Reck's Retrospective Rehash - OVER (thx obama)

[Aegor]

My justification is explicit.

[ActionDan]

^not even directly related to whatever point you were making

[xRECKONERx]

Official Vote Count

Aegor

(5): Bella, BROseidon, Riddleton, Kise, ActionDan

PeregrineV

(4): 50 Shades of Purple, 4burner, vezokpiraka, Cabd

Kise

(4): CrashTextDummie, Iecerint, ooba, Triforce

ActionDan

(4): ChannelDelibird, Aegor, Untrod Tripod, PeregrineV

Shinobi

(1): Chevre

vezokpiraka

(1): ZZZX

Chevre

(1): Shinobi

Not Voting

(1): jmj3000

With 21 alive, it takes 11 to lynch.

Deadline

: (expired on 2014-11-18 18:00:00)

[Aegor]

LOL@ four roughly equal wagons.

[pirate mollie]

mollie, you do realize that Cabd is moving 1/2 way across the country, right?

yes.

but why would you think that he would proxy me his vote over you?

[50 Shades of Purple]

mollie, you do realize that Cabd is moving 1/2 way across the country, right?

yes.

but why would you think that he would proxy me his vote over you?

pick up.

[50 Shades of Purple]

LOL@ four roughly equal wagons.

and?

[jmj3000]

Holy shit. I've got to buckle down and read. Doing that all night.

[Shinobi]

Yeah idk who to vote.

[vezokpiraka]

@crashtestdummy: your last part of the post about me makes no sense. Why did you insult in a way that is not understamdable?

[BROseidon]

mollie, you do realize that Cabd is moving 1/2 way across the country, right?

yes.

but why would you think that he would proxy me his vote over you?

There'd be multiple potential reasons regardless of his alignment, so I don't get what you're gunning at here.

[Shinobi]

I thought I'd have the answer as to where my vote would go today, but I don't really feel confident in any of the wagons right now. I'll probably throw my vote down on whoever to ensure a lynch at EoD if I can, but that's the best I can do at this point. I feel like I've squandered my time today and I'll try to pick up my play tomorrow.

[Iecerint]

I would prefer Aegor or Kise.

[50 Shades of Purple]

mollie, you do realize that Cabd is moving 1/2 way across the country, right?

yes.

but why would you think that he would proxy me his vote over you?

There'd be multiple potential reasons regardless of his alignment, so I don't get what you're gunning at here.

okay. what would those multiple reasons be?

and where would he get the idea to proxy a vote

ever

?

he isn't townreading the slot who first did it in fact I am very unsure of any reads he has except for his big long post he made with his entrance but they at this point lack any sort of developement. I VERY much empathize with the move I remember how hard games were when I was moving and I only moved to a different city. *squeezes cabd*

and there is a part of me that very much likes cabd and wishes I did not have this suspicion.

but it isn't like I can ignore a thought process that I do not understand and that seems unnatural. he isn't being run up and is in no danger of being lynched, so why the hard defense for something that is null (the move, lack of activity) but instead going after how he handled it?

it was a very strange thing to do.

[4burner]

Official Vote Count

Aegor

(5): Bella, BROseidon, Riddleton, Kise, ActionDan

PeregrineV

(4): 50 Shades of Purple, 4burner, vezokpiraka, Cabd

Kise

(4): CrashTextDummie, Iecerint, ooba, Triforce

ActionDan

(4): ChannelDelibird, Aegor, Untrod Tripod, PeregrineV

Shinobi

(1): Chevre

vezokpiraka

(1): ZZZX

Chevre

(1): Shinobi

Not Voting

(1): jmj3000

With 21 alive, it takes 11 to lynch.

Deadline

: (expired on 2014-11-18 18:00:00)

Ok super late check in and I'm totes gonna be late for dinner but whatever.

