Mini 1611: Wet Fever Dream Mafia. Ended.

[Honey bee]

The thing about bert is that him being scum would involve bbmolla lying and him actually preforming the ak nk and it seems like such a strange thing to lie about. This game is probably broken now in towns favor as we have 3 lynches still with two confirmed.

[Who]

Why Bert? I doubt scum would gladiate their partner

This is ika we're talking about. It's a definite posibility.

The thing about bert is that him being scum would involve bbmolla lying and him actually preforming the ak nk and it seems like such a strange thing to lie about. This game is probably broken now in towns favor as we have 3 lynches still with two confirmed.

True, nevermind, forgot about that.

That leaves either elmo or one of the faith healers. Though my money's on HB but there's no point in lynching HB atm.

[Bert]

Scenario 1

Everyone's town and telling the truth.

Optimal play-vote ika.

Likelihood-medium

Scenario 2

Bert's telling the truth. Ika is a scum gladiator.

Optimal play-vote ika.

Likelihood-medium

Scenario 3

Bert's a mafia role cop trying to pass off as JOAT hoping to fabricate results tomorrow.

Optimal play-vote off Bert

Likelihood-low

Scenario 4

Bert's a mafia JOAT

Optimal play-vote off Bert

Likelihood-very low

***

I agree Bert seems townish, and I feel his role is probably going to sort itself out if he is lying, though I'm not sure he is.

VOTE: ika

It's really hard to get fired up for this game.

ika: claimed troll role
BB: claimed lyncher
AK: 100% confirmed neighbor
reinoe: IC
elmo: win condition cop, which I guess is technically like a normal cop?

We don't really have a lot of time left, a little over 4 days.

In all honesty, the closer we get, I'm willing to lynch Who, Cho, honey bee, DarkLightA, and T S O. I also am dubious of BBMolla's entry into the game and would not lose sleep if we lynched him instead. Anyone else I'd be less okay with. Some of those names though are there in part because they're deadweight (which ika is too at this point).

honey bee:

If you're going to make a policy to lynch someone then the jester and scum are going to figure it out and use it to their advantage lol. That's probably a good reason not to randomize too as when we know who the jester we can read the wagons on em.

VOTE: theaceofspades u think ak scum y/n?

"Let's not policy lynch. Also I'm going to vote for the jester."

Maybe too obvious? Or maybe the N1 kill was worth the risk.

honey bee votes elmo in 150. Then there's this post:

That aceofspades post is giving me all sorts of scum feels.

Also:

VOTE: Elmo

Choo choo

problematic. She announces that she's on the elmo wagon...but wants to make it known that aceofspades seems like a pretty good lynch too.

I don't like this. I thought it might be too obvious for scum to try and drag the jester down. Seeing the switch to Elmo gives me a little pause especially iirc she returns to aceofspades.

Vote: Honey bee

Oh and I have no read on bins not sure why. Not finished but I figured I might as well post where I'm at for now and see what happens.

Currently maybe a third/halfway through day 1. Analysis incoming in subsequent posts.

Those I would vote for:
Who
Cho
DarkLightA
T S O
honeybee
Bins

Those I probably won't vote for:
Elmo
AK
ika

Never vote for:
jon's replacement
STD

Ah. Well if we're just going to the RVS, then VOTE: DarkLightA. I mean, that's what we're doing, right? Your reasoning is "I hate your post. Not going to say way. I just hate it." And your reasoning is "I'm scumreading ZazieR. Not going to say why, I just am."

I would not be surprised if DarkLightA's scum but I don't really have anything better than the fact he spent a lot of time calculating jester plan. I think that's a great front for scum but obviously not damning.

I think ika is town, I think AK is town though not confirmed, I think TSO is town.

I have null reads on pretty much everyone else, slightly leaning red on DarkLightA, maybe honey bee since maybe one scum gambled on jester.

That seems a lot better than this crap

I don't have any reads.

Or this crap

hmmmmm....

to be a jerk and use role or not.......

sigh, must wait

So if Elmo's so obv scum versus everyone else, tell me why the fuck Elmo is ten times better than the other shit in this thread.

Wake me up when we start playing mafia plz.

