Mini 1634 - English Premier League Mafia (Game over)

[Whiskers]

bus bus bus bus bus.

In short, death, should we lynch Elk and retreat back to our scumchat for the day?

[deathfisaro]

Are you more convinced that elk is scummier than Guyett + BBT combo? I mean, elk is still scummy but I don't think as much as the other two.

[BlueBloodedToffee]

@724 - Because your reads are wrong death.

I'm town.

Elk is scum. We should lynch him.

[deathfisaro]

GOOD explanation of the whole elk is scum argument that'll convince not only me but majority of the players please.
Whole game you and Guyett haven't backed up your votes.

[BlueBloodedToffee]

I'll get to this game properly as soon as I have time. It will probably be the weekend but I'll fully catch up.

[massive]

Kaboose compared to Ollie is a Kaboose town by a landslide and yet suddenly these 2 people can't see that Ollie is super scummy.
As Ollie gets close to a lynch, Ollie's outed buddy elk gets off the wagon.

You know, this is really interesting. You would expect the mindset of someone on the verge of being lynched to stay voting for the other train, even if it's just out of self-preservation.

Elk

-- why move off of Ollie in this instance? Was Guyett really that more suspicious to you? Your vote in 569 is pretty WIFOM, and doesn't reference any of the other reasons people put out for Guyett. And why haven't you revoted for him today?

[Whiskers]

Are you more convinced that elk is scummier than Guyett + BBT combo? I mean, elk is still scummy but I don't think as much as the other two.

Nope. problem is, BBT is still questionable-- I mean, unsure. It's not obvious. Elk is more-obviously scummy and until he's gone, it'll be more difficult to push a lynch on the subtler BBT. As for Guyett, he's out of commission. Sure we can lynch him today, tomorrow, at any time, but I'd like to be able to hold his feet to the fire right up until we do it, make sure he's got nothing we need,

then

lynch him. We just can't do that now.

I'll get to this game properly as soon as I have time. It will probably be the weekend but I'll fully catch up.

BAHAHAHA

HAA

, no! You've said this a lot, is it just your go-to excuse? What about all the posts you've been making, isn't that "getting to this game properly"? Man, try

again!

[Guyett]

UNVOTE:

[massive]

ETA: Since I see I already asked that question, and remember at the time you didn't want to lynch him since he was L-1 : Who else are you scumreading at this time?

[Guyett]

VOTE: ElkVOTE: Yiley
VOTE: BBTVOTE: Yiley
VOTE:

BBT

VOTE:

Elk

UNVOTE:

[BlueBloodedToffee]

No, I haven't gotten to this game properly. My thorough read through is still ~post 390.

So, yeah. When I got time I will catch up properly.

You'll see the difference.

[massive]

I think it's time for me to re-read too.

[theelkspeaks]

ETA: Since I see I already asked that question, and remember at the time you didn't want to lynch him since he was L-1 : Who else are you scumreading at this time?

I asked for the votecount to confirm he was no longer L-1 so that I could

vote: Guyett

.

I became generally unsatisfied with the case on Ollie and thus left his wagon. I thought it was fairly likely I was going to be lynched regardless, and figured I'd rather use what time I had left to push a lynch I thought had a higher chance of hitting scum (i.e. Guyett). Ollie's flip obviously confirms that he was scum, however.

I want to see a flip on Guyett, I think his behavior will be useful in finding scum once we know his alignment. I still haven't figured out how to make heads or tails of his rageposting and/or code, but if there's a code he's using to communicate, I can't figure out what he's trying to say. Can anyone figure out what his "voting half the living players in the same post in varying arrangments" might be him trying to say?

[Guyett]

VOTE: no lynch
VOTE: no lynch
VOTE: no lynch
VOTE: no lynch
VOTE: no lynch
VOTE: no lynch

VOTE: no lynch

VOTE: no lynch
VOTE: no lynch
VOTE: no lynch
VOTE: no lynch
VOTE: no lynch
VOTE: no lynch
VOTE: no lynch
VOTE: no lynch

VOTE: Elk

UNVOTE:

[Whiskers]

From what Guyett linked:
Voting no lynch a bunch of times in a row refers to a post number. Count the number of no lynch votes he makes. Like
no lynch
no lynch
no lynch

no lynch
no lynch
no lynch
no lynch

no lynch

is "341", because the first section has 3 no lynch votes, the second section has 4, and last section has 1. Then, Guyett comments on it by saying No Lynch or Lynch (though I don't remember which is which off the top of my head.)

Also one of the things is giving reads from Town to Scum.

