NY 176: Completely Ridiculous Mafia (Game Over)

[notscience]

glad to see you don't actually remember the game you're trying to meta

[MVP]

glad to see you don't actually remember the game you're trying to meta

You're also forgetting the whole

"Bullshit the read on our slot" bit

And

"Trying to fill the game with fluff to increase apathy"

But no, you're totally right.

@DJ-

Scum alignment doesn't say they have to be on a mislynch.

[Depraved Justice]

@MVP, no. I would expect scum to jump onto a mislynch opportunity if one of their buddies is indeed being wagoned. That is why I don't like the largely unexplained move by Reinoe. He said the "stuff" in the past two pages bothered him, but leaves the stuff unexplained. That is not Reinoe like.

Toonami is also town according to this head.

[reinoe]

[Depraved Justice]

Ok.

VOTE: Reinoe

Let's see what happens.

[reinoe]

Ok.

VOTE: Reinoe

Let's see what happens.

[Izariael]

Welcome to cabd. meta is pretty much all I do, man.

But you have no meta on me and yet were able to provide reasoning for your read on me within the scope of the game. Why are you not doing the same for MVP? I'm not discounting your meta entirely, but I do find it questionable. I'm not planning to put any weight into it unless there's other factors within the context of this game that I find to be scummy. And at this time, I do not see anything from MVP, aside from what I pointed out in [860].

@MVP:

Can you explain what was going on in 777? Is this first-world hydra problems? Heads don't agree on reads or something? You're using the same reads again in [870]...

Go read under completed large themes "fire emblem awakening" I was good cop bad cop. Notsci was some hydra that was scum and got dunked day one or two.

I'm having a hard enough time keeping up with this game, let alone reading another large theme game that may or may not provide anything useful...

[TheWayItEnds]

Twie bob toomai aegor

That's the scumteam

Goodnight Los Angeles

Pretty sure thats 0/4.

Slim outside chance of 1/4.

[Bicephalous Bob]

I'd like gif to answer my questions (previous post in my iso) and a chance to reply before anyone tries to get a claim out of him

[MVP]

I gave a shot at reading few days ago and that was a note that I left at titanpad.
Toomai was a gut town.
Also I primarily decided to work at backgrounds from now on because I really hate having to catch up.
And I did yell them at skype after posting that. Not much happened after it.

[goodmorning]

Fun fact:

Spoiler: boobies!

Votecount 1.28

MVP [L-2] - TheWayItEnds, Cabd, Cephrir, AngryPidgeon, Aegor, reinoe

reinoe [L-4] - Bicephalous Bob, T S O, Toomai, Depraved Justice

Toomai [L-5] - MVP, Mirhawk, Aeronaut

T S O [L-7] - Ki-Gi

Not Voting [1] - Izariael

With 15 alive, it takes

8

to lynch. The day will end in (expired on 2014-08-30 21:00:00)

Some of MVP is V/LA a bit.

[Bicephalous Bob]

so in the long time your hydra has been voting toomai (all the time), have you tried convincing them of changing the vote? The others didn't seem very attached to their toomai vote.

[Bicephalous Bob]

I mean, before ns posted his scumteam

[MVP]

I didn't even realized that we were voting Toomai until just now.
I did tell him that his scumteam doesn't even make any remote sense but he's being stubborn as ever.

[T S O]

I don't get your Toomai stance.

[MVP]

UNVOTE: btw bc ns is not here and I don't want the vote there.

TSO, whose stance?

[T S O]

Whoever was posting. I'm not familiar enough with your posting styles.

[T S O]

Whoever's there, I guess.

[MVP]

Well, gut read is kinda hard to explain.
I think we played before once in one newbie game where I was scum roleplaying this guy.

[Toomai]

• townest
  
  
• Izariael, AP
  
  
• Cephrir
  
  
• Aegor, TheWayItEnds
  
  
• Cabd, Mirhawk
  
  
• Ki-Gi, DJ, Aeronaut, TSO
  
  
• MVP, reinoe
  <----------
  
  
• BBob
  
  
• scummest

I might attempt later to look for specific posts that garnered these "reads".

I went and ISO'd MVP. These are the posts that might contain alignment-indicative stuff: 619, 623, 682, 683, and 686.

I'm not seeing scum in any of that. So why's he at L-2?

VOTE: MVP

So wait. You point out that MVP is in the "weak-scum" section of my "readslist", which I stated in that post to be probably a combination of my reads and other peoples' reads. Then you point at my post that shows that I went back to look over the slot and come to the conclusion that my read should be changed from "weak-scum" to "don't see scum", and that I don't understand why it's at L-2 (which I had previously stated in 780). Then you vote MVP to L-1.

I don't get it. Explain.

[Bicephalous Bob]

I didn't even realized that we were voting Toomai until just now.

how

[MVP]

Well I knew we voted Toomai on RVS but I saw my third head talking about nero-hydra in skype so I assumed that's where the vote moved.
As you can tell, I haven't read past page 6 (and some few posts around where I posted.)

[MVP]

VOTE: Mirhawk

My scumteam is bad

because it doesn't have this guy in it

my mistake

[Cephrir]

^Explain this please?

[reinoe]

• townest
  
  
• Izariael, AP
  
  
• Cephrir
  
  
• Aegor, TheWayItEnds
  
  
• Cabd, Mirhawk
  
  
• Ki-Gi, DJ, Aeronaut, TSO
  
  
• MVP, reinoe
  <----------
  
  
• BBob
  
  
• scummest

I might attempt later to look for specific posts that garnered these "reads".

I went and ISO'd MVP. These are the posts that might contain alignment-indicative stuff: 619, 623, 682, 683, and 686.

I'm not seeing scum in any of that. So why's he at L-2?

VOTE: MVP

So wait. You point out that MVP is in the "weak-scum" section of my "readslist", which I stated in that post to be probably a combination of my reads and other peoples' reads. Then you point at my post that shows that I went back to look over the slot and come to the conclusion that my read should be changed from "weak-scum" to "don't see scum", and that I don't understand why it's at L-2 (which I had previously stated in 780). Then you vote MVP to L-1.

I don't get it. Explain.

Ok this shouldn't be hard to explain...

YOU, a scumread of mine list both myself and MVP as "SLIGHTLY scummy". Bob is listed as your strongest scumread but you're not voting for Bob. Not voting your biggest scumread is highly unusual.

But what's crazy is when you make your post 850.

You say you ISO'd MVP and you don't see any scumminess in any of that. But...

1)MVP was a "slight scumread"
2)why aren't/weren't you voting your biggest scumread
3)you can find the inner stregnth to vote me who is also a "slight scumread", so why can't you see the scumminess in MVP whom is also a "slight scumread".
4)The timing of your defense of MVP is uncanny. The wagon on him had definitely stalled. Aegor votes and then here you come with the hard defense of a slot you haven't felt the need to defend previously (and I don't see why you would since he's a "slight scumread").
5)This is all exacerbated by the fact that I'm scumreading you. Where I'm from this looks like scum trying to defend a teammate. It's like you completely forgot you were scumreading MVP when you made post 850.

Retroactive to this Depraved Justice votes me for almost not reason. I'm scumreading both yourself and TSO, and wasn't sure if DP or MVP is scum but they're both kinda scummy. The DP hop for an erroneous meta-tell looks like a shameless attempt to create a counterwagon.

MVP has to be lynched.