I'm a little wary of honeybee...if scum just flat out ignored the jester, they would have a hard time getting the jester lynched. HoneyBee and KA were people on aceofspades for a lot of the day. It's hard to tell if scum would be so blatant though.

DarkLightA bothered me yesterday, I'm eager to see what he says today.

AK is confirmed neighbor but not confirm town. I'm leaning town for now but I don't want to lose sight of that.

I'm not opposed to wagoning Elmo but is there anything specific about his play that bothered you guys?

ika, jester's dead, we get it, you have a silly role. Care to say anything else about this game?

[Bert]

The thing about bert is that him being scum would involve bbmolla lying and him actually preforming the ak nk and it seems like such a strange thing to lie about. This game is probably broken now in towns favor as we have 3 lynches still with two confirmed.

? I don't understand the first part. What does Bb's n2 claimed no-action have to do with me?

Cell messed my quote wall up. Ouch.

[reinoe]

Why Bert? I doubt scum would gladiate their partner

Right. That's the thing. At the time there was some decent support for a lynch of Honeybee and/or STD. Although nobody opposed IKA gladiatoring (sp?) DLA/Bert, Honeybee seemed like mislynch bait at the time. (I think she's town now)

Plus Bert is JOAT (3x investigative roles) when we have a wincon cop. It's not a great case but that's why I hate relying on gut.

[Honey bee]

The thing about bert is that him being scum would involve bbmolla lying and him actually preforming the ak nk and it seems like such a strange thing to lie about. This game is probably broken now in towns favor as we have 3 lynches still with two confirmed.

? I don't understand the first part. What does Bb's n2 claimed no-action have to do with me?

Cell messed my quote wall up. Ouch.

Well, what did you do night 2 and what did you not do night 2?

[Elmo TeH AzN]

I've been trolled

[T S O]

Is there any point me not giving results?

[Bert]

Well, what did you do night 2 and what did you not do night 2?

N2, I followed STD and got "recruit" as his action. Ika got lynched D2, and STD was mafia that couldn't kill. STD's abilities/modifications aren't known to his scumbuddies according to his role PM flip.

Is it possible scum can perform two actions at night? if so, HB can't be "cleared" by sending fruit on a night a kill goes through. because honey bee happened to send fruit to the one person (AK) that died on the ONLY night there was a kill.

[Bert]

him actually preforming the ak nk and it seems like such a strange thing to lie about. T

BBMolla lied about a lot of things and wasn't town.

[Honey bee]

No scum cant perform two actions at night. that's why your cleared and how I'm trying to be cleared. but at this point it doesn't matter because elmo can clear 2 people.

[Elmo TeH AzN]

No scum cant perform two actions at night. that's why your cleared and how I'm trying to be cleared. but at this point it doesn't matter because elmo can clear 2 people.

I've been trolled

So what's your wincon Honey. It doesn't match anyone.

[Honey bee]

Town, who did you compare me to.

[Bert]

So what's your wincon Honey. It doesn't match anyone.

VOTE: honey bee

[T S O]

Wait until he explains.

[Elmo TeH AzN]

So let's run this down. Because SVD was alive and for some reason Reinoe is still alive I went to have a town wincon in the book so something would match.
Well I investigated Reinoe N3. Because well hes the obv town in this game.
N4 Investigated Honey. Doesn't match anyone.
Hence the first post

I've been trolled

So there you have it. Whats your wincon because its obv you are a 3rd party Or Mafioso

[Honey bee]

....
Did you read reinoes wincon....

[Elmo TeH AzN]

>_> Im going to sit over here.

[Elmo TeH AzN]

Wait wait wait...
But what about this
-You're still alive when all threats to the town are eliminated.

[Honey bee]

Vanilla Townie:

You win when all threats to the town are eliminated.

Town Innocent Scumhunter:

-

You're still alive

when all threats to the town are eliminated.

They're different.

[Who]

Did you check the multiple wincons thing?

Because Honey Bee's not matching mine means scum.

[Honey bee]

she investigated reinoe n3 and me n4. As I understand it the wincon is compared to the previous person not all previous people.

[T S O]

you IDIOT

[Bert]

you IDIOT

Hey TSO!!
General TSO!!

Trick or treat? Pick



/mobile

[Bert]

O Henry

Or

Baby ruth