New York 181 -- Game Over

[Egg]

Ok then...

[Nikanor]

meh, silver was always probtown.
house too.
ika why do you think that klingon cannot be mafia?

[Nikanor]

shiro might be scum.

[davesaz]

Is anybody following nik vs. garmr right now because I really can't right now.

Nice "information" but do you draw any conclusions from it? If not, why mention it?

To see if anyone can relate to the struggle I'm having with it and bring out my opinion that the format of the discussion is anti-town.

I skimmed a double ISO, did not stop to take notes. I find it odd that a high percentage of Garmr posts are either about Nik or replies to him. The percentage is lower for Nik posts about/to Garmr. It's also interesting that the context of a lot of the discussion is a 3rd party. I don't think it generated much in the way of solid reads, or advanced game state much. It puts both of them on the scum side of null.

What do you think about the motivation for the conversation? Setting aside the content which is difficult to follow, does one or both look scummy on motivation?

[davesaz]

I am still on V/LA until the 29th.

Umm, the next 29th would be in March, given it's not a leap year.

[SilverWolf]

V/LA

Until the 29th.

Thanks mod.

Please change this to March 1st. Thanks!!

[SilverWolf]

I am still on V/LA until the 29th.

Umm, the next 29th would be in March, given it's not a leap year.

That explains why the system kept saying it was invalid.

LOL

[Aneninen]

Nevermind then.
Explain why you are not scum.

Nevermind then.
Explain why you are not scum.

No, You explain why I am.

no backsies

DeltaWave's logic is pigeon poop here.

hello are you guys just going to ignore my post on nik?

No and I think he's scummy, so give examples about him playing a game of survival, please!

Other than most of the things I said about being reactionary game being mostly responses with very little of her own initiative. When things are done off her own accord she discredits them as bitching or they have very little impact in the first place.(Wakes so called walls for example.) She's playing a very safe and flexible scum game.

Note to self: examine Nikanoor's forthcoming posts thoroughly while I'm catching-up.

...

Dragonspawn.

Intentional fluffing started in 58. ISO him so as to find that despite he has 20 posts he has done nothing.

Scummy.

...

I've done quite a bit. I've gotten conversation started.
Then I took a day off. What exactly were you expecting?

I was talking about your posts, not about the absense of your posts because of your day-off.

[Aneninen]

garmr is really good at saying "i fundamentally disagree with the way you play mafia and i think you're scum for it" in incredibly circuitous ways.
me breaking it down into lines is the only way to show people that he's full of shit.

And Gammrn's Day1-gameplay was entirely different in another Large game where he was scum.

inadequate != incorrect bby

inadequate leaves room for error

, if i ask for a bright red room and you give me paint that is slightly too dull, you are inadequate but not incorrect.
but

i was just joking anyway, the difference between the two words is insignificant

.
but while we're on the subject of jokes, the fact that you've had to go back to "but other ppl agree w meeee" for a second time now is kinda hilarious.

Eigh, I wonder whether Garmmrn would talk about these posts later.

inadequate leaves room for error, if i ask for a bright red room and you give me paint that is slightly too dull, you are inadequate but not incorrect.
but i was just joking anyway, the difference between the two words is insignificant.
but while we're on the subject of jokes, the fact that you've had to go back to "but other ppl agree w meeee" for a second time now is kinda hilarious.

It doesn't matter if your right or wrong on Texcat as town you would need a good reason to town read someone. You town read Texcat and when asked on the reasoning you gave fluff aka she's funny and confident.
Also talking about jokes trying to use word play to disregard my scum read because you got caught red handed is pretty funny.

Also all your reads seem improvised nik. This isn't a town trait.

ik i'm kind of a clownfuck

The more I read this interaction the more I like Garmmrn's posts and the less I like Nikanor's posts.

[Flubbernugget]

Is anybody following nik vs. garmr right now because I really can't right now.

Nice "information" but do you draw any conclusions from it? If not, why mention it?

To see if anyone can relate to the struggle I'm having with it and bring out my opinion that the format of the discussion is anti-town.

