Zar is pretty low-content overall, but I find the pushes he's made make a lot of sense, and I feel his reads and votes in general mean that he doesn't make sense as scum unless he's scum with GreyICE. Grey makes sense as town because he's been pursuing a lot of different angles, his play makes sense overall, reasoning has been consistently fairly solid. I didn't like Grey playing the terrorist game with me recently, although I'm not sure that's particularly alignment indicative.
I don't really understand your scumread on metal, even a little bit. The best people have been able to come up with against him is "inconsistent", which is pretty crap. I feel Metal's pushes and posts this game have consistently been very genuine: I don't think he says shit like "I'm the most influential player in the game" if scum, I don't think is as patient in selling the paranoia of me as scum, his push on GreyICE even follows his tendency to irrationally scumread aggressive players when town, which is something I don't think he's aware of. His trust and relationship with ABR also makes him look pretty town, as does him being uncomfortable with ZZZX and wgeurts.
In post 1796, pirate mollie wrote:sotty yeah, ooba mebbe, it is taking him forever to post but cld you plz in a tl;dr fashion explain the kagami case? I never understood it when I was trying to keep up with the game. I feel like grey in this particular instance wld be a bigger point for you to draw from but somehow you are missing it.
I am missing the point of how Grey is so scummy in particular. I don't like that Kagami's hinged her entire game on Grey being scum because it seems like a dumb risk to make if Kagami is town. I don't think her case on Grey is very strong or convincing at the end of the day.
"Playing with Nacho is like playing with a religious conservative." ~UncertainKitten
-- Fate, Vanilla Townie, was brutally stabbed by a throwing sword in endgame.