NY 176: Completely Ridiculous Mafia (Game Over)

[T S O]

(a bad sign on your efforts, in case you thought otherwise)

[TheWayItEnds]

You are right.

I should have been loud and annoying and pushed for town lynches at the top of my lungs instead.

[T S O]

It would certainly be preferable to being quiet and anonymous and weakly pushing for a lynch in a whisper, yes.

[TheWayItEnds]

(In case you were wondering, any attempt of yours to admonish my day 1/2 play will be met with ironic laughter and derision.)

[T S O]

I really don't give a fuck - the more you laugh and deride instead of, I don't know, pushing the wagon

you claim to be pushing,

the more your play will ironically mirror that -of -me during d1/d2.

[T S O]

Yes. Then you posted that garbage about the Bob wagon.

Mirhawk
Cephir
Reinoe/Bob (at ddeadline for Bob).

That's our list. The last two only have one head scumreading. That is the pool to work in.

Reinoe hasn't done jackshit, our other scumreads started a wagon that forced a deadline claim from us thst countered Reinoe. I already said that today.

Depraved Justice,

Town Vigilante

, has died Night 1.

MVP,

Town Even-Night Gunsmith

, has died Night 2.

What do you think the chances of scum having a roleblocker and killing MVP last night?

Cause I think they're quite low.

Heres the highlight reel.

It doesnt currently include all the reasons I found Mirhawk scummy day1/day2, but I also didnt feel like it needed to.

I can add some if you want.

But literally those 4 quotes are a better case for Mirhawk than all the Toomai cases I've heard combined.

And this was a completely legitimate case for reinoe being scum d2, which was the reason I again hardtunnelled after the night, so if you want to stop being a hypocrite and start using your brain, feel free to do so.

[TheWayItEnds]

You're right.

Hard pushing for the person being scumread by only a single head of the vig hydra, after previously hard pushing for that same person the day before with no mention of any change in reasoning IS tantamount to what I'm doing here.

[Toomai]

Yeah, I needed to make sure that was happening, because if it wasn't, well, hello scum claim.

Don't be silly, I'd have to do it (i.e. graphs) as scum too, or it'd be a trust tell.

[TheWayItEnds]

Toomai do you want to comment on something on topic instead?

[T S O]

k

[TheWayItEnds]

Like your wagon?

Or Mirhawk?

Or how much TSO is embarrassing me in this argument right now?

Or like literally anything?

[Cephrir]

This page is one of my favorite pages in this thread.

[goodmorning]

strč prst skrz racek

Votecount 3.10

Toomai [L-4] - scrambles, Aegor

Mirhawk [L-5] - ika

ika [L-5] - Toomai

Not Voting [7] - Cephrir, Izariael, Cabd, T S O, Mirhawk, TheWayItEnds, AngryPidgeon

With 11 alive, it takes

6

to lynch. The day will end in (expired on 2014-09-18 20:00:00).

[scrambles]

This page is one of my favorite pages in this thread.

Something im miss in here?

[Toomai]

Like your wagon?

Or Mirhawk?

Or how much TSO is embarrassing me in this argument right now?

Or like literally anything?

My wagon? It makes sense to vote a useless player, so being on it is null.

Mirhawk? I got no idea. Pretty much everything he does is not alignment-indicative to me.

Your argument with TSO? I'm ignoring it, it doesn't seem to be producing anything useful.

[Mirhawk]

Any on else have the feeling that i zy is scum?

I do.

MVP's claim hinged on producing Night 2 results. I feel like the doctor may have protected MVP Night 2 to give them the opportunity to produce those results since MVP was the only claimed PR. Not protecting an investigative roleclaim during their only night to produce results seems like a bad play. If he couldn't produce results when protected, then lynch him day 3.

But if Cabd's crumbing about having information to reveal on day 3 drew away the doctor's protection to Cabd last night, that left MVP open for the kill. Not being the doctor, I can't confirm the doctor's actions here but I think it's a distinct possibility that Cabd drew away the protection from MVP, which got MVP killed, intentionally or otherwise.

I don't want or need a doctor's claim here btw.

Why are you using occams razor to argue in favor MVP's target while simotaniously forwarding the most convoluted motive possible on Cabd.
Seeing as how scum probably have whatever PR stopped DJ's kill, town almost certainly has another PR. Is there some reason it can't be Cabd?

Remind me about the Mirhawk case. If it is in your ISO, just say so and I will check it out.

it's probably a bad sign when I can't even remember you pushing the Mirhawk wagon.

There was never a case per say, there was a bit of justification at some point. But I don't think a case was ever made. TWIE added me to his scumlist at some point during day one.

MVP kill is essentially scum telling us they dont have a roleblocker.

If they dont have a roleblocker and Mirhawk was the person that both heads of our vig agreed on Mirhawk should really be quite dead right now.

I'm interested to know why he isnt.

The only other option is that they shot Ceph, or that our mythical clearly not mafia doc saved one of (town) Mirhawk, Ceph, or Reinoe. (this is not likely)

And since I'm scumreading Mirhawk and not Ceph, I think we should lynch Mirhawk.

I didn't realize both heads wanted me dead, I thought it was just Titus.
Also if this is the logic you're lynching on I want you to lynch Cephrir tomorrow.

I don't think there's a town doc. Objectively the best play day one would have been to protect DJ, she was the scum target for a reason.

---

Anyways the days more then half over, I should get off the fence.

Vote: Toomai

The rest of you should probably start getting your vote on as well.

[Aegor]

I am not sure I like Mirhawk's vote.

[Mirhawk]

Eh, I'm only willing to lynch Toomai, Cephrir, or Izy at the moment.

I just picked the one I judged the most likely to have the support for a lynch.

Also, I'm pretty sure the fact you brought it up means you don't like it.

[Cephrir]

Izy

...

[Mirhawk]

I know, right?

I get that exact face sometimes when I read his posts.

[AngryPidgeon]

My wagon? It makes sense to vote a useless player, so being on it is null.

K tomorrow is my designated catchup on mafiascum day. Had a job interview this week, thigns have been cray.

[Toomai]

I am not sure I like Mirhawk's vote.

He voted for your game-long scumread, what's not to like?

[Cephrir]

It's not like it was a particularly sudden vote.

[Mirhawk]

The rest of you should probably start getting your vote on as well.

[Mirhawk]

we can wrangle over the details of who's getting lynched still. But we need to get some votes going first.