Amy's
239 and
287 engage in point by point with Aneninen.
338 is trying to extend the case on Aneninen.
434 and
439 respond to criticism of her case on Anen by asking her critics to point out exactly where she's a hypocrite. This seems to be a reasonable approach. Weak town read.
Aneninen's posting style is a mixture of matching what I have seen before (but cannot be quoted) and different from what I've seen before. Previous experience has tended toward longer posts. I have seen some tunneling. The analysis in
389 looks town motivated, though scum could also do that if it would either clear a buddy or frame a townie. It may be strange to say this on someone with so many posts, but my read is null. I don't know how to read the change in posting style, and some of the posts which seem town have plausible (and perhaps even expected) scum possibilities.
------------------------------------
I saved Mathdino for last because there is so much information.
Lots of setup speculation. I'm not really comfortable with town trying to direct vig / vengeful because of the high probability that outspoken scum could control it by urging town to make bad suggestions.
50 looks busy but boils down to null reads. Votes Amy in
68 for "doing x would be useful as scum", which is a pretty null thing to say. More vig/vengeful discussion.
Post
137 "I'd like farside and Hayate to be town" jumped out at me, this always strikes me as odd. Post
145 could be role fishing.
152 switches to wgeurts, but would get back on Amy if necessary.
260 unvotes wgeurts, worried about wagons forming easily. (I disagree, the time to be worried is when they dissolve easily). Says in
269 that the amy wagon was different.
314 creeped out about people joining wagons he starts. This bothered me a bit, as town I want people to join my wagons. I can see that it's about the speed of the wagons, but even that is questionable to me as others could easily be reacting to what they see happening in the thread, not to who started the wagon.
375 is the post where he splits the player list into groups which "can't be scum together". This post is one which looks townie but is probably more useful to scum.
378 is again on the setup speculation.
426 unvotes (from Siv)
449 votes Alchemist, doesn't have a "top 3" -- has 2 lists based on flips. Looking back at that...
post 375 wrote:
If Siv's scum: Siveure, Romitelli, Amy, wgeurts, Adrien, Ankamius
If Siv's town: Alchemist, Aneninen, Amy, wgeurts, Flubbernugget, Ankamius
Which boils down to siv+romitelli+amy/wgeurts vs. Alchemist+Anen+amy/wgeurts. I find it interesting that the 3rd scum position, in both of these lists, is Amy or wgeurts, who he unvoted as being creeped out about how fast the wagons went. If he really thought they were scummy, why jump off the wagons so fast?
Overall, I get a weak scum on Mathdino.
