You could be anyone II - Game Over

[Ankamius]

This argument's only useful for shitting up the thread at this point. Campaign me all you want if you care enough.

Yeah, getting frustrated at tunneling and giving up on fruitless arguments gets you scum read with this town.

I'll believe it when I see it. Unless the last few half-page changes everything, I'm not being lynched today anyways.

[Kthxbye]

Then why do your posts look so jagged? You state the same point twice in the first post and your mention about 'saving' me makes no sense with that reasoning at all.

StrangerCoug is town.

% of sureness of the above comment?

[PeregrineV]

Then why do your posts look so jagged? You state the same point twice in the first post and your mention about 'saving' me makes no sense with that reasoning at all.

StrangerCoug is town.

% of sureness of the above comment?

Greater than 51%.

[PeregrineV]

Just finished game featuring House-scum

http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=1&t=58830

[Ankamius]

Just finished game featuring House-scum

http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=1&t=58830

How does that affect your read on him this game?

[PeregrineV]

Just finished game featuring House-scum

http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=1&t=58830

How does that affect your read on him this game?

Based on this, competence is scum for him. Making him probably town. But, I'll read him over again in ISO with an eye towards this.

[House]

Just finished game featuring House-scum

http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=1&t=58830

How does that affect your read on him this game?

Based on this, competence is scum for him. Making him probably town. But, I'll read him over again in ISO with an eye towards this.

So, post-game self meta is acceptable for future game meta declarations?

[Kthxbye]

So, after reading up on Titus:

-I think Nero is town.
-PM is still town.
-PV is likely town unless Titus really thought she'd never be lynched. 515 is way too early to be calling scum buddies town imo.
***I still very much like Josh for scum. see 655 and 708. I don't run into encryptors often enough to comment on them before they flip. Scum slip I think in 655 and more info than town should have in 708.
-TD likely town for same reasons as PV. 656 and 664. Almost like Titus was begging town to case town.
-Rach is very hard to read due to lack of posting. Meh, not feeling scum but not feeling town either....
-d3x is still town. Titus basically licks his balls all game because he came out strong town from the start. Looks like trying to be on his good side vs trying to colaberate in thread. This strengthened by the fact scum HAD day talk. Also, if d3x is going to bus, he's not going to jump off scum-Titus when she's at L-1. If he's gonna bus, he's gonna bus hard.
-TWIE is likely town.
-House maybe town due to Titus's hard core wanting to get his claim out if it was a cop claim. Kinda not sure why he wasn't targeted last night though if group scum thought this was the case...hmmm

Think I'll keep my vote on Josh.

[Kthxbye]

eyes started to blurr a bit. will be back with more from Titus reading.

[PeregrineV]

Just finished game featuring House-scum

http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=1&t=58830

Lol @ posting the link in every game we're in together.

Very fresh meta. Very good to use to compare, esp. with you as scum in that game.

[PeregrineV]

Just finished game featuring House-scum

http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=1&t=58830

How does that affect your read on him this game?

Based on this, competence is scum for him. Making him probably town. But, I'll read him over again in ISO with an eye towards this.

So, post-game self meta is acceptable for future game meta declarations?

You're most likely being honest since you are still flush with victory. Concurrent play most likely means you play similar alignments similarly. You are new to the site so have less distracting games that you might try to use different playstyles.

[PeregrineV]

So, after reading up on Titus:

-I think Nero is town.
-PM is still town.
-PV is likely town unless Titus really thought she'd never be lynched. 515 is way too early to be calling scum buddies town imo.
***I still very much like Josh for scum. see 655 and 708. I don't run into encryptors often enough to comment on them before they flip. Scum slip I think in 655 and more info than town should have in 708.
-TD likely town for same reasons as PV. 656 and 664. Almost like Titus was begging town to case town.
-Rach is very hard to read due to lack of posting. Meh, not feeling scum but not feeling town either....
-d3x is still town. Titus basically licks his balls all game because he came out strong town from the start. Looks like trying to be on his good side vs trying to colaberate in thread. This strengthened by the fact scum HAD day talk. Also, if d3x is going to bus, he's not going to jump off scum-Titus when she's at L-1. If he's gonna bus, he's gonna bus hard.
-TWIE is likely town.
-House maybe town due to Titus's hard core wanting to get his claim out if it was a cop claim. Kinda not sure why he wasn't targeted last night though if group scum thought this was the case...hmmm

Think I'll keep my vote on Josh.

