New York 181 -- Game Over

[4nxi3ty]

dragonspawn - 2 - ika, pisskop

AngryPidgeon - 1 - AngryPidgeon
ika - 1 - Albert B. Rampage
Flubbernugget - 1 - Egg
pisskop - 1 - Aneninen
Albert B. Rampage - 1 - texcat


Not Voting: A Royal Saint, dragonspawn, Flubbernugget, DeltaWave

With 11 alive, it takes 6 to lynch.

Deadline: (expired on 2015-05-03 15:32:04)

V/LA:

[Albert B. Rampage]

First the vote for the doc and now a vote for the cop.

Cop who doesn't say who's guilty and who's innocent?

[ika]

First the vote for the doc and now a vote for the cop.

Cop who doesn't say who's guilty and who's innocent?

you were pushing doc yesterday?
i am wanting to leave all the info on the table for end day
nobody CC me yet?

like do you see the flaws right now?

[Albert B. Rampage]

OK - I'll give you a chance for my vote to change. Who did you investigate on each night and what was the result?

[ika]

http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.ph ... er_sort=Go

you can read, i already told. im going to be dick on my final day to anyone who wants to be lazy

[dragonspawn]

Wait, you weren't being a dick before?

[ika]

Wait, you weren't being a dick before?

im being a bigger dick then usal to people who want em to do shit.

my belief is that confirmed towns should be dicks and bystanders in most dicussion only setpping in when needed cus its very easy for sucms to jsut go "i agree" or mirror what i am looking for what im looking for is independent thought

[Albert B. Rampage]

My vote stays then.

[AngryPidgeon]

AP, im going to eb frank, pick read and stick with them. your constant change is honesly becoming more of a nucance if anything. I personalyl think your town but right now i want stances to be more hard set

I have barely changed my reads at all in the past game Day, especially considering this is me and not some random person. So, really Ika?

I even clarified that I don't think ARS is scum. And the titus kill is NEW information that COULD suggest that. So kindly shove off.

UNVOTE:

[DeltaWave]

P dodge, will post tonight

[Aneninen]

(1) Anen, Wake could have posted that stuff just to have it analyzed post flip and have us completely wrong. He's a smart guy and knew he was dead so I wouldn't rule it out. Basically, it's a null point.
(2) I don't know Royal's meta either. Which is why assuming she busses is dumb.
(3) Yes, Titus said earlier that SK can't look too town or they get NK'd. I thought that was where you got that idea. If it's original, it just means you weren't reading Titus's posts.
(4) Pisskop has been a town read for me for most of the game. People were all over King for the so called SK slip and some of the scum (Drixx and Wake if I'm remembering correctly but maybe just Drixx) seemed to legitimately believe she was SK. I mean, maybe pisskop is SK but a lot of his frustration in this game feels real. Like he really wants a town win. But at the very least, I think you're wrong by putting him in your mafia pool. And I actually took King's comments about SK play as a non-SK tell which, to me, rules out pisskop as anything but town. Of course I'm open to the possibility that I'm wrong but that's my read on him right now.

(1) Could be, but his Twilight still felt genuine for me.
(2) Isn't (s)he a Mathblade alt? I haven't played with Mathblade either, though. I don't understand your logic here.
(3) Now, when you've mentioned it, I remember her posting that. To tell the truth, I didn't remember because (1) I'm in other games too and (2, and this is more important) Titus hadn't been in among my townreads before he fake-claimed Doc Twilight (partly because of Meta, partly because of her VCA, which seemed to be faked for me), so I took everything she posted with a grain of salt.
(4) Could you show examples about Pisskop wanting a town win hard? Also, Klingonette's play was very different from her town meta I know.

First the vote for the doc and now a vote for the cop.

Cop who doesn't say who's guilty and who's innocent?

Cut it out, Rampage!
I'm asking you once more: could you give us a read list?

I even clarified that I don't think ARS is scum. And the titus kill is NEW information that COULD suggest that. So kindly shove off.

Who's scum, Pidgeon?

[Egg]

Anen, I lost my post and I'm not going through pisskop's entire ISO again. But see his push against Wake towards the end. He was genuinely upset that people were using RL to town read Wake. And on Royal, my point is that you said she'd have bussed Wake if she was scum. Neither you or I have meta to back that or dispute it.m so where is that coming from? It sounds like an assumption you made, and a very weird one.

[ika]

Anen, I lost my post and I'm not going through pisskop's entire ISO again. But see his push against Wake towards the end. He was genuinely upset that people were using RL to town read Wake. And on Royal, my point is that you said she'd have bussed Wake if she was scum. Neither you or I have meta to back that or dispute it.m so where is that coming from? It sounds like an assumption you made, and a very weird one.

Inter-question:

Do you think ARS could be sk if you believe she does not bus? (hint i modded a game where she bussed but they were a doomed slot)

[Egg]

I have no idea if she busses or not.

But yes, she could be SK.

[AngryPidgeon]

I could get behind a flubber wagon I guess.

Egg and Anen look really town.

ABR is useless beyond belief but I don't think that is scummy necessarily. Town I guess.

actually don't think ARS would kill titus as sk after some thought. Not going to lynch ars today.

Delta has fallen off my radar a little bit. Still town on him but wouldn't bet anything on that read right now.

[Egg]

Why wouldn't Royal kill Titus?

[dragonspawn]

Seems kind of set uppy to me. I mean SK kills Titus cause her and ars are fighting so lets lynch ars.

where is she anyway I haven't seen her post in a long while

[AngryPidgeon]

Why wouldn't Royal kill Titus?

I think she knows it would make people suspicious of her.

So its kind of WIFOMy.

[Egg]

Fair, but not sure I agree.

[Aneninen]

Anen, I lost my post and I'm not going through pisskop's entire ISO again. But see his push against Wake towards the end. He was genuinely upset that people were using RL to town read Wake.

This leads back to the original assumption. If Wake's Twilight was genuine, the profile I made fits Pisskop. (If not, it's pigeon poop, yes.)

I could get behind a flubber wagon I guess.
Delta has fallen off my radar a little bit. Still town on him but wouldn't bet anything on that read right now.

Flubber is not the worst lynch after all.
I'd see some new content from Delta.

Seems kind of set uppy to me. I mean SK kills Titus cause her and ars are fighting so lets lynch ars.

I can't see a correlation there.
Titus was an obvious kill from the SK. Her Twilight fake-claim made her obv-town and in case of telling the truth, it would have been even better.

[Albert B. Rampage]

I have no clue who the scum is. All my scumreads claimed PR and/or died.

[Flubbernugget]

VOTE: abr

His reaction to Titus's push was disproportionate to the rest of his posting style this game. Titus was pushing him based on perceived softing from freeko, who died that night, and look at who's dead today

[Flubbernugget]

Also I don't understand AP's self-vote

[Albert B. Rampage]

It's true ^

All those who suspected me mysteriously disappeared. Can't deny that.

[DeltaWave]

Let's take out AP today.