NY 179: Cute and Fluffy Mafia (Town Win)

[TheDudeAbides]

It's funny because you're attacking me for ignoring the second half of DS's post, but now you're attacking me by ignoring the first half of his post.

[Garmr]

TDA is flailing.

[AlternateAccount]

Now we wait to see if TDA's scumbuddies try to help bail him out or if he'll try to lurk away that epic backtrack...

[TheDudeAbides]

I really don't know what to make of the nonsense coming from those two.

[TheDudeAbides]

I'm pretty pissed at peacebringer for ignoring the argument when he posted.

[TheDudeAbides]

I'm actually shocked that AA just ignored what I posted about his attack. It makes it pretty clear that his argument is nonsense.

[YuniChikako]

Spoiler: dragonspawn and TDA stuffs that ended up being a bit long because quotes and redundancy(?)

I'm buddies with someone I don't know

I'd love to know why you said this, I mean it's a piece of information that I simply don't have access to.

if you don't know then you clearly can't read. But we both know you can since you managed to edit the post and cut off half the question as well as the request for you to produce some sort of reasoning for your accusation that I was buddying someone who I still haven't even seen a post from.

the question at this point is why go to the lengths of making an accusation, then editing the post asking you to back it up to try to incriminate me. It doesn't make any sense. It's also pretty darn scummy. But is that because you are scum o just completely insane and dishonest? I'm not sure yet. But you've definitely attracted my attention.

so would you please answer the original question of why you think I'm buddying Nero? I fugue the more you talk the easier it will be to determine your alignment.

I see dragonspawn as somewhat scummy, but not exactly in the same way as TDA does. dragonspawn seemed to have started to get serious on getting scum reads a bit early, so dragonspawn's post that seems to be "on trial", seems to have taken place around the time he really began reading into people's posts (#27 #44 (not sure if derping around on #44 or just..)) and I think it's his full reaction that's the problem:

Dragonspawn is Nero Cain's buddy.

I'm buddies with someone I don't know and hasn't posted yet?

I'd love to see the reasoning

The end part there is way more scummy than the single part that TDA edited ("I'm buddies with someone I don't know"). Especially the bolded part. It shows defensiveness. TDA's post was obviously him derping around. If dragonspawn's reply was ("I'm buddies with someone I don't know and hasn't posted yet. Best buddies lel") then it would have been okay. But that bolded part shows him taking TDA's RVS lulz seriously.

I can see where TDA was coming from, but the editing of the post was awkward and actually hurt his case, I think. It doesn't capture the seriousness of dragonspawn's post. If TDA is town, he's not doing a very good job after doing that. I can almost smell the bw.

Of course, it is entirely possible that dragonspawn is a "little bit too serious town" and TDA is scum trying to take advantage of that, but ended up steering his "suspicions" in a weird place. "I'd love to know why you said this, I mean it's a piece of information that I simply don't have access to" takes that certain edited part of dragonspawn's post too seriously. It's just a weird scum-read.

Or they're both town who take things a little too seriously. Who knows.

Not sure if I quite got my point across, and I may have been redundant. Anyway I think I'll hold out a bit longer and see how this turns out.
Oh, and I guess I should end these turtle shenanigans.
UNVOTE: firebound12

[YuniChikako]

And then after all that time I spent on my spoiler stuff:

TDA is flailing.

[TheDudeAbides]

"It's just a weird scum read."

The issue is that it's a disingenuous argument from DS. I have no way of knowing who he knows.

It's also not the only reason why I eventually voted him.

[Garmr]

"It's just a weird scum read."

The issue is that it's a disingenuous argument from DS. I have no way of knowing who he knows.

It's also not the only reason why I eventually voted him.

This isn't legit reasoning want to explain it.

I had planned on Bus'ing him much later, but he just wouldn't leave well enough alone. He forced my hand.

so the two of you are scum? Odd admission this early in the game.

That's certainly one way to read that post.

What are your thoughts on him {pen}?

not sure yet. The fact that he starts off showing he didn't bother to see who is playing and the omgused in the next post dont exactly scream town to me. But it's still too early for me to get a feel on whether I think he is scum.

