff when I get home later. Keep preachin, bob.

pops, do you not buy that Konowa hadn't read when he made his first post?

What do you think " sounded about right" when he made that comment? If he had not read the thread then how could anything have " sounded about right"? Are you reading the thread?

[Cyberbob]

Why is everyone ignoring my case on Konowa?

I haven't ignored it but I'm not quite sure how you're reading so much into his initial reinoe vote when all he said to go along with it was "Yup." Especially since he admitted later that he hadn't actually read the thread - it would be a really weird thing to lie about, so why would he outright admit to it if he was scum? People jump on early Day 1 bandwagons for all sorts of reasons (including no reason at all).

Goofy is much scummier if you're looking for people to vote that aren't reinoe.

[Cyberbob]

Even if I do buy it, skimming thread is correlated with a scum alignment, so that's no salvation

Really? I mean I might be relying a little too heavily on my own experiences, but from what I can recall I almost always used to pay more attention when I'm scum. Can you back this one up?

[SleepyKrew]

Are you reading the thread?

Clearly not, because this is at least the third time someone said or implied I wasn't.

[SleepyKrew]

Are you reading the thread?

Clearly not, because this is at least the third time someone said or implied I wasn't.

No but seriously come up with something better than that because based just on the post you quoted, I'm obviously keeping up with the conversation.

I want a Konowa post.

[SleepyKrew]

Triple post woooo
Cyberbob, why do you think Goofy is scummy?

[Cyberbob]

I want Konowa posts, Goofy posts, I Am Innocent posts, RedCoyote posts and farside22 posts that aren't chainsaw defences of reinoe

Goofy's Post 77 is deliberately evasive and scummy as shit, also for some reason I'm having a bit of a gut reaction to his Post 65.

[farside22]

Hey cyber bob.

What's you looking for?
Why do you think the rvs question from sk is important to awnser?

As for renioe..he's expectations are a bit high. Not everyone thinks along the same ways. My expectation of some players is typically based on meta then join date.

[Cyberbob]

I'm not really looking for you to comment on any one thing in particular, just for you to comment on

something

other than lazily berating SK for supposedly being so absentminded

SK's question wasn't terribly hard hitting but that only makes it weirder that anyone would bother to not answer it. What did Goofy have to lose?

[CooLDoG]

What's your thoughts on Konowa?

Ehh. That's the best way to describe. I don't think he has contributed particularly much to the town but I don't see much in the ways of derailing it. He has only made 3 posts. I need to hear more to actually make a read on him. His vote is relativly undeveloped, but for the time in the game it is and the number of posts it doesn't strike me as ******SCUMTASTIC****** but if justs sits where he is, ehh, I could see him as scum.

Hey cooldog, farside, and red coyote, how many scum in here...

[konowa, sleepykrew, cyberbob]

One, with the possibility of two. Don't think cyberbob is scummy at the moment. His point on you seems to be, at the least, somewhat warranted.
@skrew per-emptivly, again, I'm not saying his case is good, or his posting style is pro-town, but it doesn't indicate scum to me.

PS there are almost certainly semi-lurking scum that are either facepalming at their scumbuddy reinoe going off half-cocked or rubbing their hands in glee at seeing town reinoe being an excellent focus of attention.

^probably true.

You're demanding a flawless case based on page two information.

I am not. I am demanding a slightly less than completely 100% forced, melodramatic and contradictory case based on page 2 information.

Why do you think sleepykrew's case is not forced, melodramatic, and contradictory?

the fact that you post a sparkly hat and a flail?

Why is everyone ignoring my case on Konowa? His reaction was "sounds about right".

IAI vote Konowa for me so I can get more attention

be patiant. Listen to the byrds more.

Hey cyber bob.

What's you looking for?

Why do you think the rvs question from sk is important to awnser?

As for renioe..he's expectations are a bit high. Not everyone thinks along the same ways. My expectation of some players is typically based on meta then join date.