I skimmed a double ISO, did not stop to take notes. I find it odd that a high percentage of Garmr posts are either about Nik or replies to him. The percentage is lower for Nik posts about/to Garmr. It's also interesting that the context of a lot of the discussion is a 3rd party. I don't think it generated much in the way of solid reads, or advanced game state much. It puts both of them on the scum side of null.

What do you think about the motivation for the conversation? Setting aside the content which is difficult to follow, does one or both look scummy on motivation?

Because I've used to same tactic as scum to stall a case on me, I'm personally biased to say that's what's happening here but have no actual context to apply that assumption to.

Nothing pings me as scum on garmr and the best read I have on nikanor right now is "would wagon."

[Flubbernugget]

SW do you still have intent to replace out?

[Aneninen]

Note to self: stopped catching up on Page20, post 475.

[ika]

meh, silver was always probtown.
house too.
ika why do you think that klingon cannot be mafia?

631

also her defense of "you know how i play as sk" (hint for kling: that was MM not sk) is eerily similar. where she just kinda talks about random stuff and doesnt really solve the game

[dragonspawn]

Egg, thanks for the Garmr iso but I have no idea how you took the exact opposite thing that I did from each of his posts.
dragon's posting is getting worse and worse. ik nobody is gonna lynch garmr with me today but it's getting tougher and tougher to decide whether i wanna change over to ika, davesaz or dragonspawn.

How am I getting worse? Does me asking questions make you uncomfortable? If so. Why?

[dragonspawn]

Seriously considering switching my vote to Wake.

and a whole nothing is why my vote stays on you.

oh shit I'm so scared

I have that effect on people. But they generally have nothing to fear.

[dragonspawn]

idgaf about the Sk right now

I'm guessing one of the people obsessed with talking about it has that role.

I disagree. I think it's more likely to be the scum who are thinking about the sk. That way the can pretend to scum hunt without doing so.

It's a reason Dave is now on my radar and why I was encouraging responses to ika. It's also why I adjusted my unread to slight town instead of full town. I'm not willing to say he is scum because I've seen ika play scum and this is different. But I'm not ruling it out completely

[dragonspawn]

wolf is town.

[Nikanor]

meh, silver was always probtown.
house too.
ika why do you think that klingon cannot be mafia?

631

also her defense of "you know how i play as sk" (hint for kling: that was MM not sk) is eerily similar. where she just kinda talks about random stuff and doesnt really solve the game

if 631 excludes her from being mafia then it should exclude her from being sk as well, since the first setup she suggests does not include an sk. do you disagree?

[ika]

meh, silver was always probtown.
house too.
ika why do you think that klingon cannot be mafia?

631

also her defense of "you know how i play as sk" (hint for kling: that was MM not sk) is eerily similar. where she just kinda talks about random stuff and doesnt really solve the game

if 631 excludes her from being mafia then it should exclude her from being sk as well, since the first setup she suggests does not include an sk. do you disagree?

thats besides the point? im not judging her on "well heres the setups that can happen"

im basing it on how she went about the sk. i dont really get your angle

[ika]

lets try a diffrent approach nik: are you town reading her or scum reading her and why?
addon: if your reading her as scum what scum is she (mafia or sk)

[House]

meh, silver was always probtown.
house too.
ika why do you think that klingon cannot be mafia?

631

also her defense of "you know how i play as sk" (hint for kling: that was MM not sk) is eerily similar. where she just kinda talks about random stuff and doesnt really solve the game

Scum can also setup derp, I've done it in the past as SK.

Why are you discounting the fact that she can be SK?

[ika]

meh, silver was always probtown.
house too.
ika why do you think that klingon cannot be mafia?

631

also her defense of "you know how i play as sk" (hint for kling: that was MM not sk) is eerily similar. where she just kinda talks about random stuff and doesnt really solve the game

Scum can also setup derp, I've done it in the past as SK.

Why are you discounting the fact that she can be SK?

im not? im actually suspecting her to be the sk. i said shes prob not mafia

[ika]

house can you cop garmr tonight if i protect you?

[House]

VOTE: KlingonCelt

Here there be scum.

[House]

house can you cop garmr tonight if i protect you?

wtf dude.