SMITE Role Madness Mafia (OVER AT LAST!)

[ooba]

How did you know what pantheon we were in?

I'm keep a slide of players\neighbourhoods. I don't have detailed notes for how I made each of the deductions/jumps. From memory:
- You weren't Egyptian because I am
- You weren't Greek because you replied to House saying you wanted to be in Olympus
- MS claimed Chinese and his two neighbours pretty early on D1
- Pegged {You\SW\Bitmap\xx} as Roman from the rest initially because "strongman with 2 kills" sounded liked Hercules and I'm pretty sure I spotted a Cupid thing from SW
- Reaffirmed when MS said 'Janus' after being Bitmap'd

Basically, assumed pantheon based on some breadcrumbs. Didn't spot anything that contradicted that info after that.

---

I'll be busy with some RL personal stuff for the next couple of days. Expect skimmed one liner replies. Right now - I still think FT is the best bet for scum (like adorkable in Capcom). But I'm no where as sure since FT's not as bad a adorkable. I think beast will be today's lynch and I'd rather we do this mislynch now than in D6. Probably never going to vote TD.

V\LA till 23rd

^pedit: @Cephrir: That's the second 'anti-morale' post from you. ('This game is really dense and kinda losing my interest a bit right now. I will probably get re-energized when the game stops feeling like slogging through liquid asphalt.') Whats wrong? It's not that bad.

[Cephrir]

I've been slowly getting back into the roll of current events but I still feel like a lot of my reads are ????

[Imperium]

Are xombie, zzzx, and mastin in the same neighborhood?

Okay, yes they are. I liked xombies reaction to the metal sonic fake claim, not finding anything I don't like in his ISO really. I've noted one thing in the neighborhood, but it's more a if x then y is possible thing, but that's not even that strong.

Xombie has been strongly defending mastin, I'm assuming based on something in the neighborhood, and vice versa. Mastin is calling his hood his masonry, so he's town reading all of them.

Xombie - I don't see you claiming a strong town read on zzzx. What is your read on him?

[Cephrir]

I'm keep a slide of players\neighbourhoods. I don't have detailed notes for how I made each of the deductions/jumps. From memory:
- You weren't Egyptian because I am
- You weren't Greek because you replied to House saying you wanted to be in Olympus
- MS claimed Chinese and his two neighbours pretty early on D1
- Pegged {You\SW\Bitmap\xx} as Roman from the rest initially because "strongman with 2 kills" sounded liked Hercules and I'm pretty sure I spotted a Cupid thing from SW
- Reaffirmed when MS said 'Janus' after being Bitmap'd

This post is pretty town. If ooba was scum, the true answer to how he knew the pantheons would be because he is scum. However, he was able to produce all of these things, none of which I really picked up on, 40 minutes after the question was asked. I believe this would take longer than 40 minutes to fabricate, and furthermore, I don't think scum would have seen reason to care about the pantheon issue enough to have something like this ready.

[Imperium]

Ooba - thanks, that makes sense.

[Cephrir]

Xombie - I don't see you claiming a strong town read on zzzx. What is your read on him?

I am also interested in the reverse of this.

[Cephrir]

none of which I really picked up on

Obviously I picked up on my own neighborhood and MS claiming Chinese. But the other things.

[Metal Sonic]

I'm keep a slide of players\neighbourhoods. I don't have detailed notes for how I made each of the deductions/jumps. From memory:
- You weren't Egyptian because I am
- You weren't Greek because you replied to House saying you wanted to be in Olympus
- MS claimed Chinese and his two neighbours pretty early on D1
- Pegged {You\SW\Bitmap\xx} as Roman from the rest initially because "strongman with 2 kills" sounded liked Hercules and I'm pretty sure I spotted a Cupid thing from SW
- Reaffirmed when MS said 'Janus' after being Bitmap'd

This post is pretty town. If ooba was scum, the true answer to how he knew the pantheons would be because he is scum. However, he was able to produce all of these things, none of which I really picked up on, 40 minutes after the question was asked. I believe this would take longer than 40 minutes to fabricate, and furthermore, I don't think scum would have seen reason to care about the pantheon issue enough to have something like this ready.

nitpick re " true answer to how he knew the pantheons would be because he is scum.": not necessarily. hoodmasonrys such as mine would not have scum, and thus scum still require deductive skills to determine the neighborhoods.


but I agree

that oobas posts are better recently.

i will take off the rose tinted glasses



also i plan to vig one of beast/td when i can

[Metal Sonic]

if we are lynching either.



i am leaning on a beast lynch. also, why has beast not posted recently

[Metal Sonic]

beastcharizard Jan 17, 04:12am Feb 13, 01:58pm 6 days 9 hours 58


he does not look very prodded

replace him then we grill the replacee

except scum have daytalk so this method may not be conclusive enough

[Imperium]

Beast logged in Monday night but hasn't posted anything on site since Saturday.

[Imperium]

What do you think fueled the last minute AP wagon?

My best guess is the pressure of impending deadline is what motivated most of the votes. The stuff you and Imperium posted previously most likely provided the original spark for the wagon.

pretty much i guess

What are you doing?
Who are you townreading?
Who are your primary scumreads?
What is your input on yesterday and today?

Seriously why do you play if you don't post anything?