I'm not sure what some of the posts are, though, like 734. I'm guessing his scumreads are BBT, Yiley, and Elk (actually, sounds about right via last page), and that he wants to lynch Yiley now...?

[Whiskers]

VOTE: no lynch
VOTE: no lynch
VOTE: no lynch
VOTE: no lynch
VOTE: no lynch
VOTE: no lynch

6

VOTE: no lynch

1

VOTE: no lynch
VOTE: no lynch
VOTE: no lynch
VOTE: no lynch
VOTE: no lynch
VOTE: no lynch
VOTE: no lynch
VOTE: no lynch

8

VOTE: Elk

UNVOTE:

618,
referring to Elk (as in, hey Elk, this is the answer)
Unvoting to keep the votecount in balance.

btw,

Unvote

[Guyett]

VOTE: no lynch

[Guyett]

VOTE: no lynch
VOTE: Guyett
VOTE: deathfisaro
VOTE: Red Arrow
VOTE: Whiskers
VOTE: no lynch
VOTE: no lynch
VOTE: massive
VOTE: BROseiden
VOTE: no lynch
VOTE: no lynch
VOTE: theelkspeaks
VOTE: BBT
VOTE: Yiley
VOTE: no lynch
VOTE: no lynch

[Whiskers]

VOTE: no lynch
VOTE: no lynch
VOTE: no lynch
VOTE: no lynch
VOTE: no lynch
VOTE: no lynch

VOTE: no lynch

VOTE: no lynch
VOTE: no lynch
VOTE: no lynch
VOTE: no lynch
VOTE: no lynch
VOTE: no lynch
VOTE: no lynch
VOTE: no lynch

VOTE: Elk

UNVOTE:

Just checked, by the way: when Guyett does a post number and then a No Lynch, it's good. Lynching a post means he thinks it's bad.

[BlueBloodedToffee]

You know what I actually cba catching up on like 350 posts.

Reads;

Town; Whiskers, Death

Null/leaning town; massive, RA

Null/leaning scum; Guyett, BRO

Scum; Elk, Yiley.

Although, if what everyone is saying is true and Ollie did go after Yiley hard, then Yiley might not be scum and I would replace him with BRO.

[Guyett]

VOTE: No Lynch
VOTE: No Lynch

VOTE: No Lynch
VOTE: No Lynch
VOTE: No Lynch
VOTE: No Lynch
VOTE: No Lynch
VOTE: No Lynch
VOTE: No Lynch
VOTE: No Lynch
VOTE: No Lynch

VOTE: No Lynch
VOTE: No Lynch
VOTE: No Lynch
VOTE: No Lynch
VOTE: No Lynch
VOTE: No Lynch
VOTE: No Lynch
VOTE: No Lynch
VOTE: No Lynch

[Guyett]

VOTE: No Lynch
VOTE: No Lynch
VOTE: No Lynch

VOTE: No Lynch
VOTE: No Lynch

VOTE: No Lynch
VOTE: No Lynch

VOTE: Bro

VOTE: No Lynch
VOTE: No Lynch

VOTE: No Lynch
VOTE: No Lynch
VOTE: No Lynch
VOTE: No Lynch
VOTE: No Lynch
VOTE: No Lynch
VOTE: No Lynch

VOTE: No Lynch
VOTE: No Lynch
VOTE: No Lynch
VOTE: No Lynch
VOTE: No Lynch
VOTE: No Lynch

[Guyett]

VOTE: No Lynch
VOTE: No Lynch
VOTE: No Lynch

VOTE: No Lynch
VOTE: No Lynch
VOTE: No Lynch

VOTE: No Lynch
VOTE: No Lynch
VOTE: No Lynch
VOTE: No Lynch
VOTE: No Lynch
VOTE: No Lynch
VOTE: No Lynch
VOTE: No Lynch
VOTE: No Lynch

[Guyett]

VOTE: No Lynch
VOTE: No Lynch
VOTE: No Lynch

VOTE: No Lynch
VOTE: No Lynch
VOTE: No Lynch
VOTE: No Lynch
VOTE: No Lynch
VOTE: No Lynch
VOTE: No Lynch

VOTE: No Lynch
VOTE: No Lynch
VOTE: No Lynch
VOTE: No Lynch
VOTE: No Lynch
VOTE: No Lynch

[Guyett]

VOTE: No Lynch
VOTE: No Lynch
VOTE: No Lynch
VOTE: No Lynch

VOTE:

VOTE: No Lynch
VOTE: No Lynch
VOTE: No Lynch
VOTE: No Lynch
VOTE: No Lynch