The entire premise of meta is to find subtle tells and nuisances that a player does without knowledge. As soon as a player is aware of these tells, they are useless because they can be exploited.
Handing us a game, and saying "Here, this is how I play as scum." is pointless. Anything he did in that game can be manipulated for this one, making reading the game a waste of time.
As a noob, I believe posting that posting his past game was null. That being said, I haven't read the game he posted, but I think I will do that later. I see that you can manipulate meta. I think that meta reading is pretty dumb in general. But I don't think that linking his past scum game makes him any more scummy. It can very, very easily be a noob town thing to do.
Jesus, arguing with you is making me think letter's might be town.
As for the rest, I accept your responses, but it doesn't change my opinion of you. Placing a vote on a day 1 lurker just seems like lazy scum to me, especially when you follow up the lurker vote to vote onto a strong wagon.
(hey, this mafia game thing is pretty fun. I wish I could play more than one game right now, haha! /offtopic)
