NY 176: Completely Ridiculous Mafia (Game Over)

[Cephrir]

I think I agree with the previous poster

[Mirhawk]

Shit that was my fault, I'm the tunnel monster.

Also, I'm thinking we need full disclosure at this point.

My thoughts on Cabd's alignment depend on what AP has to say.

[AngryPidgeon]

Call me Rose Tyler because I'm looking for a man with a sonic screwdriver.

I have a feeling I'm going to be a lot like state farm mafia this game.

I'm a nurse.

Dr. Who reference and I was a nurse in state farm mafia, I told GM was shocked that I managed to roll such an od role again when I saw it.

I also crumbed NURSE somewhere with sentences but I cant be bother ed to go look it up right now.

Apparently Cabd saw one or both of my crumbs and figured out what I was softing. I said that if I died he is scum because if he is what he is basically claiming to be (Doctor) then he should be parking his protection on me every single night. I don't have any guarantee that there is a Town Doctor in the game. My PM explicitly says that I become a doctor if *any* doctor dies. I kind of thought that a Mafia Doctor made sense after the MVP and Nero/Titus flips, but now I have no idea what to think. It's totally possible this is 4 scum with an RB/SM? or some thing heavy and town is stacked.

So plausible lylo today and if its not then Cabd is probably scum.

[AngryPidgeon]

Basically setup spec makes me lean scum on Cabd, but the way he called me out on my claim and softed his to me makes me heavily lean town. I have a hard time seeing scum putting themselves so far out there; also I'm fairly certain MVP kept talking about investigating Cabd and if he is a Mafia Doctor, why not just lay low and let them clear him? The MVP kill doesnt make much sense from Cabd scum in this case.

[ika]

he claimed bg i believe. so we have a problem

[TheWayItEnds]

So... since I already knew all that.

Does it say whether you would become a full doctor or an even night doctor or anything like that?

Or just if a doctor dies you become a doc?

[Mirhawk]

On a weird note, something just occurred to me that makes MVP's claim slightly more legit. Not going to explain.

N

othing too much else to add right now.

U

nderstandably people don't want to lynch MVP today, and I personally sort of want to see more of the setup to get a better sense of whether or not their role is in the game.

R

eally think Bob is the best lynch Today, DJ is town and Reinoe is meh.

S

till, deadline is basically almost here so if we could lynch someone ASAP that'd be fantastic (yes Cabd Im fully aware you are not voting anyone and that is even worse than a vanity wagon).

E

veryone needs to start consolidating votes (preferably on Bob).

This was somewhat of a pain to find. The first post also somewhat refers to his claim as well. The first one actually makes me think his claim is more legitimate then the second one.

Is alignment switching normal? If a mafia doc dies is it possible for a town player to switch sides as a backup? It seems to me that this could lead to some lylo shenanigans where it's impossible for town to win.

Reading AP's iso made me remember why I thought he was town. It also made me kind of care more again, I'm going to do more of them.

[Mirhawk]

Cabd, if you're a bodyguard why did you think AP's nurse crumb was legit?

Also who did you protect each day?

[ika]

Is alignment switching normal? If a mafia doc dies is it possible for a town player to switch sides as a backup? It seems to me that this could lead to some lylo shenanigans where it's impossible for town to win.

if you going to this line of quesitoing your thinking more along the lines of judas an salurus (may be wrong on this one)

where when they are lynched they change alignments (ones town and one scum, when lynched chat change sides)

but they are considered bastardized roles so i would say he just becomes town!doc

[ika]

i also want to hear actions, theres something thats inconsistent with it tbh

[Mirhawk]

The thing that's inconsistent is why are all of our PR's dead.

[ika]

The thing that's inconsistent is why are all of our PR's dead.

you werent suppose to say that, i was waiting for him to justify his actions but expalin how ever pr is dead

[Cephrir]

Is alignment switching normal?

Not even slightly

[Cephrir]

Well, he claimed to save scrambles, so... either he's lying or scum roleblocker.

[ika]

Well, he claimed to save scrambles, so... either he's lying or scum roleblocker.

it makes sense as scum rb merly by n1 kill alone if you think about it

[Cephrir]

Probably both, really.

[ika]

im half tempted to vote but at same time this is lylo so i want to hear others imputs....

also the fact there has been like no other votes but TSO on AP is akward

[ika]

I genuinely think reinoe is either ballsy enough or stupid enough to play "too stupid to be scum" as scum.

I have ~reasons~ to think reinoe slot is town.

i ran an iso but this is odd....

im gonna take a sleep off and then prob place my vote cus i rather not see any bltzing

[ika]

one question though for anyone:

is it technacly bastard to have a backup role (nurse) but not a primary (doc)?

or is that just frowned apoun or something?

[Cephrir]

Neither, it's very much a thing and no one seems to mind. For good reason, really.

[T S O]

yay no quickhammer

[TheWayItEnds]

On a weird note, something just occurred to me that makes MVP's claim slightly more legit. Not going to explain.

N

othing too much else to add right now.

U

nderstandably people don't want to lynch MVP today, and I personally sort of want to see more of the setup to get a better sense of whether or not their role is in the game.

R

eally think Bob is the best lynch Today, DJ is town and Reinoe is meh.

S

till, deadline is basically almost here so if we could lynch someone ASAP that'd be fantastic (yes Cabd Im fully aware you are not voting anyone and that is even worse than a vanity wagon).

E

veryone needs to start consolidating votes (preferably on Bob).

This was somewhat of a pain to find. The first post also somewhat refers to his claim as well. The first one actually makes me think his claim is more legitimate then the second one.

Is alignment switching normal? If a mafia doc dies is it possible for a town player to switch sides as a backup? It seems to me that this could lead to some lylo shenanigans where it's impossible for town to win.

Reading AP's iso made me remember why I thought he was town. It also made me kind of care more again, I'm going to do more of them.

I dont think switching sides could ever be normal.

But I have seen setups where if a Mafia Doc died the Town Nurse would become a Town Doc. I'm not sure if those setups were explicitly normal, but I would think they were?

[TheWayItEnds]

I didn't realize both heads wanted me dead, I thought it was just Titus.
Also if this is the logic you're lynching on I want you to lynch Cephrir tomorrow.

Is there a reason you stopped pushing this today?

No way.

If you lynch me you're not lynching Cabd after.

Can we talk about this too?

[T S O]

massclaim to fuck

Vt

[TheWayItEnds]

...Also is there anyone around who wants to talk set up with me?

Pedit

Also Yes.

Massclaim.

VT