NY 177: Simple Complexity (GAME OVER: Scum Wins!)

[Titus]

Psyche my butt is sufficiently out there. I am woman enough to prove I get the scum. No need to prove being macho. :p

[gameplay506]

Ok just read the few pages. Titus from what I read in the rules it is inpossible for Tso or Pere to have told anything to Aero if they are scum simply because scum dont have daytalk. Also Aero came up with himself on that in the nb.

I suggest we lynch someone scummy today other than Aero and cop investigates Aero tonight.

[Wake1]

Vote Count 1.11

Aeronaut (5):

Josh_B, notscience, Titus, Mirhawk, Shaddowez

OkaPoka (4):

Aeronaut, Alina, Tree, Elyse

Tree (3):

reinoe, OkaPoka, Majiffy

Titus (2):

T S O, tn5421

texcat (2):

Aegor, Replacement (Farside22)

tn5421 (1):

PeregrineV

Elyse (1):

Gameplay506

Not Voting (3):

RoyalApe, Psyche, texcat

~ With 21 players alive, it takes 11 to lynch!

~ Deadline expires 9/3/14, @8am central.

~ Seeking replacement for Farside22. If you know of anyone who might join, please ask them.

~ VLA: [reinoe 9/1/14]

OP | Game Rules | Day Start
1.1 | 1.2 | 1.3 | 1.4 | 1.5 | 1.6 | 1.7 | 1.8 | 1.9 | 1.10 | 1.11 | 1.12 | 1.13 | 1.14 | 1.15 | 1.16 | 1.17 | 1.18 | 1.19
Aegor's Lynch & Flip
Elyse and T S O's Murders & Flips
2.1 | 2.2 | 2.3 | 2.4
Aeronaut's Lynch & Flip
Texcat and Josh_B's Murders & Flips
3.1 | 3.2 | 3.3 | 3.4 | 3.5 | 3.6 | 3.7 | 3.8 | 3.9
tn5421's Lynch & Flip
Titus's Murder & Flip
4.1 | 4.2 | 4.3
OkaPoka's Lynch & Flip
Majiffy and Mirhawk's Murders & Flips
5.1 | 5.2 | 5.3 | 5.4 | 5.5
PeregrineV's Lynch & Flip
Gameplay506 and notsciences' Murders & Flips
6.1 | 6.2 | 6.3

[Majiffy]

Why arent we lynching tree again? Hes empirically scummy.

[Titus]

Shit you are right Gameplay...but then why wouldn't Aero highlight what he thought the crumbs were? Suspicious.

Aeronaut is scummier.

[gameplay506]

Shit you are right Gameplay...but then why wouldn't Aero highlight what he thought the crumbs were? Suspicious.

Aeronaut is scummier.

I told them to shut up and not discuss anything.

Soo Titus who do you scumread? (if you already made a list link me to it). Maybe we can work out a lynch we agree on.

[Majiffy]

I grok but the role will work itself out either way, despiye a vocal minority's claims of the opposite.

[Majiffy]

@titus

[Titus]

Gameplay, this is a Titus tunnel. I am getting Aeronsut's head today. You think they are scummy. That us the lynch we can agree on.

Jiffy, I can countermove any pretend investigation from Aero. His claim will not sort itself out.

[gameplay506]

Gameplay, this is a Titus tunnel. I am getting Aeronsut's head today. You think they are scummy. That us the lynch we can agree on.

Jiffy, I can countermove any pretend investigation from Aero. His claim will not sort itself out.

Titus there is no need to lynch him today. Someone can easily investigate him tonight and if he catches him Aero will be lynched tomorrow.

[Majiffy]

Jiffy, I can countermove any pretend investigation from Aero. His claim will not sort itself out.

Either he'll have a no-gun report on a scum we end up lynching, or he ends up fucking himself by clearing townies and POE.

[And regarding claiming/being RB'ed] That leaves any other PRs we might have unblocked, or else we'll have a direct CC.

So unless you're going to explain why Aero is immune to all of this, I don't see your argument.

Plus, other investigatives.

[notscience]

Have we found out who else is in the hood yet?

[Titus]

1) Gee anyplayer can be investigated so we should just nl. No reason Aero is different.

2) Why out a PR to lynch scum? Oh wait Aero claimed GS so I guess a PR must claim to lynch him. No.

3) You are supposing Aero's claims will be belived. Why? Aero will not be trapped.

Aero claims scum is town...never caught bc we do not lynch cop clears and vigs don't shoot them.
Aero claims town as scum...will happen in lylo with no opportunity to correct...