What do you think about 3654? If TD is town, why do scum try so hard to NOT lynch him? Is FFFFFF more dangerous?

[d3x]

@Garmr- Why did you choose to not respond to anything else from my p3583? I'm curious to hear a response to the 2ndary Lynch Claim. Did I understand you correctly when I said you asserted that 5 players would back the mollieWagon? And then I showed that this was a lie?

@Kthx3591- No, I don't think it's harsh at all. Not only have I used that exact terminology earlier in this game, we're talking about Lynching someone. Lynching is pretty harsh, bro. I fail to see the difference. Or are you saying that my placement of you on my List is harsh?

@mollie3594- I hear what you're saying, but I'm not about to Lynch anyone who's not on my Scum List. I legitimately feel bad that you're having a shitshow time of it, love. I wish that wasn't the case, but it is.

This needs to die Today. I'm not moving my Vote.

@Ank3598 {and anyone else fronting this opinion}- Explain to me NeroScum. I refuse to believe that 4/6 Wagoners were all ScumMates.

Spoiler: VoteCount

Official Vote Count

TiphaineDeath

(6):

T S O

, TheWayItEnds, Kthxbye, StrangerCoug,

FFAE00 FFED00

, Mom<Ank>

FFAE00 FFED00

(6):

Titus

, Majiffy<Kise>,

I Am Innocent

, Nero Cain,

vezokpiraka

,

Aunt Jemina

Garmr

(1):

I have no creativity

pirate mollie

(1): Josh_B

T S O

(1): TiphaineDeath

Hostile Intent

(1): pirate mollie

StrangerCoug

(1): PeregrineV

Yiley

(1): d3x

TheWayItEnds

(1): Garmr

Not Voting

(6): inte<Pine>,

Hostile Intent

,

Wake88

, RachMarie, Lucky2u, Yiley<Fish>

@P5- ^^ That is what you are not answering. You are

still

Voting Nero and not responding to me regarding this issue.

@page145- There seem to be a bunch of people talking about supporting a FishWagon without actually pushing/Voting. That bothers me almost as much as the landscape of Wagons being attempted have all pretty much shifted once a FishWagon became the out and out front runner. If he flips Scum, this will definitely be key to finding his partner{s}.

In 1165, 4 of the votes on FFFFF are scum.

Explain.

[d3x]

Think I'll keep my vote on Josh.

Not only is your Vote not on Josh, it'd better not change to Josh. Fish is the clear Lynch for Today.

[Kthxbye]

youre right, forgot it was on fish.

UNVOTE:

till I finish my scum iso's

[Ankamius]

@Ank3598 {and anyone else fronting this opinion}- Explain to me NeroScum. I refuse to believe that 4/6 Wagoners were all ScumMates.

Sure.

I don't usually go after indies I think it is a waste of time

I could buy that you are the sk.

I'd also be ok with a pl of Titus.

This is the original post that got me to scumread Nero. He posts noncommittal reads on two controversial players. This wasn't as relevant at the time, but he never did jack shit with either of them the entire day phase.

New scumreads:

pirate mollie and

Nero Cain.

*waves hand*

This is not the scum you are looking for.

oh nm, you are in the mom slot, no wonder you are trying to mislynch me.

His response to me posting that I have a scumread on him. He dismisses it out of turn with reasoning that makes no sense. If you look at the rest of his posts throughout the day phase, he kinda flipflops on Titus a bit, but the lack of anything concrete when he shows he's paying enough attention to somewhat follow the game is raising red flags.

