Open 577: Hope Plus One! (GAME OVER - SCUM WIN)

[Mathdino]

VOTE: Aneninen
for asking to be in a townbloc.

[Cane + Able]

VOTE: Constantine

Because forming townbloc..

[Cane + Able]

VOTE: Constantine

Because forming townbloc..

-House

[blindmewithscience]

VOTE: Constantine
Because he's Constantine

[Cane + Able]

VOTE: Constantine
Because he's Constantine

RVS is over.

[Mathdino]

VOTE: Constantine
Because he's Constantine

Is this a serious vote?

Edit: Ninja'd.

[blindmewithscience]

VOTE: Constantine
Because he's Constantine

RVS is over.

Man, already missed RVS
If so, then I guess I'll just
UNVOTE:
Interesting how Constantine gives two separate reasons for joining the game in 34 an 36. Not saying they both can't be true, but this switch is weird.

[Cane + Able]

VOTE: Constantine
Because he's Constantine

RVS is over.

Man, already missed RVS
If so, then I guess I'll just
UNVOTE:
Interesting how Constantine gives two separate reasons for joining the game in 34 an 36. Not saying they both can't be true, but this switch is weird.

Wake is half of Cane + Able, so he really didn't.

-House

[blindmewithscience]

Wow, completely missed that you were a hydra...

[Cane + Able]

Wow, completely missed that you were a hydra...

Interesting town slip.

Question is whether it was intentional.

[blindmewithscience]

Sorry, I'm confused. How is that post a townslip at all? (Apologies if I'm asking dumb questions-I'm not exactly a mafia veteran)

[Mathdino]

Note to self: BMWS and C+A are not scum together.

[Mathdino]

VOTE: Constantine
Because he's Constantine

RVS is over.

Man, already missed RVS
If so, then I guess I'll just
UNVOTE:
Interesting how Constantine gives two separate reasons for joining the game in 34 an 36. Not saying they both can't be true, but this switch is weird.

Why did you unvote directly before providing a reason to be suspicious of Constantine? Your 'random' vote wasn't exactly a bad one.

[Cane + Able]

Sorry, I'm confused. How is that post a townslip at all? (Apologies if I'm asking dumb questions-I'm not exactly a mafia veteran)

Scum tends to pay attention to pre/early game happenings for scheming and reputation building purposes.

Town doesn't have much to do pre-game and may miss out on details.

[Cane + Able]

VOTE: Constantine
Because he's Constantine

RVS is over.

Man, already missed RVS
If so, then I guess I'll just
UNVOTE:
Interesting how Constantine gives two separate reasons for joining the game in 34 an 36. Not saying they both can't be true, but this switch is weird.

Why did you unvote directly before providing a reason to be suspicious of Constantine? Your 'random' vote wasn't exactly a bad one.

His reason for suspicion was unfounded.

-House

[blindmewithscience]

Why did you unvote directly before providing a reason to be suspicious of Constantine? Your 'random' vote wasn't exactly a bad one.

I voted Constantine simply because he was Cinstantine, and from my (cough) past experiences (cough) with him, just wanted to. And I didn't really think that what I pointed out was a good reason to vote Constantine. That inconsistency wasn't really scummy IMO.

[Cane + Able]

Note to self: BMWS and C+A are not scum together.

A bit early for associative tells.

-House

[Mathdino]

But not too early for townslips?

The idea is just that if y'all were scum together, BMWS probably would've known the hydra stuff. I honestly don't think that was a townslip though, I could see him doing that as scum with you as town.

[Cane + Able]

Sorry, I'm confused. How is that post a townslip at all? (Apologies if I'm asking dumb questions-I'm not exactly a mafia veteran)

If you knew how your post was a townslip, then by definition it wouldn't be a townslip.

-House

[Cane + Able]

But not too early for townslips?

Never too early for townslip because those are often done in a single derp post.

Associative tells develop over time. Everyone will be interacting in interesting ways until we feel each other out.

[St Constantine the Hermit]

VOTE: BMWS
For being BMWS

[Mathdino]

One of us isn't making sense House, and I'm inclined to think it's you. I don't think BMWS's derp post is enough to make him town, but I think it's enough to show he's not scum with you. Your interaction with him doesn't say anything.

But here's the thing. If you think he's town for that, wouldn't that mean you agree that he's not scum with you? There's no disagreement here.

lol dat omgus

[Cane + Able]

But not too early for townslips?

The idea is just that if y'all were scum together, BMWS probably would've known the hydra stuff. I honestly don't think that was a townslip though, I could see him doing that as scum with you as town.

Or you could, you know, play smart and hunt for town instead of scum, then vote off scum via PoE.

Aside from blatantly terrible scummy moves, I'm more interested in finding town than scum because scum will become clear soon enough.

BMWS isn't being lynched today, and quite likely not tomorrow unless he derps pretty hard.

-House

[St Constantine the Hermit]

For the record, I'm not letting this become another mathdino dominated game. He didn't exactly lead town to scum in the last few games he was in, and I'm not ready for the mindless scum to start latching on to him.

[Mathdino]

How bout you not talk about ongoing games, Constantine?

Not exactly ready for you to start clogging up the thread, mate.

@C+A: The issue is that 'townslip' doesn't discount the fact that he unvoted Constantine and then cast suspicion on him.