This strikes me as off. I don't know why a town player would ask this except to change their play to look town. Just doesn't hit me in the right way.

[popsofctown]

Even if I do buy it, skimming thread is correlated with a scum alignment, so that's no salvation

Really? I mean I might be relying a little too heavily on my own experiences, but from what I can recall I almost always used to pay more attention when I'm scum. Can you back this one up?

Scum tend to be less motivated and to be having less fun, as a rule. That means they are less likely to read the thread, much like you are less likely to read every word of a boring text than of a good novel.

That's for the average person, it might not apply to you. Maybe you like playing scum, or you read everything either way but have a meticulous attitude as scum.


Goofyd00d does give me a vague scum vibe, but Konowa has a better feel for me.

[RedCoyote]

Bob, really? I said I agreed with your vote against him and the premise behind it. I have my own individual points against Drew that I want to pursue. I didn't just join in for shits and giggles, and you're tying Drew and SK alignment's together far too early over one post. I thought it sounded suspicious, but let's not go crazy. So for you to make the implication (correct me if I'm wrong) that because I am voting Drew, the person that overly defended SK and tried to make it seem like he didn't, and because SK is a town read of yours at the moment, then that means I am de facto chainsaw defending reinoe. That's a lot of assumptions to be making about four different players.

reinoe, my answer is one.

[RedCoyote]

EBWOP: alignments

[Cyberbob]

Bob, really? I said I agreed with your vote against him and the premise behind it. I have my own individual points against Drew that I want to pursue. I didn't just join in for shits and giggles, and you're tying Drew and SK alignment's together far too early over one post. I thought it sounded suspicious, but let's not go crazy. So for you to make the implication (correct me if I'm wrong) that because I am voting Drew, the person that overly defended SK and tried to make it seem like he didn't, and because SK is a town read of yours at the moment, then that means I am de facto chainsaw defending reinoe. That's a lot of assumptions to be making about four different players.

reinoe, my answer is one.

Did I say I wanted posts from them/you specifically about reinoe or any other topic? No, I just said I wanted more posts. There were no implications being made except what you've created in your mind.

[reinoe]

PS there are almost certainly semi-lurking scum.

how many scum here...

[I am innocent, goofydood, popsofctown]

[CooLDoG]

Even if I do buy it, skimming thread is correlated with a scum alignment, so that's no salvation

Really? I mean I might be relying a little too heavily on my own experiences, but from what I can recall I almost always used to pay more attention when I'm scum. Can you back this one up?

Scum tend to be less motivated and to be having less fun, as a rule.

[RedCoyote]

Did I say I wanted posts from them/you specifically about reinoe or any other topic? No, I just said I wanted more posts. There were no implications being made except what you've created in your mind.

I want [...] RedCoyote posts [...] that aren't chainsaw defences of reinoe

Explain to me how to correctly interpret this statement.

[RedCoyote]

Did you leave out punctuation or something? Otherwise that's a pretty big backtrack, Bobby.

[reinoe]

Hey cooldog, farside, and red coyote, how many scum in here...

[konowa, sleepykrew, cyberbob]

What is this supposed to accomplish?

How many games outside of Road To Rome do you have. I know we played together in that one U-Pick, but was that your only non-newbie game?

[Cyberbob]

Did I say I wanted posts from them/you specifically about reinoe or any other topic? No, I just said I wanted more posts. There were no implications being made except what you've created in your mind.

I want [...] RedCoyote posts [...] that aren't chainsaw defences of reinoe

Explain to me how to correctly interpret this statement.

That last bit was only referring to farside. I was quite obviously not saying that all of the posters I listed have spent a significant amount of time attacking SK. The reason that this is obvious is I have a functioning brain.

[Cyberbob]

Hey cooldog, farside, and red coyote, how many scum in here...

[konowa, sleepykrew, cyberbob]

What is this supposed to accomplish?

How many games outside of Road To Rome do you have. I know we played together in that one U-Pick, but was that your only non-newbie game?