He votes mollie here to start off day 4 with, but very quickly throws out that he's open to leashing as well. Even after there's a significant amount of open opposition to the mollie-wagon, he just camps on it passively until sheeping the wagon on me the moment it starts to form.

I didn't bother looking at his ISO before I replaced in, but his play the last two day phases screams scum flying under the radar as the more vocal players duke it out amongst themselves.

[Garmr]

@dex
Tbh I thought more people agreed on mollie being sk than but conversation is proving otherwise I don't know where this 5 thing is coming from through. Tbh I addressed the points to me and made notes about who you wanted to lynch over the course of the day. Also if its me wanting to lynch the sk now I have explained my reasoning of why it's best to deal with me or mollie now. Pretty much all your questions have been talked about by other people.

Or is you talking to other people because i did note what you said but I didn't want to interrupt your pushes.

Also if your going to say my view on how sk should be dealt with is wrong I'm going to say fuck off I changed my mind since day 3. If mollie is just going to say smart remarks and cry us a river all day I don't care how anti town i have to be she can die (ingame.)

[PeregrineV]

@Ank3598 {and anyone else fronting this opinion}- Explain to me NeroScum. I refuse to believe that 4/6 Wagoners were all ScumMates.

Official Vote Count

TiphaineDeath

(6):

T S O

, TheWayItEnds, Kthxbye, StrangerCoug,

FFAE00 FFED00

, Mom<Ank>

FFAE00 FFED00

(6):

Titus

, Majiffy<Kise>,

I Am Innocent

, Nero Cain,

vezokpiraka

,

Aunt Jemina

Garmr

(1):

I have no creativity

pirate mollie

(1): Josh_B

T S O

(1): TiphaineDeath

Hostile Intent

(1): pirate mollie

StrangerCoug

(1): PeregrineV

Yiley

(1): d3x

TheWayItEnds

(1): Garmr

Not Voting

(6): inte<Pine>,

Hostile Intent

,

Wake88

, RachMarie, Lucky2u, Yiley<Fish>

@P5- ^^ That is what you are not answering. You are

still

Voting Nero and not responding to me regarding this issue.

In 1165, 4 of the votes on FFFFF are scum.

Explain.

Since it's Tuesday with Thanksgiving coming up, I might be VLA over the holidays, so will claim this now.

I am the cop.

Night1: StrangerCoug is town
Night2: IamInnocent is scum
Night3: Nero is scum

So, on the 1165 vote count, there are 4 of the presumably 6 scummembers voting the counterwagon to TD. (could be Kise is scum too, but that would be too funny).
Since FFFFFF is not the Mafia God, this indicates to me that they did not want TD lynched. Very badly.
Making him highly likely to be scum, and should definitely be tomorrow's lynch.

tl:dr- Vote Nero

[House]

VOTE: Nero

Cop guilty

[PeregrineV]

VOTE: Nero

Cop guilty

And your last 2 selections for scum? (Throw in your SK guess too)

[House]

VOTE: Nero

Cop guilty

And your last 2 selections for scum? (Throw in your SK guess too)

No idea, you cleared the one I wanted dead the most.

[PeregrineV]

VOTE: Nero

Cop guilty

And your last 2 selections for scum? (Throw in your SK guess too)

No idea, you cleared the one I wanted dead the most.

OK, then lets regress. Do you have any reads on other players in this game?

[StrangerCoug]

Your 'saving' point doesn't make any sense because if you have to put that you think I'm scummy that many times, why would you you feel the need to save me from that situation in the first place?

I said I

WOULDN'T

, silly! Read!

I am the cop.

Night1: StrangerCoug is town
Night2: IamInnocent is scum
Night3: Nero is scum

Buying.

UNVOTE: Formerfish
VOTE: Nero

[Formerfish]

Vote: Nero

I have no reason not to believe you right now. And this seems like a pretty stupid thing for you to do if you were actually scum.

[PeregrineV]

Vote Nero

I have no reason not to believe you right now. And this seems like a pretty stupid thing for you to do if you were actually scum.

Well, considering I made it 1000% times easier, I expect that read/catchup will be done in the next few days, right?