Vote: Dragon Spawn

[Garmr]

@Yuna

What I see is tda jumping on newer player who's eager to break out of rvs.

[Nero Cain]

Lurking is suspicious

I agree. Good thing I'm not doing that.

guts leaning scum on IAI.

not sure what to think about TDA yet.

[TheDudeAbides]

Garmr, I did:

I'm voting Dragon Spawn mostly because of the -these things don't scream town to me, but not sure if scum- post. Doesn't scream town is mostly meaningless, and he's avoiding conflict by not saying that he finds those things, perhaps mildly, scummy, and if he doesn't want to suggest they are scummy, why tack on the not sure if scum part.

[Garmr]

Garmr, I did:

I'm voting Dragon Spawn mostly because of the -these things don't scream town to me, but not sure if scum- post. Doesn't scream town is mostly meaningless, and he's avoiding conflict by not saying that he finds those things, perhaps mildly, scummy, and if he doesn't want to suggest they are scummy, why tack on the not sure if scum part.

I swear you make stuff up for fun sighs.

I still don't see your point his just saying that he finds it scummy but it's early game. That rings to me a newer player saying what's on his mind.

[TheDudeAbides]

The point is that he doesn't say that he finds it scummy. He says doesn't scream town.

Despite being difficult, I think Garmr is trying to read me.

Unvote.
Vote: AA

Bullshit case, and trying to stifle discussion.

[AlternateAccount]

I'm actually shocked that AA just ignored what I posted about his attack. It makes it pretty clear that his argument is nonsense.

lurk away that epic backtrack...

I didn't ignore it. One minute you're claiming that Dragonspawn never said Nero never posted, and when you just get called out on your lie you move the goalposts hardcore.

I think maybe you didn't read what I posted.

The point is exactly that he didn't just say something about Nero not having posted, but he also said something about not knowing Nero, that was the point.

That's a pretty hardcore backtrack/goalpost move.

The point is that he doesn't say that he finds it scummy. He says doesn't scream town.

Despite being difficult, I think Garmr is trying to read me.

Unvote.
Vote: AA

Bullshit case, and trying to stifle discussion.

All OMGUS, All The Time.

[TheDudeAbides]

I have not backtracked on a single thing regarding DS.

[TheDudeAbides]

The only way AA could think that I backtracked as he's accusing me of is if he forgot why he attacked me in the first place.

[Kid A]

I just ISO'd myself, and noohing I've said could possibly be described as a nasty hack job.

VOTE: thedudeabides

[TheDudeAbides]

LOL

[TheDudeAbides]

But at least Kid A is probably town.

[The Dream Weaver]

VoteCount 1.3

Albert B. Rampage (2):

Dripping Goofball, randomidget

AlternateAccount (1):

TheDudeAbides

d3x (1):

killapenwin

dragonspawn (0):

Drake Crusader (0):

Dripping Goofball (1):

Albert B. Rampage

evilpacman18 (0):

firebound12(0):

Flubbernugget(3):

I Am Innocent, firebound12, Peacebringer

Garmr (0):

golden009 (0):

I Am Innocent (1):

dragonspawn

Kid A (0):

killapenwin(1):

d3x

Nero Cain (0):

Peacebringer (1):

Flubbernugget

randomidget (0):

TheDudeAbides (3):

Garmr, AlternateAccount, Kid A

YuniChikako (0):

Not Voting

- Drake Crusader, evilpacman18, golden009, Nero Cain, YuniChikako

With 19 alive it takes 10 to lynch.

Deadline is in (expired on 2015-01-23 13:00:00)

UNVOTE: firebound12

In the future, please don't put changes in votes in spoiler tags.

Seeking a replacement for golden009.

[evilpacman18]

Did we catch scum already? Huh. Good work team.
Judging by that VC, ABR is probably town too, which is fun.

[DrippingGoofball]

Did we catch scum already? Huh. Good work team.
Judging by that VC, ABR is probably town too, which is fun.

Explain that.

[Albert B. Rampage]

He owes you no explanation, scum.

Vote: TDA