So just how do you expect to prove Aero is lying?

[Majiffy]

1) Not every player is a GS claim. Strawman argument.
2) Or clear him? Aero can still be town, remember this. Argument refuted.
3) Still assumes Aeroscum and disregards the possibility of Aerotown. Poor argument, refuted.

I don't get your other two bits here. Try English!

None of your arguments hold water, mine still do.

[notscience]

Have we found out who else is in the hood yet?

[Josh_B]

Oh, I know, Aero will you lynch tree or investigate him? This could really solve the issue of who is doing what.
And then we could all get along to lynch Gameplay. He's in a neighborhood, but for some reason thought this game was mountainous. LOL WUT?

VOTE: Gameplay

[gameplay506]

Oh, I know, Aero will you lynch tree or investigate him? This could really solve the issue of who is doing what.
And then we could all get along to lynch Gameplay. He's in a neighborhood, but for some reason thought this game was mountainous. LOL WUT?

VOTE: Gameplay

Josh you are blind and stupid. I already said that Wake wanted to make a mountabious nb setup and that is from where I got my theory. Also a neighborhood and mountanious can go together. So try again.

[notscience]

No they can't.

[Titus]

1) Not every player is a GS claim. Strawman argument.
2) Or clear him? Aero can still be town, remember this. Argument refuted.
3) Still assumes Aeroscum and disregards the possibility of Aerotown. Poor argument, refuted.

I don't get your other two bits here. Try English!

None of your arguments hold water, mine still do.

1) Any scum D1 will claim GS is my point. No reason to treat GS as dpecial bc it cannot be confirmed.
2) Cop checks do not clear the cop. Scum already know the answer.
3) I showed how Aero can fake GS results...and there's I checked the dead guy.

My arguments hold water.

[Wake1]

Amending prodding time to 2 days, instead of 3.

[Majiffy]

RE: Mountainous;

No they can't.

This. But that doesn't mean Wake can't just be stupid and think it is, and therefore describe it as such.

1) Not every player is a GS claim. Strawman argument.
2) Or clear him? Aero can still be town, remember this. Argument refuted.
3) Still assumes Aeroscum and disregards the possibility of Aerotown. Poor argument, refuted.

I don't get your other two bits here. Try English!

None of your arguments hold water, mine still do.

1) Any scum D1 will claim GS is my point. No reason to treat GS as dpecial bc it cannot be confirmed.
2) Cop checks do not clear the cop. Scum already know the answer.
3) I showed how Aero can fake GS results...and there's I checked the dead guy.

My arguments hold water.

1) Why would "any scum" claim GS D1? You aren't supporting your arguments, just spouting off unfounded shit that doesn't even refute anything, and acting like it does.
2) Uh

what?

Put down the crack pipe and come back to this game when you can manage coherent thoughts.
3) Except fake reports will either clear townies or be incorrect. So POE/caught-by-bad-report still holds. Consistently saying "lol guess what? 'nother dead guy" isn't going to last long, either.

Your arguments are shit.

[Titus]

1)Scum claim gs bc of ppl like you Jiffy who refuse to lynch a gs D1 solely bc yhey claimed it.
2) Scum can fake cop easy. If that is a hard concept, you are scum.
3) PoE and caught by bad reports does not hold. Clear obvtowns..kill obvtowns. PoE never happens until lylo.

[Titus]

There Scum GS claims guilty on town.

Name a scenario where you would lynch a claimed gs day 1 without a cc.

[gameplay506]

No they can't.

Um Wake came up with it. So yes they can.

[Majiffy]

1)Scum claim gs bc of ppl like you Jiffy who refuse to lynch a gs D1 solely bc yhey claimed it.
2) Scum can fake cop easy. If that is a hard concept, you are scum.
3) PoE and caught by bad reports does not hold. Clear obvtowns..kill obvtowns. PoE never happens until lylo.

1) Your argument would be stronger if you just said "PR". But either way; this is a shitty WIFOM argument. Town PRs exist. It doesn't make sense to lynch them D1 if they can be sorted otherwise.
2) I'M TALKING ABOUT A FUCKING COP COPPING AERO YOU F-
3) Uh, yes it does. A hell of a lot more than your "lol pr claim lynch it" position.

Name a scenario where you would lynch a claimed gs day 1 without a cc.

None. Just like I can't name a scenario where I'd lynch a claimed any PR D1 without a CC. Because it's

objectively bad play.