Reck's Retrospective Rehash - OVER (thx obama)

[Riddleton]

Cause we have 4 days till the deadline and nobody is willing to push those wagons. I'll try again tomorrow, but we don't have enough time to pressure lurkers now.

4 days is plenty.

[xRECKONERx]

Official Vote Count

PeregrineV

(8): Triforce, 50 Shades of Purple, ooba, Aegor, Untrod Tripod, ChannelDelibird, 4burner, vezokpiraka

Aegor

(3): Bella, BROseidon, Riddleton

Chevre

(3): Shinobi, Kise, Iecerint

vezokpiraka

(2): PeregrineV, ZZZX

Kise

(1): CrashTextDummie

Shinobi

(1): Chevre

Not Voting

(3): Cabd, ActionDan, jmj3000

With 21 alive, it takes 11 to lynch.

Deadline

: (expired on 2014-11-18 18:00:00)

[Riddleton]

My scumread on Aegor is in-sync with BRO's similar thought process on him in these two posts. I agree with them completely; Aegor's list looks oppurtunistic.

I admit my case on Kise was flawed. When viewing his activity ISOs, I looked at the total posts produced, but not the timestamps. It's since been proven that his activity isn't indicative of his alignment. I'm

slightly

suspicious of people like Triforce, Aegor & CTD for being so willing to jump onto my case without looking through it too much. Townpoints for CDB and ooba for analysing things beyond the surface level and commenting their disapproval of my case. If they were scum, they would have an easy excuse to jump onto the wagon, and the fact they didn't tells me they are probably town.

[Cabd]

I am getting nothing done today because holy shit i am moving and oh my god i have so much fucking stuff to pack.

I will honor sheep one of mollie or iece here probably.

[vezokpiraka]

Does anyone feel that this is scum ooba?

Hmm.. not really, I don't see that. I weakly townread him particularly for his earlier game activity. I very much agree with his thoughts on massclaiming, and his setup information provided in these two posts are pretty helpful I think.

Those things came from a very calculated mindset. That is exactly how ooba scum functions.

[Iecerint]

Do the people on the P5 wagon still think he's scum, or is the attitude more like "to hell with it"?

[Shinobi]

Do the people on the P5 wagon still think he's scum, or is the attitude more like "to hell with it"?

Am wondering this as well.

[ooba]

Mixed feelings about Pere for a while now. Also, I think ZZZX is town.

Vote: Aegor

I'd be okay with a Chevre lynch today too.

[vezokpiraka]

Mixed feelings about Pere for a while now. Also, I think ZZZX is town.

Vote: Aegor

I'd be okay with a Chevre lynch today too.

What makes you think ZZZX is town?

[Triforce]

I'm just going to point out that no where have we actually agreed with any "case" on Kise, and only thought he was a good lynch because of CTDs comments.

That would also be the point at which we decided to kick him out of honorary commune status...I think. I mostly just remember a vague conversation I had with the other half where we agree with CTD that Kise looked sketch.

We'll get back to you on PV but would love for certain people to be more active or replaced.

[ooba]

Mixed feelings about Pere for a while now. Also, I think ZZZX is town.

Vote: Aegor

I'd be okay with a Chevre lynch today too.

What makes you think ZZZX is town?

Last two posts. Doesn't look like it's calculated - 'genuine' vibe.

[ActionDan]

Oh yeah, PV is rather town, would not lynch. Aegor isn't necessarily scum. read pending

[Iecerint]

Whatever, let's just lynch dan.

Unvote; Vote: ActionDan

I think Chevre is the most likely to be scum, but I don't realistically see him being lynched today.

[Riddleton]

Whatever, let's just lynch dan.

Unvote; Vote: ActionDan

I think Chevre is the most likely to be scum, but I don't realistically see him being lynched today.

God no. Not lynching a lurker.

[ChannelDelibird]

I'm actually very tempted to move to Dan. Iecerint's right that the PV wagon could do with a health-check; town just shrugging after a wagon sat around with a big lead for several days is what got wgeurts mislynched. PV has at least bucked his ideas up a bit as a result of the wagon and we've got more to work on later if we need to go back to him. I can't admit to any kind of surety that he would flip scum. Also still open to a 4burner wagon if that happens but none of the other current options particularly enthuse me (closest is Aegor but I'd rather lynch Dan first at this point, I think).

UNVOTE: PeregrineV
VOTE: ActionDan

[Iecerint]

Number of times I have actually regretted lynching a lurker on this site: 0.

[Untrod Tripod]

what the fuck

don't get me wrong, I want to lynch Dan too, but this looks like you're trying to swing it away from PV

[Riddleton]

I second the 'what the fuck'. I would like to take this lustrious oppurtunity to lynch scum.

Aegor is a fine lynch today. So is 4burner.

[Iecerint]

what the fuck

don't get me wrong, I want to lynch Dan too, but this looks like you're trying to swing it away from PV

It's almost like I don't particularly think that PV is scum.

[Untrod Tripod]

well no one's perfect

[Riddleton]

except me

[ActionDan]

I suppose it wouldn't really help if I used my get out of jail free card here would it. Since the townies are voting me out of frustration and PV isn't scum?

[ActionDan]

wait. It's like 3 days from deadline. why so serious?

[ActionDan]

anyway some quick reads.
ZZZX - town
4burnr - town

[ActionDan]

this is in addition to those reads I've given previously aka

iec - town
CDB - town