I might not appear to be doing much but lets say stuff are getting interesting.

anyway my reads are not complete yet. but I feel ms is null/town . Mastin is prob town. and the rest should calm down and actually slow down thier posting lol.

If you only think mastin is prob town, what do you think of her treating your hood like a masonry and what's your read on xombie?

[Cephrir]

nitpick re " true answer to how he knew the pantheons would be because he is scum.": not necessarily. hoodmasonrys such as mine would not have scum, and thus scum still require deductive skills to determine the neighborhoods.

The deduction would be much easier, though.

[Imperium]

I'm keep a slide of players\neighbourhoods. I don't have detailed notes for how I made each of the deductions/jumps. From memory:
- You weren't Egyptian because I am
- You weren't Greek because you replied to House saying you wanted to be in Olympus
- MS claimed Chinese and his two neighbours pretty early on D1
- Pegged {You\SW\Bitmap\xx} as Roman from the rest initially because "strongman with 2 kills" sounded liked Hercules and I'm pretty sure I spotted a Cupid thing from SW
- Reaffirmed when MS said 'Janus' after being Bitmap'd

This post is pretty town. If ooba was scum, the true answer to how he knew the pantheons would be because he is scum. However, he was able to produce all of these things, none of which I really picked up on, 40 minutes after the question was asked. I believe this would take longer than 40 minutes to fabricate, and furthermore, I don't think scum would have seen reason to care about the pantheon issue enough to have something like this ready.

Yeah, I have a town read there anyway, though if I have time I'll check out a scum game to see if an indicator is there too. The question was mostly a stray thought with me thinking about scum in my neighborhood.

[Skybird]

beastcharizard Jan 17, 04:12am Feb 13, 01:58pm 6 days 9 hours 58


he does not look very prodded

replace him then we grill the replacee

except scum have daytalk so this method may not be conclusive enough

MS, how do you know scum have daytalk?

[Imperium]

Town (S->W): Solar Wind --> mastin2 --> Metal Sonic ----------------> vezokpiraka --> beastcharizard --------> TiphaineDeath --> ZZZX (based off of mastin) --> Cephrir -------------> FourTrouble -> Heartless -> Bitmap

Scum (S->W): Imperium -> TSO --> Ankamius --> Skybird --> RachMarie ------> ooba --> farside --> TheWayItEnds --> aceofspades --> xombie

UNVOTE: Ankamius
VOTE: Imperium

Leeeeeeet's talk about your reads list here.

1) you have mastin as town, fine. You're giving zzzx a town read based entirely off mastin, cool. Why do you then have xombie in your scum reads when mastin has also been calling xombie 100% town? You can't say it's because zzzx is doing more because that's objectively false.

2) I get your reasoning for twie and the unprompted admittance of the vote thief making him look good (I have a tin foil hat theory on that) but why do you think that his two predecessors didn't fess up to the stolen vote when house was raising a stink about it? Also you note that he has fluff while tso also has fluff but twie'so is more organic. Why the ambiguous reads that mean nothing! I mean hey I like stuff like organic, forced as much as the next person but please to be acting like you're reading the thread and not spitballing.

3) If you believe vezok saved cephrir from a nightkill, I don't believe he did, but if you believe he did, why is cephrir not higher on your reads list?

4) if you're basically reading tiphaine death and beast as town because they're lynchbait, why do you have rach and ankamius in your scum reads? Pretty sure rach has been v/la this day phase, so you're scum reading her for being v/la? (I also get that you think td's I blocked mastin is so town, but I have my own problems with that one, and if you think he's town from that how did you miss that we were trying to figure out if he was lying?)

5) how is bitmap town but rachmarie isn't?

[Xombie]

Xombie - I don't see you claiming a strong town read on zzzx. What is your read on him?

Town.

I was super worried about his slot due to some neighborhood things D1. But he's def town due to other things since. Just

really

hard to let go of reads once I have them in my gut/head, which is essentially why I try and find town first.

[Cephrir]

I don't think TD's block of mastin is particularly town, as someone who actually read mastin's posts yesterday.

[Imperium]

...... I think given how much people trust her and how much she was asking not to be targeted groupscum would find her the perfect choice to send out for a kill. And also, THERE WASN'T A GODDAMNED KILL!

I have a problem with this post.

[Cephrir]

Is it the fact that it confirms he actually did read mastin's posts yesterday?

[Imperium]

Is it the fact that it confirms he actually did read mastin's posts yesterday?

And by that point I do not believe he thought his roleblock on mastin stopped the kill.

[Cephrir]

Because he seemingly forgot, voted other wagons, and hasn't pushed it in the intervening 9 days?

[Imperium]

No. I mean at the moment when he said, "THERE WASNT A GODDAMNED KILL" I do not believe he thought his roleblock stopped the kill.

There's exactly one reason why he could have said that, but I'm just not sure either way.

He could be derp town? IDK

[Cephrir]

I don't follow.

[Imperium]

...... I think given how much people trust her and how much she was asking not to be targeted groupscum would find her the perfect choice to send out for a kill. And also, THERE WASN'T A GODDAMNED KILL!

I'd like your conclusion better if someone else already hadn't claimed to have blocked the kill.

This might point to derp town?

IDK