PV wagon stalled, as someone mentioned in much the same way as wguerts which is curious.
Aegor is leading wagon, but of the wagon I'm only really townleaning on BRO, but that's subjective to me rather than any real info regarding the wagon's makeup prior to a flip. Could lynch given the AD push and the info it would give.
Kise wagon is late entrance but I could see it. There's probably enough information in the play to be a gainful lynch even if the flip is town. Also I like CTD's entrance and have townish on Iec and ooba, and my Tri suspicions are probably unwarranted.
AD I don't think we lynch on Day 2. Maybe day 3 if the contribution doesn't pick up. We aren't near endgame yet, we've got one caught scum already, not a priority. It would be less informative than any other wagon's lynch. Coupled with the fact that the wagon aside from CDB is iffy and no, I don't like it.

I could get behind a Vezo lynch, but with not much time remaining I don't see it happening. Also if Kise becomes the wagon I could move to secure it later when I check back in, but as lead wagon and probably the best available right now I'mma VOTE: Aegor


Be back later.

[4burner]

Wow 10 hours to go and it's a ghost town.

[Iecerint]

It's 8 AM.

[Chevre]

Unvote

OK, I probably shouldn't have disappeared for a week, but I think I just had internal guttural problems with my Shinobi vote which I didn't know how to rectify. Like when Iecerint asked "what is the

real

case on Shinobi?" and I tried to trip back through his ISO looking for solid examples of that flippant response to votes I had oft cited it just wasn't there in the way I thought it was. I still think Shinobi is a little bit shady but it's not worth a vote on him.

That being said, I do not like the way PV's wagon disappeared in the cluster that was the last 10 pages of this game. I disagree with Triforce that it is not like the wgeurts wagon. That wagon stagnated for a bit while votes just tacked on here and there until we reached lynch. This one, on the other hand, died down and other options built up, which seems very very shady to me (even though at least two out of the other three I could also see a case on). This is exactly why I'm moving my vote there.

Vote: PeregrineV

I will not get home before this game hits deadline, just so that is known.

[Iecerint]

If my skepticism of the Shinobi wagon made you reconsider that wagon, why doesn't my skepticism of the PV wagon similarly make you reconsider it? You make it sound like the PV wagon disappeared into the ether under dubious circumstances, but you have simultaneously apparently decided to unvote Shinobi because of my influence.

More generally, why are you persuaded by my take on Shinobi when I think you're scum? Why are you not more disturbed that I think you're scum?

[jmj3000]

This is going to sound hypocritical as fuck, and I don't care. I hate how Riddleton is insisting on not lynching lurkers. Lurkers are how scum hide. Lurkers are hwo scum st-up mislynches at the most inopportune times. His posts sound like he wants a safety net for later in the game, so he won't have to work too hard. However, I can come to terms with an ActionDan lynch not happening in ~8 hours, unless more people can be convinced. Also, looking through PV's ISO, he has contributed more than Aegor. Aegor seems to take what everyone else has said, paraphrases it so it seems like he thought of it, then posts it. ActionDan did a flurry of fluffy posting, and threw his vote on the largest wagon that wasn't his,after only mentioning that Aegor wasn't necessarily scum. He hasn't come up with a case, hasn't expressed any more suspicion on him, nothing. I hate when I see a flurry of fluff posts followed by a vote. It makes me instantly dislike you, and not trust the vote. ActionDan's ISO doesn't inspire me with confidence because I don't see any reads that weren't already being said by others before him.

Vote: ActionDan

[Shinobi]

I'm around. Whoever gets to L-1 should just claim since town can't be assed to build wagons properly.

[vezokpiraka]

I'm here.

I'll vote in a way to prevent deadline no lynch.

[xRECKONERx]

Official Vote Count

Aegor

(6): Bella, BROseidon, Riddleton, Kise, ActionDan, 4burner

ActionDan

(5): ChannelDelibird, Aegor, Untrod Tripod, PeregrineV, jmj3000

PeregrineV

(4): 50 Shades of Purple, vezokpiraka, Cabd, Chevre

Kise

(4): CrashTextDummie, Iecerint, ooba, Triforce

vezokpiraka

(1): ZZZX

Chevre

(1): Shinobi

Not Voting

(0):

None.

With 21 alive, it takes 11 to lynch.

Deadline

: (expired on 2014-11-18 18:00:00)

[Shinobi]

If nothing happens in 3 hours I'm just going to vote.

[PeregrineV]

I want to vote Aegor just to make sure lynch happens, except that 4burners defense of his nullread ActionDan makes me not want to move my vote.